General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
Kameraden
TIKhistory
comments
Comments by "Kameraden" (@Alte.Kameraden) on "The REAL reason Hitler killed Ernst Röhm in the Night of the Long Knives" video.
1:02:26 my god, I just told someone that the yesterday. That Marxism doesn't hold a Monopoly on the word Socialism. He accurately said Utopian Socialism and Marxist Socialism are not the same thing but then kept acting like Marxist Socialism was "Real" Socialism and kept describing Marxism and kept using the word Socialism instead. He couldn't get it through his skull that Socialism as a "Trunk" of the Tree, Marxism is just one branch of it, and rejected any other example of Socialism, so dismissed examples I presented. I told him Marxist do not hold a monopoly on the word, never have, and even at the time of Marx many Socialist were not Marxist Socialist, heck some Anarcho-Socialist even despised Marxist Socialism. I even an example of Oswald Spengler's Preussentum und Sozialismus and Ishay Landa's essay critique of Spengler. Every single example that Landa uses to claim Spengler wasn't a socialist only proved he wasn't a Marxist Socialist which Spengler would totally agree with Landa on. But being Landa seemed to think Marxism was Socialism itself, not that Marxism was just a form of Socialism Landa absolutely fails at proving Spengler wasn't a Socialist. I told the person in that in fact the Nazi's abolishment of Private Property Rights, the formation of the DAF among other examples are why Spengler even later called Hitler and the Nazis Bolsheviks in disguise.
10
sydmccreath4554 Golly, I didn't proof read. That being said, I see only two places worthy of a complaint.
2
11:35 is an image that most socialist can not even grasp. Even people like Animarchy on youtube reject the idea of socialism being anything but 'their' idea of socialism. Ignoring the fact that Socialism is the Tree Trunk, and everything else is branching off it.
1