Comments by "Rutvik" (@rutvikrs) on "6 tunnels, rail bridges u0026 more: Modi govt’s Himalayan infra push u0026 what it means for Kashmir, Ladakh" video.

 @ed5928 people forget that Modi's most cogent critics are ones to the right of his government. Be it market oriented or civilizationally oriented.
12
@akshaytakkar6747 and education is of no use without complex demand that industries demand, not people. Just do an MS in electrical, mechanical, instrumentation or material science from IIT and see the job prospects. (They all join IT jobs while these are some of the hottest fields abroad.) Focus on education is producing a class of people who cannot be used for our economy filled with low avg productivity and simple demand. The stuff you are saying worked in the 80's not today. The Taiwanese/Korean/Chinese industrial worker and today the Bangladeshi woman textile worker are showing us the path.
10
 @NigamMehta the last bit. Yeah.
8
Land, labour and judiciary first. Education will take care of itself.
7
@akshaytakkar6747 we are already producing mid and high level employees. What we need is low end manufacturing that adds 200-400M jobs. For that we need to attract businesses like china did with land, labour and judicial reforms. We already have a diaspora of 150 million who are the upper crust of the western society, even if 2% of them return, that adds 3 million entrepreneurs with use cases in the market. Again, AI and Automation means nothing without complex demand. You might have seen how many kids in the west are already at market level without education while the median worker in India is not ready even with things as simple as working in a team. This is the end product of living in an industrial society. Hand a 3D printer to a kid in the most privileged primary school in India and an average upper class kid in the developed world and see the difference.
7
"Kare toh kare kya, bole toh bole kya"- opposition
6
@JohnSmith-vn8dm and that sub par analysis by Haqqani is a demonstration that the sub continent has not produced a single noteworthy Left, right, center or Neo political thought on the global stage. As for the Chinese, anyone with a cursory knowledge knows the shift between Guo Morou to Dengist -methodology-(edit: historiography). There would be no modern China without the vision provided by the KMT.
5
 @sumitsharma4426 he can't. He is from the school of thought that infrastructure builds itself. 😂
5
@arunk.7708 this reminds me of Pappu senior having the opportunity to revive SCL. As usual, we made the mistake of bypassing it instead of working on reliable supply chains and East Asia jumped on the opportunity. The stuff you are talking about came at a massive cost with a lack of scale. Modi government too is missing in action when it comes to technology transfer but we have improved significantly.
5
@akshaytakkar6747 I am not asking for a defunding in education or no reforms. I am just saying that it cannot be a leading investment. The issue is that we have mistakenly conflated education with the miracle of the Indian service sector. Our services are not end-to-end and that is why you won't find a single Indian IP. We are picking up the odd jobs of the Western market and that domain specificity is mistaken as an end product of good education. An Indian example, Dabur has a product range, understanding of production and supply chains, 50 years of data and trendline for the Indian/diaspora market and brand value. They are primed to open a service business in Ayurvedic healthcare. The Estonian who builds the backend for service business (as an analogy for our current service sector worker) cannot be mistaken to have an understanding of the Ayurvedic service sector. But we do that error. This is why Chinese have been able to build native yet global software based companies like Tencent.
4
You can't do things that way.
3