Comments by "suraj s" (@surajs5913) on "Amit Shah holds massive roadshow in West Bengal" video.
-
10
-
8
-
7
-
4
-
@jaswirgill6245 brother the main demands of farmers apart from removing these 3 laws is to implement swaminathan commission report and give written assurance of MSP. Government is already trying to implement most of the reports recommendation, including better irrigation projects, encouraging new technology for drip irrigation, kisan credit card, crop insurance, etc. If farmers were to talk with the government so that any problems in implementing the swaminathan commission is solved, it will be good for farmers and whole nation.
Swaminathan commission itself recommended that agriculture must be in concurrent list so that both centre and state can make laws. That has not been legally amended but it is as per the spirit of the swaminathan commission.
Govt has given assurance to give written promise of MSP, stop interstate trade and strengthen APMC while imposing tax on private mandis. Tell me which portion of the farm laws are the farmers.against that the government doesnt want to talk about?
I am sure that indian farmers are educated enough to take the chance to talk and turn the three laws into exactly as per the swaminathan commision recommendations, or demand new laws for the same( so that land rights of the farmers are protected, etc.) Question is why they are not doing that and instead turning this into a ego clash between farmers and govt?
Farmers are not fools, but that doesn't mean that government is evil. Farmers now have a chance to decide what they want, beyond just urea subsidies, water subsidies, electricity subsidies, etc. If that is done and farmers are interested to looking past the ego of the government and their own egos, this opportunity can be used to create the best agriculture laws that benefit both the farmer and the consumer.
I dont want to pay 100 rs per kilo for onion knowing that the farmer only got 30 rs. And i also dont want to pay income tax knowing that it will be used to procure rice when rice is already rotting in FCI godown.
This government mah be less smart and have a bit ego but this is the best chance in history of independent india that farmers can sit down with govt and decide whats best for farmers and people. I hope this chance is not wasted...
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1