Hearted Youtube comments on Veritasium (@veritasium) channel.
-
12000
-
12000
-
12000
-
11000
-
11000
-
11000
-
11000
-
11000
-
11000
-
10000
-
10000
-
10000
-
10000
-
10000
-
10000
-
10000
-
10000
-
10000
-
10000
-
10000
-
10000
-
9900
-
9700
-
9300
-
9100
-
8100
-
8100
-
8000
-
7900
-
7900
-
7800
-
7700
-
7700
-
7500
-
7500
-
7400
-
7300
-
7300
-
7300
-
7300
-
7300
-
7200
-
7100
-
6800
-
6700
-
6600
-
6600
-
Fantastic revisit! The animations and the simulations were spot-on, and great at showing the difference between the transient “first-second” effect, and the steady-state “rest of time” behavior. The whole “expanding loop of current” thing is a great way to phrase it, because after that poynting loop expands to match the actual physical loop of wire, then stuff starts to behave normally and all of the power is transmitted around the loop very close to the wire.
I still hold that for this simple circuit, turning on a lightbulb with wires much smaller around than they are long, the effect of surface charge vs internal charge is negligible, so you can ignore any skin-effect stuff and say that “mobile” electrons are indeed pushing on other “mobile” electrons using their fields, but I totally agree that that’s a simplification, just a simplification that makes the intuition a lot easier.
I also need to do some math about how far the average “electron” is displaced in order to build the initial charge distribution around some typical circuit elements - axial flow is the only way I understand those charge distributions getting built, and this whole endeavor has made me think hard about what that means. Someday when I think I understand it better I’ll edit up my pt.2 response video - thanks for the shoutout! I’ve got a great experiment in the works to show the “expanding poynting loop” 😁
6600
-
6500
-
6300