Comments by "FiveLiver" (@FiveLiver) on "David Starkey Talks" channel.

  1. You don't need any introduction David. We've known you for decades.
    18
  2. Scruton never had much of a bite - his disciple Douglas Murray only showed his teeth after Oct 7.
    8
  3. Good shout. PR will mean an immovable Islamic bloc in parliament.
    8
  4. 18:51 A crass oversimplification, "the bizarre notion...you invade a country to give women the right to wear miniskirts". Afghanistan was invaded to get Bin Laden. Though the regime that harboured him was of the fundamentalist flavour of Islam it didn't mean the invasion was at all anti-Islam. It actually should have been, but was called 'The War on Terror' by Bush, and is the reason why it was ultimately an unwinnable war as the enemy was not defined. Islam was pandered to throughout the occupation, and not at all challenged as the source of authority in the land. Women had worn Western dress in Kabul in the 1960s and 70s, is it not better to support people to live as they wish, rather than as they are commanded on pain of punishment by violent theocrats? In doing so we would be protecting our own right not to be so commanded. Communism was undermined throughout the Cold War by the West, but Islam, the first political ideology in history and equally desirous of global domination, was not even identified as the source of the treat that sent armies to Afghanistan in the first place.
    8
  5. Unite The Kingdom 27 July
    7
  6. There can't be any ifs.
    7
  7. who made this happen
    6
  8. Who do you want to submit their CV for head of state? It's easy badmouthing the monarchy until you consider the alternative.
    6
  9.  @ManofTruth999  you must be here to hate watch
    6
  10.  @Barrettszippo  His contributions to British freedom is what I'm interested in.
    6
  11. The Great Repeal Act - I like it.
    6
  12. 26:42 By 'Geoffrey Elton' you mean Gottfried Rudolf Otto Ehrenberg
    6
  13. Conservatism is not going to come from the Conservatives. Forget them.
    6
  14. show us the counter evidence that there isn't two tier governance.Or is that a 'trick' you can't manage?
    5
  15. Throw your weight behind Reform UK, David.
    5
  16. Interesting analysis from the Richard III Society you have drawn our attention to. The conspiracy theory that Richard murdered his nephews really needs to be examined.
    5
  17. Stasi Starmer.
    5
  18. Doomer
    4
  19. So everything is upside down there.😃
    4
  20.  @paulembleton1733  It's not just the odd person and anyway they just get recycled around to another department.
    4
  21. YOU are gone the UK has not
    4
  22. The overly long preamble got to me again.
    3
  23.  @wilfridwibblesworth2613  What about solid excrement?
    3
  24. All Israel's problems come from Islam.
    3
  25.  @senoirmunchez  Ultimately it becomes a demographic head count.
    3
  26. 40:19 The Magnificat is nothing to do with anti-whiteism.
    3
  27. Some issues with the sound quality.
    3
  28.  @simongleaden2864  An interesting, but contrasting comparison: while Clay's new name was intended to reveal, Ehrenberg's new name was intended to conceal.
    3
  29. Why not?
    2
  30. Where have all the Tories gone?
    2
  31. where've you been?
    2
  32. UKIP are still going.
    2
  33. What book, what podcast?
    2
  34. Go away
    2
  35. Starts sentence....drinks.
    2
  36. They have conserved the Blairite establishment.
    2
  37. Vladimir Putin?
    2
  38.  King Alfred  Then why did they leave?
    2
  39. You are describing antiwhiteism - the social morality of the west where doing harm to whites is not considered wrong.
    2
  40. The whispering.. oh the whispering..
    2
  41. Viewers may find this video of interest. ​​Panagiotis Constantinou - King Henry VIII's Six Wives - Real Faces - Queens of England 11mins 8Jan22
    2
  42. South Africa was a functioning first world country under a minority. Majority rule has been a disaster for the country and resulted in persecution for the minority.
    2
  43.  @PlightOfTheInnovator  Everybody is using it even Elon Musk.
    1
  44.  @PlightOfTheInnovator  Why wouldn't he use it? Does it offend you?
    1
  45. Grey eyes?
    1
  46.  @welshed  The beneficiaries of Blair's devolution are the fake nationalists who are really globalists and the woke causes they espouse.
    1
  47. I once saw a clip of some America youth asking an Englishman "what language do they speak in England?"
    1
  48. David seems a bit under the weather.
    1
  49. Don't embarrass yourself.
    1
  50. two-tier governance is antiwhite.
    1
  51. Hilarious!
    1
  52. They work in concert.
    1
  53. David starkey says the Suffragettes weren't terrorists. Simon Webb come in here.
    1
  54. Tory voters like me have moved to pastures new. I would like the Conservative party to get out of the way and let those better suited to representing the British people take power.
    1
  55.  @lydiamalone1859  Not so much 'magic' but agreed upon. As it takes centuries to establish such a thing, once gone it cannot be recreated. The value of the monarchy is that it exists outside of politics, like an umpire who doesn't take part.
    1
  56. The left don't debate - they lock people up.
    1
  57. All that is fine as long as we stop importing the Third World into the Anglo-sphere (an issue you don't mention)
    1
  58. Your country created a new religion, antiwhiteism - the moral satisfaction at the white erasure of the West.
    1
  59. 15:32 Though I agree with him generally, I think David will have to find a better refutation of Rousseau than this quote from St Augustine.
    1
  60. They use it nonetheless
    1
  61. Can you do anything other than name call?
    1
  62. Starkey's atheism demonstrates he's not a clever as he thinks he is.
    1
  63.  @KnellofPartingDay  It shows he's quite dim, and believes he is responsible to no greater power.
    1
  64.  @robinsoncrusoejr7089  Unfortunately, if you watch enough of Starkey's material you hear the same things umpteen times. Add to that, 'what is democracy children?' seminar type questions and it all becomes rather tortuos. If he had something brilliant to say please tell me. It's important to get to the point IMMEDIATELY. Then back up what you are saying. I'm not a millennial or gen Z, I'm one of the highly revered boomer generation.
    1
  65.  @livelovelaugh2130  Hitchens is a contrarian and a doomer. Murray is coming into his own now.
    1
  66.  @tdevry  Not a tall silly. Before then he was more of a passive and somewhat detached observer. After that he sounded like he was in the fight.
    1
  67.  @aranisles8292  Books are great for establishing credentials and thought leading, but they are not a mass consumption media. The media is the battleground: speeches, debates, interviews. In interviews Scruton came over as meek. The left are in ascendent everywhere, they are winning in culture and in politics. Scruton failed. Who have moved populations in recent years? Donald Trump and Nigel Farage. Public opinion is shifted by outspoken and fearless people who don't back down.
    1
  68.  @Barrettszippo  You may not like it, but Scruton failed, the left keep winning. It started way before Stasi Starmer.
    1
  69.  @morqthana  quote some of Scruton's anti-semitic bigotry for us will you?
    1
  70.  @morqthana  Why Scruton what?
    1
  71. Then you are part of the problem
    1
  72. Trump an 'awful candidate'?
    1
  73. 👁
    1
  74.  @wolfiestreet6899  The official narrative is that Islam is a religion of peace - I said otherwise.
    1
  75.  @costakeith9048  Islm imposed itself on societies that were once Christian, Zoroastrian or Buddhist. You speak of the 'flaw' in liberalism, but liberal Britain created the largest empire in history, and led the world into modernity. The millions from the backward Third Wold are trying to get into the liberal countries of the West because they don't like the values, and hence the living conditions imposed on them by Islm, an ideology that is anti-individual and anti-creative. People are voting with their feet. We should assist them where they are by acting against this 14 centuries old problem which would shackle the world given the chance.
    1
  76.  @costakeith9048  I'm talking about giving people the right to choose, and that includes choosing Christianity. It wasn't feudal Britain that built the Empire it was the Enlightenment values of freedom to trade and stake your own claim in the New World. The Empire was not 'lost' - the USA, Canada, New Zealand and Australia still exist as expressions of the British race and values and are the living legacy of Empire. The rest India and Africa were developed from trade and and the desire to explore and was not intended to be permanent like the Roman Empire. The Empire was a net drain on the exchequer, and we are better without it. What exactly was 'disastrous' about the reforms of the 1830s and 1911? Your attack on liberalism doesn't acknowledge that our society is liberal in nature, and springs from our Christianity, to deny that is to throw the baby out with the bathwater. What we have today is not liberal, it is the opposite. It is the authoritarian excesses of leftism and conformist collectivism that have damaged this country.
    1
  77.  @costakeith9048  Enforcing Christianity is contradictory to the spirit of Christianity, while enforcing Islam is essential to it - giving everyone no right of choice creates the cultural and creative Islamic backwaters that Trump had a term for, ending in ‘holes’. Enforced Christianity cannot possibly work as post Reformation there is no agreed form of Christianity. Charles I and Cromwell had opposing beliefs, which led to civil war. The divine right of kings? Good luck bringing that back. It is absurd to believe that the continuation of the British Empire was an option into the 21st Century. As if the countries in Africa, India and the far east would have happily gone along with it? This is pure fantasy. The end result of democracy is tyranny? Obviously not, democracy is the antidote to tyranny. What we have now it not democracy, it is a corruption of it; the will of the people is ignored again and again. All the “It’s democracy, it’s liberalism” is just nonsense and has to stop. It’s woke leftism and globalist technocracy, dressed up as liberal democracy that is imposing ‘equality’ over us.
    1
  78. ​ @costakeith9048  It's time to remind you that my comment was about Islam, not the sects of Christianity, not democracy, not Russia and the Tzars. We in civilised Britain (God knows where you are from) either regain real democracy and the rule of law, or continue with the current pretend democracy into digital globalist despotism, which is turning a blind eye to the problems caused by the religion of peace.
    1
  79.  @costakeith9048  The purpose of Islam is dual: to convert the world yes, but more importantly subdue it under Sharia - this is how Islam spread historically, by the oppression of dhimmitude. To imagine it is not a threat is exactly what they want you to believe. You have already had a Muslim in the White House, ("the future does not belong to those who slander the prophet of Islam") and had Hillary Clinton won in 2016 her Chief of Staff was a daughter of the Muslim Brotherhood. References to Islam have already been removed from FBI training manuals. While martial law would be a good thing to halt the criminality and corruption, of the current establishment, it would only be to reintroduce REAL democracy, it cannot exist indefinitely as, like all things, a dictatorship will devolve into corruption.
    1
  80.  @costakeith9048  Let's also not forget that Britain and France occupied Constantinople after defeating the Ottomans, and it was there for Russia's asking had not that country been subverted by Bolshevism with a desire not to cooperate with capitalists. What an opportunity missed. Just to point out that while Islam conquered the Byzantine provinces of Egypt, Syria and Palestine, the schism with Rome happened long afterwards, so it would be wrong to arrogate those places to the Orthodox church at that time.
    1
  81. 9:22 "..to protect a text which for the whole of the Christian middle ages was regarded as the work of the Devil" Fat chance the Pope or the Archbishop of Canterbury saying that today.
    1
  82.  @shabbos-goy9407  CRT comes out of Antiwhiteism, not the other way round.
    1
  83. Stasi Starmer
    1
  84. Not is he declares martial law and makes himself dictator.
    1
  85. Islam was the original organised crime.
    1
  86. Antiwhiteism has many origins.
    1
  87. Comrade Starmer King of the anti-white woke.
    1
  88. 7:40 No one is descended from the prophet Mohammad - there is no historical evidence that he even existed. You might as well say descended from King Arthur.
    1
  89. What a great justification for white erasure!
    1
  90.  @sbor2020  The Tories are as woke and antiwhite as Labour - they have to go.
    1
  91. They have conserved the achievements of Blair.
    1