General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About

Curt Gevert
Democracy Now!
comments

Comments by "Curt Gevert" (@curtgevert5664) on "Report from Beirut: Israel Is "Targeting Everyone" in Bombing Campaign, Killing 700+ in Just Days" video.

Prior to Oct 7, 2023, show me how many Israeli soldiers were in Gaza?
8
from what?
5
why?
4
how so?
3
If you're gonna assign POW status to every Israeli citizen, then where are the Red Cross inspections of POW camps where Israelis are being held? Where are the letters POWs have the right to write to relatives? to name a few rights POWs have a right to.
2
@novuspatriarch no you didn't, you're just saying slogans and using circular reasoning. Racism doesn't exist if you can't cite specific examples of it. My unanswered question remains, cite a specific law in Israel that has unequal treatment based on ethnic groups. You can't even answer that simple question, except by citing more slogans. Take a peak at Israels Penal Law, it's online, anybody can go to the laws and cite the laws and instances where the law is not being applied properly. It is not hard to do.
2
Why??
2
Aug 15th 2024, India's independence day, doesn't answer the question
2
@novuspatriarch Yes, it was the arabs that invaded Israel, not the other way around.
1
@novuspatriarch circular reasoning
1
At the end of WW2 Breslau and Stettin were awarded to Poland. Those places were not 'stolen' by Poland
1
@novuspatriarch I was citing international precedent
1
@novuspatriarch Israel can't steal what internationally belongs to them
1
@novuspatriarch Arabs were offered a state in 1948, they refused, in the 1960s they were offered a state they refused, they were offered a state in the 80s and 90s they refused, in 2008 they were offered a state they refused. They don't want a state
1
@novuspatriarch no they're similar.
1
@novuspatriarch when the State of Israel was proclaimed in 1948, it was the Arabs that started the war and kept it going
1
@novuspatriarch next, instead of being a lemming, explain the territorial boundaries that Israel supposedly stole.
1
@novuspatriarch I try identifying the many different times that arabs were offered a state and they refused, but the censors don't want you knowing that.
1
@novuspatriarch No, the area was known as British Mandate Palestine, it was awarded to the UK after winning the war against the Ottoman Empire. The Balfour Declaration would have given what is now Israel, Gaza, West Bank, and Jordan to the future Jewish state.
1
@novuspatriarch there is precedent in international law, in 1919 the Danzig corridor and Posen were awarded to Poland at the end of WW1.
1
@novuspatriarch Explain Israeli arabs. No pro-hamas terrorist can
1
@novuspatriarch the Israeli Arabs I know paint a completely different picture than what your saying. They are very happy and prosperous
1
@novuspatriarch the Israeli Arabs I know say differently
1
@novuspatriarch also, Israeli Arabs sit on the Israeli Supreme Court, hardly second class citizens
1
@novuspatriarch ???
1
@novuspatriarch if they were so unhappy, why did they stay living in Israel for 3 generations instead of moving to some Arab utopia?
1
@novuspatriarch Israel took Sinai and gave it back, look up the Camp David Accords. Israel got peace that has held for a long time
1
Why are Israeli Arabs serving in the IDF?
1
Sounds like you're the one full of it
1
@novuspatriarch dodging the questions I put forward
1
@novuspatriarch ok, if Israel is such a racist country, why are several judges Arabs? Telling me you answered the question already, when you haven't is no answer.
1
@novuspatriarch America is not a racist country nor is Israel
1
@novuspatriarch next cite one law on the books in israel that proves your point
1
@novuspatriarch it needs to be codified in a specific law book, with a specific code number, or it doesn't exist
1
@novuspatriarch you're pulling it outta your rear, since you can't cite a specific law on the books
1
@novuspatriarch your fantasy is not law. For example, Assault on Police Officers is governed by Israel Penal Law 5737-1977. Where is your claimed racist law written down?
1
@novuspatriarch no answer
1
@novuspatriarch ok cite the specific incident where laws in Israel are enforced differently.
1
@novuspatriarch Independence Day in India
1
@novuspatriarch I did that's how I found independence day in India. You cite a date as evidence, August 15th is also the Ides of August. Without any context, a date alone means nothing.
1
@novuspatriarch circular reasoning, no answers to direct questions, typical lemming
1
Why are there Arab judges in israel?
1
@novuspatriarch circular reasoning, no wonder you're a confused mess.
1
"just look at what I said" even though you've said nothing.
1
@novuspatriarch basic logic requires that you answer the question, without referring to other responses.
1
@novuspatriarch when you lose land in a war, you don't get to claim that land was 'stolen' at the end of that war.
1
@novuspatriarch Israel disengaged from Gaza and prior to Oct 2023 there were NO Israelis anywhere in the Gaza strip, so what lands were stolen?
1
@CrimeEnjoyer Jordan has accepted a jewish state and Israel and Jordan are at peace. Egypt has accepted a jewish state and they are at peace. They both live side by side in peace. They may not like each other, but they are at peace. That's how Israel rolls.
1
@CrimeEnjoyer Why, show me where Hezbollah or Hamas accepted the jewish state
1
The headline is exaggerating, they're only targeting Hezbollah, these cowards routinely hide in civilian areas.
1
@novuspatriarch identify which lands? During those wars Egypt lost Sinai and Jordan lost the west bank. Egypt and Jordan renounced claims to Gaza and West Bank when they made peace with Israel
1
@novuspatriarch No, it was a war brought on by the arabs attacking Israel after it declared independence. The arabs lost the 1948 war, losers don't get to dictate terms to the winners, it's the other way around.
1