General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About

DonXardas
HistoryLegends
comments

Comments by "DonXardas" (@DonXardas) on "HistoryLegends" channel.

 @el_gabron but that does not make them false. Russia is slowly but surely taking ground. There is no denying that.
75
@SerfinBird USA in WW2... what a joke, you do understand that USA actually joined the combat when the soviets already did break the Reichs spine. And what did the US army do? They landed in Normandy, pretty much the best fortified area. They lost thousands while landing at that beach out of sheer stupidity. And even then they were lucky that the germans pulled out a lot of their forces out of Normandy before that day. If they did not do that, the US casualties would be way higher.
40
 @AgentDoubleOSeven77 that could be true but Ukraine has yet to take any land.
20
@paja2788 you would bw right, except Ukraine never did declare war or even anything similar. So there is no legal reason for mandatory service and people being forced into the service is illegal.
18
@AgentDoubleOSeven77 yep he is no Zhukov. And it looks like Russia will lose Kursk? According to who? There is litteraly no indication that Ukraine can win, take and hold Kursk.
17
I mean they are losing. There is no doubt about that.
8
 @BrotherHood-xh9sg it is weird in cases where their own vountry is actually a country that cares about their citizens. This is not the case with Ukraine.
8
@paja2788 actually you need it. Ukraine did not declare any kind of official state emergency either. And such behavior directly violates ukrainian constitution. But the ukrainian government after the Maidan never cared for it or any human rights.
8
They always did have an army, but they lost to friggin emus in 1931, so you can not take them seriously.
7
 @Kefir_72 так в этом и шутка.
7
@brobot_8371 well this is kinda a stupid comment. What does it matter how crappy Bosnia is? The quality of life dropped in Germany several times in the past 2 decades. And instead of fixing domestic problems, the germam government is financing a corrupt state. Great job.
5
@leshmanekenborec9243 well he was not wrong. All those "50 times" he reported about the frontline crumbling and I did not watch every of his videos but in those that I watched he never said Ukraine is crumbling. He was talking about specific areas of the frontline. And he is far more honest about the war compared to Ukraine/Russia. If you listen to them Kiev/Moscow have allready been taken.
4
 @Lanacat-m2t почему смаковать? Но Украина сама к этому шла, так почему вдруг надо жалеть идиотов?
4
@Arteus_Hoplit that depends on your definition of "heavy casualties".
3
@BFey-z7qwell Ukraine started a civil war in 2014/2015. Russia started a war with Ukraine in 2022.
3
@AgentDoubleOSeven77 yeah not answering a question but writing a pathetic parody of a joke. Well this tells mountains about you.
3
It takes a lot of time to make a video. Usualy a few days. So of course there will be no news about what happened in the last few days.
2
Wow, you are triggered.
2
Not really. If you look at the ammo production in EU, it was being cut down over the recent years. The only part of NATO that produces a lot of shells is USA. And even they do not produce enough. It will take a year or two to build new production lines. And EU has not even started building them.
2
@Super_king33 1. Называли. Вы понимаете ято есть рвзница между юридическим статусом и тем как это воспринимаеться/называеться в народе. Так вот, США юридически не объявляли войн. Тут вы правы. Но они никогда не запрещали людям называть это войнами. 2. По вашей логике не стоит осуждать убийцу если тот указывает на другого убийцу и говорит что мол тот тоже плохой.
2
 @RAEJDER for that the other side would need t change their "narrative" as well.
2
@PM-oe8sp what do you mean public satelites? Not only did Ukraine need infos from military satelites, they needed a bunch of other intel as well. Also ukrainians are nowhere of this level of planing. Most of ukrainian apparatus has no clue what they are doing, because just like in Russia they got their positions because of connections and not because of their skill. That level of operation needed someone on the mossad level. Well Russia f-ing up there security did help them, but ukrainians would never manage it on their own. Even just those bridge bombing were most definetivly not done just by them.
2
 @wizard6547 yes.
2
 @arkcon714 more like 15K to 16K
2
@Boom.Desjardins still better than Ukraine. And I was born in Ukraine, I saw it for myself. It is a dirthole full of uneducated morons. And yeah Russia is not great, but still way better compared to Ukraine.
2
@MitchellN2002nl actually no. It was bot considered safe. And no, this does not absolve the seperatists or whoever of downing that plane, it just shows that Ukraine is also to blame. Also it is very possible that Ukraine did allow planes to fly there hoping that something like that would happen. They did try to escalate the whole thing on multiple occassions. And before you say anything the best example is that ukrainian rocket that hit Poland and Ukraine instead of saying "yeah it was us, it was a missfire" they claimed it was Russia.
1
@desmondgriffith7855 and?
1
@desmondgriffith7855 dude you just wrote how many people died in Normandy. So what? How does that in any way invalidates what I said? Your comment was pointless. That is why I asked "and?". And instead lf being a smug smartass you could actually try to finish your thought.
1
@brobot_8371 of course Germany is better than any eastern european country, but only in comparison to them and only because Germany did a good job 50 years ago, while those countries suffered communism. I lived 20+ years in Germany. In the last 10 years the government managed to cut the living standart to less than 1/3 of what it used to be.
1
@johanstinson no hamas is solely responsible for all the death. The history of the whole conflict can explain their reasons/motivation, but it in no way excuses them for what they did. And ok lets talk about the history of the conflict. Who started the first Israel-Arab war in 1947/1948? Was it Israel? No. The arabs did it. Did arabs ever suggested a peqce treaty? Nope. Did Israel and/or western countries offer a peqce deal? Yes, on multiple occasions. Did the arabs accept it? No. So yeah while Israel is not a saint (no country is) pretty much the whole situation is the fault of the arabs. And the most sad thing is, their hate (and their religion) is far more important to them in comparison to their children and their future. Just think about it for a second. The germans killed 6M jews. After nearly 80 years there are estimated to be only up to 12M in the whole world. So the germans killed probably more then the half of all jews in the world. The jews did not start a slaughter of germans. They did not killed german women or children. Today they live in peace with them. They did not let hate dictate their future. The whole Israel-arab conflict is only few years younger. And what do we see here? The arabs hate the jews so much, that they are willingly using their children as human shields and celebrate the death of jewish children and women. They could have build a great country with all the aid from EU, USA and other countries, but they turned themselfs into a terror state. There is no humanity in those savages. Only hate.
1
@el_gabron maybe, I did not heard about it, but to be honest I do follow the development on the front every second so it could be.
1
 @kingkoi6542 probably not, but it would have prolongd the war and a lot more people would have died on all sides
1
He just reports facts. When Ukraine was pushing Russia back in 2022, he reported about losses of Russia. Right now the situation is different and Russia is winning, so he is reporting about that.
1
@Marrothefirst cause it makes sense (economicly) to use up oder equipment. Why do they need to buy their own gear? Cause russian army is corrupt. They have been "investing" in churches instead of gear. It is not that they were not prepared. I talked to a few russian officers/soldiers and they did not know that they gonna invade Ukraine and those who knew were told, that they gonna meet no resistance and most ukrainian people wellcome them and that ukrainian government gonna surrender. That is why they went in with stretched out support lines and not prepared to fight. That was a royal f. up.
1
I mean one is a high tech rocket capable of long range which is difficult to hit because of its speed. The other one is just a bomb. I actually would expect somethink like 1 Kaliber = 300-400 FAB.
1
@toddforbes2079 1. Dont know where you got the 200 square km number. It is more like 160 square km. But ok lets say it is 200. 2. You do understand that the frontline is not a few km wide. It is thousand + km wide. Obviously Ukraine is not pushing everywhere on the frontline, but when you look at the areas they are pushing, those 200 square km mean nothing. It is just not significant enough. Depending on the exact position it means they managed to earn somewhere from a few hundred meters to a few km on. 3. Comparing land gain of two armies with different goals and strategies is just dumb. Russia does not need to take the land that fast. They can easily fortify their position and destroy the incoming forces, kinda like they do. 4. Yes they did not use their full force. But they already lost quite a number of trained soldiers (especially those wgo knew how to use western tanks) and quite a number of western tanks/equipment. Ukrainian ministery of defense said that they lost up to 20%, but as well know neither ukrainian nor russian official statement can never be trusted, the real number lies somehwere around 30% or 35%. 5. You see, there is a problem with people not understanding warfare just thinking that they can send their main forces on a mission that will change everything. Lets say if Ukraine uses it main forces to brach all the russian fortifocation and reach the sea. What do you imagine will happen? If they use all the forces or even just the vast majority, Russia can collapse ukrainian defences on the other parts of frontline. So Ukraine cant just use all their forces for that mission. So they need to send in, less units. Which would mean that breqching of russian defence lines would take longer if possible at all. Russian troops have more time for reinforcement. So you see it is not so easy. 6. What I agree with is that they are trying to cripple supply and command chain and are somewhat succesfull.
1
@marcbush2796 so after 2 month and after losing aprox. 1/3 of their equipment and a lot of those trained soldiers they finally arrieved at first russian defence line. Great. If they are gonna fight like that, they gonna lose the rest before they arrive at the last defence line. But I love how you are just assuming and claiming a bunch of nonsense. You are assuming they gonna breach russian lines, even though all the attempts until now were fails. You are assuming Russia is not gonna flank/attack those ukrainians from both sides when they are gonna march south. You are assuming Russia can not use ships for their logistics. You are claiming the war will be over and Putin will be gone. Those claims and assumptions are just stupid, like stupid on level of clinical idiots.
1
 @jorgeandrade783 nah. The numbers are way higher. It is probably somewhere around 300K kia and around 100-200k wounded for each side.
1
 @damonburroughs5283 well technicly there was no mobilization. Mobilization is only possible if there is war. What Russia did was a partiall monilization or whatever they called it.
1
@damonburroughs5283 they actually do not. It is forbidden in Russia to call this war war. In all official talks they use the term "Special military operation" which by itaelf is stupid but not really new. Nevwr have heard the term on a war time foozing, so I can not tell you about that, but war crimes do not mean that there is an actual war. It is a brode term for crimew commited in a military conflict. It does not need to be a war. And yes both sides did commit a bunch of those.
1
@damonburroughs5283 ah ok. Yeah I think they ae using the wrong terminology. Russia is failing hard in their innerpolitical/media war. It was a moronic move to forbid people from using the word "war". The really sad thing they even managed to fail the coverage of the other side. They could have always mentioned that Ukraine does not recognize the whole deal as war. Ukraine never did officialy declare war on Russia, cause that would mean Russia will stop sending gas to Europe through Ukraine. And EU would drop Ukraine as a hot potato.
1
 @Brandon-w3o a donkey? A singular donkey?
1
@PM-oe8sp nah dude, they are not. And no, in a lot of ways the corruption got worse. It is just their mentality. Just like russians need a Tzar whom they will follow. That is the problem with people in the west, they do not understand what kind of people they are talking about.
1
 @majorintel9623 well yeah, Israel is winning.
1
@sdavid3569 they did not really push for it. They made a show out of it, trying to present themselfs like some kind of saints while Russia is the litteral devil. But okay that is just propaganda, Russia does similar stuff. Just look at what they demanded (yes they demanded and did not try to negotiate). Russia, who is in the far moire advantagious position, shall draw back their forces, give back all territory and pay reparations. And the most laughable, they did not even suggest to lift their sanctions if Russia would do that. So in short they asked russia to roll over and die. In what world would any country, that is not utterly losing a war, do that? And while the demands of Russia are hard, they reflect the reality of the battlefield. And hey I am not pro-russian, I am anti-ukraine though, but to deny reality is just madness.
1
 @rodi8266 a d that is a good thing.
1
 @AshGreen359 because tge majority of people are frigging dumb.
1
@ivanshevchenko5045 well it does. And if you do not believe me welk that is a you problem.
1
@jesan733 nah, the joke is not that bad. It is not great either, just a cheap joke. The funny thing is the context of the joke. If those who are pro-ukrainian did not write about russians only having shovels, nobody would make those jokes. And here lies the problem. You do not think it is funny because you can not objectivly look at the situation, you are trapped in your bubble. Just as those who make those shovel jokes are trapped in their bubble. And now that the russian side is winning/pushing forward, you are in denial.
1
@Johnplayerspecial23 oh jeez another nazi lover. Dude it is okay to be pro Ukraine but why do you people repeat nazi paroles like some mindless drones. For once in your live think and educate yourself before you write this garbage.
1
@willietorben560 myabe, but lwts say they are gonna take it. You think they will be able to hold it for long? I dont think so. A month at best which is not gonna make any difference. And do they expect no reaction from Russia? In my opinion the whole thing is just moronic. It will only cause more death and suffering.
1
Why should he be recognized? Do you think they all know each other?
1
И там и там жизнь дерьмо (вне зависимости от войны).
1
@Maxhartmann2024 1. Я где то написал что весь мир живёт хорошо и только постсоветские страны плохо? Не надо приписывать мне такой бред. 2. Да если брать весь мир, то жизнь в постсоветских странах нормальная. В Африке, арабских странах и большей части Южной Америки похуже. В этим никто не спорит. Если сравнить только с другими европейскими странами, то нет. В этом сравнении хуже. Тут снова же надо дифференцировать. У постсоветчких стран есть аспекты в которых они лучше других европейских стран. Этого никто не отрицает. Но если говорить про общий уровень жизни, то смешно утверждать что постсоветское пространство на европейском уровне. 3. Ну может у вас там и есть такие патологические "страхи". Только я тут не при чём. Речь не о каких то уберменшах или подобном бреде. Просто менталитет абсолютного большинства людей постсоветского пространства сформировался уж такой. Исторически так получилось. Я даже больше скажу, средне статистичкий немец намного глупее условного "русского", менее начитан итд. Но при этом немец просто будет работать а не сидеть на пятой точке и ждать что его сначала пнут чтобы он начал работать.
1
 @MilushevGeorgi dude you need to pull whoevers fingers out of your behind. They are way up high and scrambling those few drops of functioning grey matter that you still have.
1
 @Айнур-в9ч ну будем честными, в Ираке никого не жалко. Там реально дикари живут.
1