Comments by "Silver Prussian" (@Silver_Prussian) on "Bashkortostan. A Republic That Wants To Break Away From Russia." video.

@nosmokejazwinski6297 where is this colonial master you speak of ? Also are you referring by any foreign land that a westerner has stepped on cause they are the only ones who had colonies to exploit.
9
Haha uhh sorry to tell you this but there are no ,,plans" for anything that is not within the interest of the russian federation because every interest of the federation is their interest as well.
8
 @ArtisZ because they had full right to the name rus since muscovy has descended from the principality of valdimir suzdal, principality within the kievan rus
6
 @uninstaller2860 it wont be an ethnostate becaue it will never leave russia
6
@lorenzofalorni3961 no you cant call it that since it was able to recounquar all rus territories and unite the people under one bamner again so it has the right to the name russia. Also muscovy before it bacame its own principality was infact a city that was part of the principality of vladimir suzdal which in term was part of the kievan rus, this further legitamises russias claim to the name of rus
5
@sircatangry5864 and from whom should muscovy have sought recognition ? Nobody has the right to dout their right to the name. Ivan the formidable is the an accurate translation not the terrible, he wasnt terrible at all he has killed far less people than most european leaders in history. If he was recognised as the ruler of the territories of the Rus and his country encompassed those territories referred to as Rus then the nations name can rightfully have rus in the name. Not that it matter since the principality of muscovy was born after the fall of the principality of vladimir suz-dal , principality that was part of the kievan rus, so muscovy is a direct descendant of that nation therefore it has all the rights to the name No russia tsar saw himself remotely connected to the mongol horde
5
@sircatangry5864 Votchina means feudal lordship Its not my fault your cognitive abilities dont work properly. Daniel was the youngest of 5 children so it was unlikely that he would rule anything but he was given rule iver moscow which latter turned into a principality in 1282, his father gave him the right to rule over moscow not the mongols. Ivan the formidables mother was only partially lipka tatar, as ivans grandmother was of serbian origin. The only title he has is simply tsar of all russians, thats it he didnt identify himself with the golden horde at all.
5
@sircatangry5864 I dont think you know what the word argument means or how to even use it in a sentence without sound like a bunch of nonsense.
5
If you are hoping for the best then you are hoping for them to remain part of russia. Man the hypocracy is real in the minds of russophones when it comes to russian territorial integrity and the eu
5
@uninstaller2860 you are comparing oranges to apples how does algeria compare to bashkortostan might you explain since one saw only exploitation while the other benefited from being part of another state.
5
 @vredacted3125 the only thing that is laugable here is your pseudo history did you stay late up night to think what fan fiction to write ?
4
@Lamzesh Похоже, это ваша проблема, а не проблема государства. Если вы собираетесь жаловаться, что школа не кормила вас всем с ложечки и не баловала вас в надежде, что вы проявите некоторый интерес к изучению своего языка, это ваша вина, что вы не взялись за это. Если вы приложите усилия, вы сможете выучить его в кратчайшие сроки, это тюркский язык, ради бога, вы не изучаете ядерную физику.
4
🤦🤦🤦 bro I can apply the same logic to any country with a lot of minorities that live within a soecitic territory like the US and its native ameri...ohhhhhh thats right I fotgot. Maybe if the russians had been as cruel there wouldnt be any of these miserable poorly made videos questioning russian territorial integrity.
4
 @The_ZeroLine wrong as factually wrong info made into propaganda that appeals only to a certain group of people
4
@scoobydoobers23 china does not economically dominate siberia, do you even understand the meaning of the word even ? Russia remains the main investor of its territory the only investment the chinese have done is for energy and a port in the northpole for the future northpole trading route. Siberia has also recieved investment from kazakhstan and has locked for investment from the middle east so what are they gonna take over ? By this logic the massive investments of china in hungary means they will take over hungary. The chinese have purchased some land for farming becasue they want to ensure their food security thats why they sogned a treaty with russia in case of emergency that russia would help them with food supplies. Ofcourse they will be buying products made in the area you muppet its the closest to them. If you have the ability to purchase a product from you area you arent gonna purchase the same product from the other side of the continent are you ?
4
@uninstaller2860 I will say never cause this isnt really something open to interpretation its a straight answer
4
@uninstaller2860 no I am talking about development on the cultural, social and economic level not just money. You know these people werent living like kings and queens before the big bad russians arrived.
4
Yes and your source for thst would be ? Btw just because there is an uprising doesnt mean its popular among the populace nor that it was in their atvantge.
3
 @little_lord_tam wow I wonder why you mentioned him
3
 @scoobydoobers23 bro why does everyone think like 7 year old when it comes to geopolitics, the chinese will not be taking anything or dominating anything for atleast 1000 reasons
3
@@sei.tsukinothey wont, they also dont habe claims on territory that isnt theirs as they have not only signed multipule treaties but it would bea geopolitical disaster for the chinese, not only that there are no chinese people there just a lot of russians. Seriously dude stop treating geopolitics like a strategy game.
3
@neftalydotcom they havent invented anyhting like that and if you think everyhting between all these peoplw was sunshine and rainbows before the russians came a think again, the only rrason why places like the caucuses and central asia are stable is because the russians kept them from fighting one another.
3
 @MetalGearyaTV guess what they arent
3
I know right ? I am not even russian even i can tell just from the title that we will be delving into a pile of sh*t.😂
3
@sircatangry5864 🤦🤦🤦 the conquest of kazan was entirely different.It was held and controled by the russians a few times prior to Ivan the formidable, it was simply a liability to remain as an entity as it had constant political turmoil which resulted in change of leadership that was simply too much of a risk to keep existing. Siberia was conquered over many decades and centuaries by the time the conquests have begun however Ivan the formidable has already passed away. Astrakhan was based around the volga river just like kazan, this was an important trade route at the time and the russians wanted full control over it, astrakhan would align itself with the crimean khante which would not work in their favour in the end, with the capture and annexation of astrakhan one of the biggest slave markets on the volga river was destroyed. Ohhh yeah guess what all those states were not innocent little happy states minding their own business, they have taken thousands of people and sold them as slaves. The crimean khante for example from 1500 to 1700 would export 2 million slaves taken from poland and russia.
2
@sircatangry5864 I havent ignored your sh*t I debunked it
2
Nobody is seeking to quote on quote ,,free" themselves whenever somebody uses the word freedom they have an alterior motive.
2
 @MeepChangeling literally all of it is wrong, these videos do not represent the majoritu mindset of the people that are spoken in the video.
2
The quesrion should be if you really know what the people of bashkortostan want and what do they really think, its nothing simular to what the videos is implying.
2
 @Trolligi nothing will be born because none of these people want to leave russia
2
Expanding your knowledge, yeah right he is totally doing that and not serving you his own narrative thar is not based in reality.
2
 @Island_of_Solitude yes there were since 1548 infact.
1
 @ВиталийЦегельник-ъ3ю shhh let them live in their delusionals that dont involve real history
1
@sircatangry5864 muscovy was not created by the mongols lol learn real history. Not only that but the son of Nevsky ruled over tver not muscovy 🤦 jesus you font know sh*t Wtf you even talking about The word вотчина means fiefdom or feudal lordship and no russian tsar has called any it those lands anyhting remotely what you said, instead of making up fan fiction on the spot why dont you open a book or god damn google force once ?
1
@vredacted3125 I already have and its bullsh*t you are more than welcome to read from historically correct sources and educate yourself
1
After Kazan fell to Ivan the Terrible in 1554–1555, representatives of western and northwestern Bashkir tribes approached the Tsar with a request to voluntarily join Muscovy. In 1798 the Spiritual Assembly of Russian Muslims was established, an indication that the tsarist government recognized the rights of Bashkirs, Tatars, and other Muslim nations to profess Islam and perform religious rituals. Ufa Governorate (guberniya), with a center in Ufa, was formed in 1865—another step towards territorial identification. In March 1919, based on the agreements of the Russian Government with the Bashkir Government was formed Bashkir Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic. During the Soviet period, Bashkiria was granted broad autonomous rights—the first among other Russian regions. The administrative structure of the Bashkir ASSR was based on principles similar to those of other autonomous republics of Russia. Tell me when did those uprising occur my guy please I would very much like to hear.
1
What lanaguhe repression all have the right to learn their lanagauge from grade 1st to last if they wished so.
1
Wow another piece of well created propaganda that is will be gawked at by minority not representing the majority of the population.
1
Jesus christ why are people like you so bad in the head were droped on your head as child by your perrant or what ? Nobody in russia has had a problem with trying to revive your lanaguge even if its mostly identical to russia. The problem is that many ukrianian speakers those thst only speak ukrainian seem to think its ok to harass those that dont want to learn it simply for speaking in russia. Yes there are tons of videos of that happening, you dont even have to go to telegran to see example so you cant deny like ukrainian state media does. This in a time when ukriane want to be more ,,european" and adopt ,,european values" one of them is to not discriminate anybody on any basis. There are many european countries that have several official lanaguges
1
 @sircatangry5864 yeah thats not really the case there my guy, and there is a lot of proof for that
1
@evancarmean2698 and where did you go exactly beside kiev did you went to lviv because you wouod habe gotten a lot of frouning faces. Also thats no longer the case even in kiev, go and check some videos of how they harass russian speakers. Isnt it amazing how russians would not notice or give a damn about the differnece between both lanaguges but ukrianians would immidiatly jump on your neck for saying both are simular.
1
Pretty sure you habe no f*cking knowledhe on the matter and you are speaking a bunch of nonesense, like ,,true russian" whats that suppose to mean ? In russia there is a distinction between russians and russian citizens but thats not on discriminatory bases. Ethnic minorities have their own native and broder russian identity as citizens.
1
@Dreju78 even though they are citizens of that country too ? Also the amount of people mobilised from the republics is not proportional to their population, meaninh there are less mobilised minoritiee and more mobilised erhnic russians. Like in ww2 it was the same the most amount of mobilised, killed and serving in the army were russians, followed by ukrainians, belarusions and so on.
1
 @Dreju78 you do realsie there are contractors, tuva is a rather poor region so many have signed a contract, and there arent more tuvans that russians on the front my guy
1
@Dreju78 there are people from the big cities thar volunteer, infact there was am interview with a layer that volunteered for the army and returned and was interviwed again, you can visit the channel real reporter he reports on some of the current topics regarding russia.
1
There is a forum of the exiled incels, they are individuals from some republics who claim they represent all people of their ethnic group 😂😂 you can alresdy guess what kind of douchebags they are, you habe radicals from the ex radicalist regime from chechnya, people who claim to be big political and social figures but somehow nobody in the republics has ever even heard of them.😂
1