Comments by "Max Smith" (@maxsmith695) on "1944: Should We Bomb Auschwitz? | Free Documentary History" video.

  1. I am an archeologist and have been to Auschwitz, Treblinka, Madanek, Sobibor, Belzac and Chelmno.
    5
  2.  @heathercontois4501  - The entire cache of camp records were captured by Russia and then returned in 1991. Can you discuss what those documents revealed.
    3
  3. I heard it was 55 million and only 19 survived.
    2
  4. Germany's rise to power came from slave labor, there were 10,000 camps and most were involved in some type of work.  Auschwitz III also called Buna Rubber, made all the rubber for the German military. One bombing strike on the plant, would bring the German war machine to an end. America was actively involved in making Germany strong via bank loans and American firms building vehicle for Germany. Ford is one name most often mentioned. Those details are absent from classrooms in America.
    2
  5. True.
    2
  6. They did.
    2
  7.  @notabene7381  - Where did he sleep in the camp?
    2
  8. My uncle was in auschwitz for 21 years. He tunneled out in 1946.
    1
  9. They did.
    1
  10.  @TD-oo1hl  The San Francisco earthquake killed almost 3,000,000.
    1
  11. People believe in Aliens, Bigfoot, Spinning Earth, an unknown, unseen, unproven force that is so strong it holds trillions of gallons of water to the earth but not a butterfly.
    1
  12. They were still primitive in 1991.
    1
  13. Who said that ?
    1
  14. As a student ?
    1
  15. Are historians forgetting Germany was attacked by Poland, England, France and america first.
    1
  16. Brits had broken the German code in 1942. They knew all that was happening in Auschwitz. It was labor camp.
    1
  17. They did. That is how care packages were delivered.
    1
  18. Israel has no formal borders. Why?
    1
  19. All history, must never be forgotten. The Punic Wars laid the foundation for modern Europe.
    1
  20. Bread?
    1
  21. Have you ever been to the camp?
    1
  22. define " by what ".
    1
  23. Those are not his words.
    1
  24. Sad but true. Never forget.
    1
  25. I used to spend a great deal of time, teaching my students this part of Ireland's history.
    1
  26. America and British broke the German code in 1941. They knew what life was like in Auschwitz. Read the red Cross reports.
    1
  27. Red Cross was in Auschwitz each week. They wrote a 1500 page report in 1946. They reported no problems. have you read it?
    1
  28.  @FreeDocumentaryHistory  The German war machine could not operate if not for slave labor.
    1
  29. Morganthau sought to dismantle all of Germany.
    1
  30. The Americans destroyed all the railroad tracks and roads, no food could be delivered.
    1
  31. The Most Holy Saint Pope Pius XII, Saved 800,000 and the ADL gave him a special gift.
    1
  32. they did.
    1
  33. Insects dropped on a camp?
    1
  34. What is the point ?
    1
  35. Dresden , Never forget.
    1
  36. He admitted in 1985 his words were all hearsay.
    1
  37.  @Amandaaa2244  I read the 1985 transcript from the Ernest Zundel trial in Canada. The Attorney was asking very clear and specific questions. I only know what he said under oath.
    1
  38.  @Amandaaa2244  Transcripts are like fingerprints.
    1
  39.  @Amandaaa2244  I found his transcript online. It was in January 1985 in Toronto.
    1
  40.  @bcaye  I have just published my 5th book on the Germany Empire 1933-1945.
    1
  41.  @abdirahmanidris290  - fortunately the transcript remains online.
    1
  42.  @abdirahmanidris290 - I believe the court transcripts.
    1
  43. 15,000,000 killed in Vietnam and SE Asia.
    1
  44. American publication , Readers Digest. in 1942 said 6,000,000 would perish. February 1942 edition.
    1
  45. What would YOU have done AFTER the war to not abandon the people of eastern Europe. Stalin placed them under Communism.
    1
  46. Is Elie Wiesel a Auschwitz inmate?
    1
  47. Allied Generals never went into Poland.
    1
  48. I was liberated from Auschwitz.
    1
  49. Did the bishop admit to that.
    1
  50. American bankers gave Germany the loans. The German leader used slave labor for the rest.
    1