Comments by "WALTERBROADDUS" (@WALTERBROADDUS) on "Ship vs Ship - Who Would Win - Episode 001" video.

  1. You realize your now going to face a sea of Coke vs Pepsi and Blonde vs. Brunette ship questions? šŸ™„ Good luck.
    209
  2. Ā @Volunteer-per-order_OSullivanĀ  First, it does not have 5 times the range. The Iowa had anti ship UGM-109b Tomahawks or the optional nuclear. The Kirov's only have 20 anti ship missles. And the Iowa's are armored to fight other BB's. Even if the missle defenses fail, it can take the hits and still hit back. Also, extended range ammo then in development would have boost the gun range to 100 miles. It is fair fight match then and now.
    11
  3. Actually the better matchup is the Iowa class versus the Soviet Kirov class. That is what they were brought back in service and upgraded to be a match for.
    7
  4. Ā @DrachinifelĀ  Firing rate can not be maintaned for any ship using humans to move heavy shells and powder bags. Even a trained crew of weightlifters will weardown in a few mins.
    2
  5. More ships is not the issue. The right kinds of ships is. The French have no large number of Amphibious landing craft. Nor do the Germans have the crews to man that fleet or the logistics to support non standard French weapons. Nor do more ships change the aircover or minfield issues.
    2
  6. Answer? Draw.... missiles are fine on unarmored ships. But would not slow a Iowa. To see what modern weapons can do, watch a sinkex..... https://youtu.be/imwLc2T3oks
    2
  7. Ā Golden EagleĀ  Actually they still have the original mech computers. https://youtu.be/wPRY5gGS3c8
    2
  8. Ā @ELCADAROSAĀ  Hoagie..... I'm a Philadelphia guy.šŸ˜·
    2
  9. Ā @mpetersen6Ā  Reds are dangerous.....šŸ˜·
    2
  10. Ā @ELCADAROSAĀ  Used live in Warrington...
    2