Comments by "David H" (@DavidHalko) on "VisualPolitik EN"
channel.
-
45
-
35
-
21
-
21
-
14
-
13
-
11
-
9
-
5:15 - “deal Trump made with Taliban”
You mischaracterized the cease fire /peace agreement between the US and Taliban. I don’t know if it’s due to ignorance or just have an axe to grind with the former U.S. Republican President.
All wars must come to an end with a political arrangement between the parties.
The Taliban ran Afghanistan before the invasion, they hosted & protected Al Qaida [who attacked the US repeatedly, during Clinton & Bush years.] The Taliban was at war with the US during the Obama & Trump years.
The Taliban agreed during the Trump years that they would not host/protect terrorist organizations belligerent to the U.S. & would cease attacks against the U.S.
In cooperation with The Taliban meeting certain hard metrics, the US would not attack the Taliban & withdraw soldiers from Afghanistan. This was a reasonable agreement.
During the Biden years, he decided to ignore the part of the agreement where the Taliban was obligated to meet their metrics, and decided to cut & run… even though The Taliban held up their end of the agreement to not attack the U.S. & not willingly host terrorist organizations hostile to the U.S.
Why Democrat Biden cut & run, not holding the Taliban to the rest of the signed agreement, when the son of the Afghan President was a Democrat community organizer for Candidate Biden, is puzzling to me.
Biden did not force the Taliban to uphold their agreement, so it should be no surprise the Taliban are not holding up any other international norms. Biden cleared the road for which the Taliban would continue to travel during his Administration.
If you are going to tell the story, you should tell a more complete story, with all it’s odd twists & turns.
9
-
8
-
7
-
7
-
@BolshevikCarpetbagger1917 - “Putin did drive Ukraine eastward… selling oil and gas”
But that was too little, too late.
Ukraine had already been working with several exploration companies, where Ukraine would have been supplying their own oil and gas.
What is better? Harvest your own oil & gas, or pay Russia for it? Clearly, paying Russia was not enough.
“EU deal that would have required Ukraine to raise prices by at least 100%”
That is speculation. The EU deal would have opened up new markets for Ukraine’s existing grain products, oil/gas products which were under exploration, and Ukraine had been working to become a Hydrogen Exporter to Europe. This would have caused inflation, due to the immense number of jobs & cash flowing to Ukraine, but the standard of living would have raised for everyone!
“U.S/NATO regime change outfits”
I am sorry to tell you, but large bureaucratic organizations don’t change courses quickly, it takes immense pressure to make them change course. Something like an invasion of a nation & committing genocide. Invading Georgia did not cause a response, because of limited Russian intervention. Invading Ukraine in 2014 did not cause a response, because of limited Russian intervention. Invading Ukraine again in 2022 caused real support from western nations.
“… commenced their work in Ukraine”
Unfortunately, Russia
- invaded Ukraine regions in 2014 with gas/oil exploration
- created killing fields of civilians in occupied Ukraine territories
- deported children from Ukraine into Russia
- castrated POW’s, to limit new children to be born in Ukraine
- depopulated nearly all males from 18-60 in Russian Occupied Donbas by ensuring they would all be killed in the meat waves against fellow Ukrainians
- mined the Ukrainian dam circa 2022 which provided water for grain production, so Russia could starve Ukrainians again like the original Holodomor
- later blew up the Ukrainian dam in 2023, the water store for Hydrogen cracking
- possibly just mined the nuclear plant, where Hydrogen would be produced for Europe
7
-
7
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
@surajitmondal823 - it really depends on what the fundamentals are that the group[s] conserve.
If they conserve fundamental Modern/Western Values, then all is good in the world.
If the conserve Social Darwinistic values, that drove Europe into WW2, there is a serious issue that may bite others, especially minorities.
If they conserve non-Western values (ie slaving because they are of the wrong ethnicity or religion, like was done in the Balkans of Europe, Caucuses of Asia, or coasts of Africa, for over 1300 years), that is serious problem that may bite The West (that problem did not start getting thrown off until invading slavers were kicked out of the Western European continent 1492, it took several hundred years for Western Europeans to figure out that slaving was bad for them to do as was done to them, and slaving did not completely get thrown off the world until WW1 brought legalized slavery all to an end.)
The Communists still commit genocide by ethnicity in countries like China, as they did in Soviet times (ie Holodomor of Ukraine, Famine of Ethiopia, etc.)… Communists still slave, through work camps & concentration camps like former Soviets & North Korea & Cuba, sending laborers & military & doctors to kill & help others in exchange for hard currency to their sponsoring socialist government (while keeping family home so they don’t flee) like North Korea & Cuba & China.
That was not long ago for some of these, and fairly isolated to only a few nations today.
This has been a painful process to get here, and now we can talk to people around the world, instantaneously! 😀
Fundamentals are an important thing to conserve, when it is the bedrock of Western/Modern Civilization. It took us a long time to get here, with a lot of stumbling along the way. We live in a special time, never similarly experienced before in the history of the world. The fundamentals for where we are must not be lost.
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
Universal health care sux because only known treatments are paid for.. if you need a different treatment plan, you are on your own or traveling to another nation.
In the US, the poor & ages get universal health care, the middle class pays for it, the upper middle & rich pay for new health care options that gets invented, and everyone who is brought to a hospital gets serviced, regardless of ability to pay.
I pay a lot of money in premiums, which I seldom use, with family members paying 100% for other treatments that insurance does not cover. If I was in a universal health care system, new taxes would still go to the same system that I seldom use, and a lot of the treatments that we purchase would be outlawed… so many in the US are quite happy with not having universal health care.
5
-
5
-
@richardacevedo280 - “Is it time to limit the effort or totally pull out…”
I spent some time in Eastern Europe, as well.
Families in a Eastern Europe, who lost in wars against Russia, emigrate and fight along side other countries against Russia. This occurred for generations (ie Korean War, Vietnam, etc.) Support for delivering blank checks to Ukraine, from countries like the US, come from these generations of expatriates who are part of the political systems. Traditionally, they have been more conservative, fighting against the Communists, but it conservative politicians abandon them in their time of need, they may float to the politicians helping their homeland, and this is a very dumb political move to cede a massive voter base to progressives, and progressives want to write blank checks to capture this voter base.
Also, counties like The Ukraine have intrinsic value. They were the ones who built much of the tank, nuclear, and naval infrastructure for the Soviet Union. If The West wants that skill set to return to Russia, that is up to them, but if The West wants those skills, and the lower cost labor, then full NATO support is likely a much better option.
Then, there is the need for a food exporter. Whichever side controls the food exports from Ukraine, wields a lot of soft power around the world.
There are also precious minerals in the Ukraine, which Eastern & Western chip industries need to operate with, which are not readily found elsewhere.
Coal and Steel reserves are significant, and steel is important for ships, tanks, and general construction. Wherever these pieces of Ukraine show up, after the war, has the potential to become fairly rich. The same areas have natural gas reserves, so new smelters can be done with gas, in the future.
Ukraine also has some of the largest natural gas storage on the continent of Europe. Wherever Ukraine lands after the war, will control European land based energy storage systems.
Ukraine was seen as a future a Hydrogen partner for Europe, so wherever Ukraine lands after the war will help control a future energy supply for Europe.
Basically, Ukraine is a key to Central Europe, foreign nations tried to control them for thousands of years, and it is in The West’s best interest to have a free Ukraine instead of being enslaved to an antagonistic Russia controlling it.
5
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
The world hoped Russia would become more than they did, after they liberated themselves from the Communists, who slaughtered sizable civilian populations across two continents.
To be quite frank with you, Russia has a population problem. Killing hundreds of thousands in an Eastern European war is doing nothing for the population problem Russia has, and has weakened Russia.
Russia has squandered it’s military equipment & ammunition, slowly saved up since WW2, it is disappearing by the day, and the means of production to replace it fast enough does not exist on Russia’s 2x continents.
Cheap fossil fuels to India does not make an alliance.
Cheap fossil fuels to China (who can get fossil fuels from any other nation) & Russia outsourcing their production to China does not make Russia stronger.
Once China is satisfied with how weak need Russia becomes, China might take back some of the land China ceded to Russia via treaty.
At that point in time, Japan might take back their islands.
Other European countries may take back their naval base, as well.
Ukraine is likely to take back Crimea, denying Russia of another port… the Ukrainian port which Russia stole their sole aircraft carrier from. (Russia got many of their strategic bombers & missiles from Ukraine, after Western Powers made Ukraine concede them to Russia, for a lousy piece of paper that Russia & US & UK signed for the guarantee of Ukrainian borders.)
In the end, and I don’t know why, Russia spanning 2 continents has nothing but people willing to die for their motherland, when the motherland can not even provide toilets & washing machines for their peoples spanning 2 continents. Stolen or coerced nuclear, naval, aerial, and missile technology is the only difference between Russia of 2020’s and Russia of 1800’s.
What a disaster for Russian peoples. They were capable of so much more, but how many have already died in the Ukrainian meat grinder.
3
-
When trade routes become unsafe, civilization disintegrates.
If you think that the airline industry, shipping industry, tourist industries, relocating jobs, visiting families, mail, etc. are remotely possible without overseas bases & hard power… you would be sorely mistaken.
The US completely disbanded their military after the Revolutionary War… and it was the Islamic Slave Traders of Africa & Middle East who created a need for a standing military of the US, due to piracy. It was only after the US helped end of WW1 that Islamic Slave Trade was legally eradicated [with revival of multinational slave trade in lawless areas after the US Obama Administration in countries like Libya, Syria, Iraq, etc. through organizations like the Islamic State.)
Properly wielded Hard Power disrupts the most wicked of human behavior, while Hard Power restraint permits wicked behavior.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3