Comments by "TJ Marx" (@tjmarx) on "Frustration mounts as China hits record number of new Covid cases" video.
-
5
-
2
-
2
-
@Injudiciously You've gotten a little confused too, bit like the little Koala. It's quite interesting that so many people don't really understand how the Westminster system functions but are all too eager to act otherwise.
You are correct that the UK has no formal constitution, however it does have a series of documents passed through parliament that collectively amount to a constitution. It's why the UK is correctly called a constitutional monarchy.
The UK is not actually a democracy however. The house of commons was created to prevent a repeat in England of the revolt that took place in France. The Westminster system rigs the game so that the house of commons have no real power as a way to maintain the monarchy and it's power whilst pretending to the masses they have a say.
The Magna Carta is better described as a gentlemanly agreement. There many times since it's signing that Kings have disregarded it. All legislation and agreements in the UK only exist so long as the monarch entertains them. At no point has the crown relinquished power.
All of the lords and land owners from magna carta became peers in the house of lords, their descendants continue the system today.
Nothing from the house of commons can pass without first the consent of the peers in the house of Lords and then the consent of the King. Nothing is law without royal ascent, which is a fancy way of saying the King signed off that he's ok with making that thing law.
It is important to understand that just because Elizabeth never exercised her power during her reign, she always held an unlimited veto, as does the King today. Monarchs are sovereign, that's just a fancy way of saying they are indistinguishable from the countries they rule over and their inhabitants. The King is the UK, it's what gives the royal family immunity from prosecution.
The King is the FUNCTIONAL head of state and no prime minister becomes prime minister without first meeting with the King, being interviewed by the King, and the King saying s/he can be his prime minister then inviting the prime minister to form a cabinet. Remember the formal title for the UK prime minister is his royal majesty's prime minister, as in belonging to the King.
The UK is objectively a sleeping dictatorship pretending to be a democracy. The Queen rubber stamped things, the King may or may not. Regardless, they retain the power to refuse legislation, to create new legislation from nothing and to order the house of commons to debate a thing. The Lords too retain the ability to force the house of commons to pass legislation.
The UK has never been equal, it's always been the rich ruling over the slave class. It remains a serious crime in the UK to talk about republic or to talk against the monarchy. The UK simply does not have the freedoms the rest of the western world enjoy.
2
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1