General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
Jack Mac
Celtic History Decoded
comments
Comments by "Jack Mac" (@TheEggmaniac) on "Indo-European DNA: The Genetic Migration of Indo-Europeans…" video.
'Aryan' is a very outdated term which was used by the Nazis. It was connected to racial categorisation. It originally referred to people who were Indo- Iranian. There was no invasion of Europe by Aryans or Indo Europeans. There were constant waves of migration of Indo European people into central and western Europe. The places they moved into were wilderness and relatively empty of people. Though its possible they killed males of the original inhabitants they came across, and took the women into their tribe.
10
@19ate4 I dont have hate for anyone, Im not sure how you come to that conclusion. The term Aryan,' which I think you equate with Indo European, or even white Europeans, is no longer considered relevant or accurate in a discussion about movements of ancient people into Europe. Historians do not use the term Ayran to describe people who moved into Europe after the last ice age. They havent for a long time. You can call yourself what you want. I dont care. Who are 'we? by the way.' And what has the star of David and Jews got to do with anything, that this video is about? You seem confused.
3
@АнтонПавлов-ц4з Im not sure why you are posting that statement. What is the relevance of this to the video, or my comments? Its an ancient Indo European symbol used by many cultures. Its meaning and use varies in different cultures. The term 'Aryan' is no longer used by academics, as it has been misused and corrupted by Nazi Germany in the past. As was the swastika symbol, which the Nazis used to mean racial purity. Indo - European is the term used today to describe people originating thought to have originated somewhere in the north Indian sub continent.
3
@АнтонПавлов-ц4з So ? It doesnt mean it comes from Aryan, if thats what your getting at. It has various meanings. I believ one is lioness and another noble, amongst others.
1
@АнтонПавлов-ц4з I may also mean that, it doesnt nessarily have anything to with Aryan. You ve found a place name that has the first 2 letters the same. Proves nothing.
1
@АнтонПавлов-ц4з Arizona is ancient name given to the state by the original native Americans, it comes from 'alĭ ṣonak,' meaning 'small spring.' Arawa is ancient place in New Zealand meaning place of canoes. They both start with 'Ar' but obviously have nothing to do with Aryan. I mean you need to have more than a few letters in name, to prove its got anything to do with Aryan.
1
@АнтонПавлов-ц4з There is no definite evidence that the original source of the swastika was with any people called Arian. Just about every where was conquered by someone. Just because a name has few letters in common with a place, is not proof enough of any connection. I dont know what youre banging on about.
1
@АнтонПавлов-ц4з Ok answer to your question, it would be the country youre living in. If you were British or American, and you lived in France, then your country would be France. Perhaps you mean what is youre home country, or what country would you be from? People with British or American citizenship and passports, can live in countries other than Britain or America. Youre not really making much sense. Why dont you get to your point dude? if you have one. So far you have said there is place called Aria, in Greece. Which I think you assume is called that, because it was formed by Aryans. Though you show no evidence of this. Also you have mentioned the Aryans used a swastika symbol. Though not sure what the relevance of this is, as other cultures have used it too, including the Nazis.
1
@АнтонПавлов-ц4з Hey bud I really dont know what point youre trying to make. I was just trying summarise what you had posted. I didnt say Aria had anything to do with the Greeks or Nazis. But youre not really making any sense.
1