Comments by "Rutvik" (@rutvikrs) on "12 themes for 2024 from Modi no-confidence motion Lok Sabha speech, 6 positive u0026 6 negative" video.

When he talks, they run. What kind of opposition is this?
154
@rakiniprem it's still their duty to listen and debate. Walking away meant they had something better to do. How was the time utilised?
15
@n______n26 he was working? 🤔
6
@rakiniprem the topic and current issue is the no confidence motion and no riot was solved by a parliament discussion. Free access to the parliament digital library is available for everyone, show me a single instance of a PM discussing plans to solve a riot. This simply isn't the forum. Too bad you don't understand how our democracy works.
2
@markonikof Debate is qualified by addressing the thesis not by presence. which specific question raised by the opposition went unanswered?
2
@HunterSailo so did matrilineal Kerala and coastal Karnataka, the states changed our societies into patriarchal for the sake of governance. We did just fine. In my book, the "way of life" argument has reached its limits when people in the region accepted modernity and even Christianity. Just to be clear, this isn't "mainlander racism" seeking to exclude or stereotype you, it's a callout that social stratification along clans is not sustainable. Your education will not be useful till tribal and feudal politics perpetuate victimhood. It prevents trade between three emerging clusters, India, ASEAN and China that you stand to benefit from.
1
@HunterSailo 50-60 million
1
@HunterSailo I know the point. Partial loss of identity is a price every society has paid for economic and social progress. Making peace with it has led to access to higher political and social capital by linking to larger sets of identity. This was true for Germans and Italians in the 18-19th century and just as true for South India post independence. We benefited from access to resources from central India and industrialised. It's not like states and communities here don't have historical rivalries. If Karnataka was an independent nation state we would be fighting wars with Tamilnadu over water and Maharashtra for the Belgaum district. Same applies for every state in India. I am not contesting that Congress, and now the BJP have mismanaged the situation at some level. What is making it worse are the community level narratives. There is no focus on increasing the size of the pie just fighting over a larger share. The solution is muting parts of identity like land, laws and genetics. Play up other parts of identity like cuisine, music, philosophy, sports, etc to maintain distinction. Every developed society has done that and reaped its benefits.
1
@HunterSailo I can equally say the same thing about Bengaluru and a Mumbaikar will say the same about his city. Filled with outsiders. Does that mean Marathis or Kannadigas have lost their identity? If anything it has put an economic filter and we found areas of specialisation, software and finance where we are represented well. The same thing will happen in your states too after a period of market correction. If your response is that your state is too small or poor, look at Goans who maintain distinction from both giant neighbours while integrated with both. Neither the Indian state nor the Indian population wants to obliterate identities, we take inordinate pride in diversity. Even if outsiders take all of your land, the average Indian will stand up for your right to keep a percentage(50+%) of land in native ownership, examples in Himachal Pradesh and Ladakh.
1
@HunterSailo that is the legal term for people crossing borders from Myanmar which has undeniably happened. it applies to Bangladeshis, Sri Lankans, Pakistani Punjabis and Nepalis who crossed without documents. The American discourse uses the term "aliens", doesn't mean Mexicans or Syrians are landing in UFOs. If the intent was to treat you as third class citizens, then people would be put into labour camps and value would be extracted. Instead money is being spent to improve. Do a simple Google search of tax earned-spent map of Indian states, my states, MH and KA gets ₹7.7 and ₹13.9 for every ₹100 rupee the state earns, you get ₹1485. What kind of third class citizen gets that?
1
@rakiniprem Kerala is at the top because it games it's metrics. Tell me one college or university in Kerala that all of India competes to join. Some examples are LSR in Delhi, BITS in Pilani, RV/National/MSR in Bengaluru.
1
@rakiniprem 1. If Manipur was the issue, a special session should have been arranged, not a no confidence motion. 2. Kerala is a state in ruin. I lived among enough Mallus to know that they go to Bengaluru/Chennai for education and Coimbatore for healthcare. The state designs policy to better the metrics not the state. The only profession they are overrepresented in is nursing which is not a job creating profession. 3. Congress used to be a big camp party with its own right wing. Those people moved to the BJP today from Scindia to SM Krishna to the Birlas. These are the people who built the institutions. You are missing the point if you think that the current Congress which sheds a faction every decade(TMC, YSCRP), is the same entity.
1
@rakiniprem 1. Does not address the rebuttal I raised. You said the topic was Manipur, while even the title of this video mentions the no confidence motion. The characterization of BJP seems like circular logic and a serious case of black/white thinking. There isn't a single Hindu organization in the picture, Muslim Meiteis are killing Christian Kukis, BJP Kuki MLAs were assaulted and Meiteis forced the replacement of Assam rifles. These are enough data points to tell you that the primary lens is clan/tribe not religion. If BJP simply wanted an unstable state they wouldn't sign the tripartite agreement or continue the past methodology of integration with appeasement. 2. What data do you have for migrants causing the trouble? Also Kerala imports labour instead of the best of Indian talent because the width approach to raise metrics has led to lack of farm/construction labour. The equivalent class in Kerala moves to the Middle East. Biharis and UPites have also picked this trend. Their numbers are increasing in the Middle East. Also BJP has two model states, MH and GJ, not the migrant states. it's the same congress that ruled UP/Bihar historically not the BJP.
1