Comments by "" (@SG-js2qn) on "Adam Ragusea"
channel.
-
3
-
Real science doesn't have consensus. Here's my take on the origin of the pork taboo (which I see is finally briefly alluded to at the very end of the video). The pig was domesticated at least twice, once long ago in Mesopotamia, and once in the vicinity of China. They became identified with those cultures, just as others focused on the cow, fish, or poultry.
The Semitic cultures of Judaism and Islam fought to maintain a distinct identity from the dominant Mesopotamian one. So they focused on promoting their own traditions of food, clothing, language, beliefs, family stories, etc. Anyone seen partaking of Mesopotamian culture was perceived as an infidel ... someone who was not being faithful to the ways of the tribe.
FWIW, the Semites were pastoral shepherds, and their main protein sources were sheep and goats.
This same problem also presented itself with resistance to Canaanite culture and Egyptian culture.
IMO, this is very easy to understand. It's part of reinforcing tribal identity. I think the cleanliness issue is another retro-projection.
2
-
2
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1