Comments by "Vikki McDonough" (@vikkimcdonough6153) on "A ship that refused to die - USS Marblehead, her crew and a voyage around the world" video.

  1. 3:00 - Wake Island hadn't fallen by that point; did you mean to say Guam?
    2
  2.  @Drachinifel  Huh. Would that've been a false alarm resulting from the first Japanese attack on Wake (the one that was repulsed)?
    2
  3.  @Tuning3434  I don't recall having heard that question in any of the Drydocks (and, looking through the question lists for the last several Drydocks, my memory seems to be accurate on that point), and my question was limited to the refits that could've been done without major structural changes (i.e., putting new turrets with different-size guns on the barbettes, but not altering the sizes of the barbettes themselves).
    2
  4. Could/would semidreadnoughts have been made more useful by converting them into dreadnoughts, where possible (AFAICT, this would've been possible for four classes: the Lord Nelsons, Radetzkys, Dantons, and Satsumas, giving broadsides of six, six, seven, and eight 12" guns, respectively), or else into second-class dreadnoughts (replacing a mixed battery of twelves and eight-to-nineishes with a uniform 10-inch battery)? For instance, would a Lord Nelson be more useful with a broadside of six 12" guns (replacing the twin 9.2s with single twelves) or eleven 10" guns (replacing the 9.2s one-for-one with tens and swapping out the twin twelves for triple tens), or a Danton more useful with a broadside of seven 12-inchers (replacing the twin 9.4s with single twelves), or a Connecticut more useful with a broadside of eight 10-inchers (replacing the twin twelves with triple tens and the twin eights with single tens), than in their original forms? All of these conversions would've exchanged a mixed-caliber broadside (with its attendant shell-spotting, etc., difficulties) for a uniform all-big-gun main battery, and any decrease in broadside weight would've been (a) slight, and (b) easily-countered by using slightly-heavier shells (in none of the cases I've examined would the shells've had to've been even as much as 10% heavier).
    1