Comments by "Julian The Apostate" (@juliantheapostate8295) on "Fight for the Factories | BATTLESTORM STALINGRAD E32" video.

  1. I think Paulus had the manpower to hold the defensive line on the Volga. From then, it's repulse Uranus and allow Army Group A to seize the oil. Desperate stuff, but they had little choice
    2
  2.  @TheImperatorKnight  Bloody hell Lewis, that was a valiant attempt - I enjoyed reading it!
    2
  3. Aye, Chuikov likely had his confidence dented but he was an insanely brave man - it was never suggested he was a coward
    2
  4.  @TheImperatorKnight  I saw one guy who I genuinely think was unable to understand that you were representing a position without advocating for it. He may not have been neurotypical
    1
  5. I don't think you're right. If the Soviets had not been as ruthless, the Germans would have kept the war going longer. And in any case, the participants of WW1 were every bit as bad
    1
  6.  @MrCSRT8  Not for the commanders! Many of them were WW1 veterans
    1
  7. He's covered the operational implications in a few videos in this series - I don't have the episode and time stamps I'm afraid but Glantz covers this in his 'Struggle for the Flanks' chapters in his Stalingrad books
    1
  8. Both sides are to blame on this one. The Soviets should have prevented the children from getting involved. To the extent they are able
    1
  9.  @TheImperatorKnight  Carl has built a great team at the Lotus eaters - they're doing for journalism what you're doing for history. Why does anyone have a TV License now?
    1