Comments by "Yo2" (@yo2trader539) on "What’s it like being Half Black in Japan?" video.

  1. Please stop attacking Asian people in the US.
    24
  2.  @simona4315  His ancestors are actually Chinese who migrated to Korea and later migrated to Japan.
    11
  3.  @Babadubab12  It's difficult to explain in words, but you can often guess from body language, facial expression, hand gesture, timing of "AIZUCHI" or conversational style, fashion, hairstyle, voice pitch, etc. (I thought his Japanese was native. It's the non-verbal component that is slightly different from kids who've grown up in Japan, regardless of ethnicity/nationality.)
    11
  4. I fear the first girl will always struggle in Japan. The second girl will likely be accepted and treated as Japanese by other Japanese.
    3
  5.  @Neophema  She also says she spent "Yochien" overseas. But I can't tell which part of her speech is Miyazaki-ben.
    3
  6. @@homie3461 Linguistically, there were many Japonic languages. Mainland Japanese or Yamato Japanese and Ryukyu language started to slowly diverge from around 1,500-1,700 years ago. So they are a dialect of each other. (There is also a category called Peninsular Japonic, which was spoken by the indigenous Japonic people in southern parts of the Korean peninsula in ancient times.) Modern standard Japanese is based on upper-society Eastern/Tokyo dialect.
    3
  7. @@homie3461 There are US bases in Yokosuka, Atsugi, Yokota, Misawa, Iwakuni, Sasebo...on mainland Japan, so I don't agree with your statement. Yes, indeed they are annoying and no local wants them. At the same, we all understand that Japan has signed three military alliances--with the UK, Germany, and currently the US--in the 20th century alone to counter-balance the Russian/Soviet threat. The benefit outweighs the cost, at least currently. Thus, I believe it's in Japan's interest to maintain the security alliance, especially with the increasing Chinese threat. Of all the prefectures, Okinawa is the most likely invasion target by the Chinese, so it does make sense to keep US forces in Okinawa (as the proverbial "Tripwire"). Also I don't think people in Tokyo have any desire to "suppress" Okinawa language/culture. The uniqueness of Okinawa is why it's the top vacation destination. Also, if Japonic is a language from Manchuria, in theory there should be more common cognates with Koreanic and Manchu (which also originate from Manchuria). But even the basic words do not overlap, so I'm not so convinced in the West Liao River hypothesis. The rice-farming and sea-faring Yayoi people (Y-DNA Haplogroup Group O1b2) who migrated to the Japanese Isle and Korean peninsula around 3,000-3,500 years ago do seem to have genetic lineage from around the Yangtze Basin. Their most common characteristic is low/weak alcohol tolerance, which is presumed to be a natural selection.
    2
  8. @@homie3461 Good points, and thanks for the clarification. I think the common joke is that "Language is a dialect with an Army and Navy." In other words, it's often times political categories than linguistic ones. Examples are like Thai and Laotian, Norwegian/Swedish/Danish, German and Dutch, Romanian and Moldovan, or even Spanish and Portuguese. If I recall in the field of linguistics, there is no concrete definition of language vs dialect. But some say high mutual intelligibility or common lexicon/cognates is the deciding factor between language vs dialect. As for proto-Japonic or "日琉祖語," we still don't know whether it's based on a Yayoi-language or a Jomon-language or a hybrid/pancake language. Phonetic similarity with some Austronesian/Polynesian languages, grammatical similarity with Turkic, Mongolic, Manchu, Koreanic, and a lot of unique Japanese cognates indicate that Japanese language is a hybrid language of the various people who moved to Japan from 38,000-40,000 years ago.
    2
  9.  @ductritran8637  Let's be real. TAIHO, MUROFUSHI Koji, MIYAZAWA Rie, TAMAKI Denny, HASEGAWA Jun, TAKIGAWA Christel, SAWAJIRI Erika, TAKAHASHI Ran, or SHIROTA Yu...endless amount of famous and successful half/mixed people in Japanese society. In other words, the discrimination is coming from the darker skin-tone. In summer times, many Japanese women use umbrellas and wear long sleeves to avoid getting tanned. As traditional make-up indicates, there is a strong aversion of darker skin-tone. It's implied that people who work in the fields are more tanned, which means the aversion has socio-economic and cultural roots. I've heard similar stories from South Koreans and Chinese when it comes to beauty standards.
    2
  10.  @Sunshine-zi4nq  May I ask what are the "three races" in Singapore? I've heard anecdotally that Singapore tries to unofficially maintain roughly 70% ethnic Chinese-ness through immigration, because there is a difference in birth-rate. I suspect ethnic Chinese tend to be more educated and have less children. Chinese, Malay, and what would be the third ethnic group?
    2
  11. 40% of Japanese carry the same genetics, which is Haplogroup D. Ainu have the highest D admixture. But they were mixed with Okhotsk people to varying degree.
    2
  12. ​ @Eli_Pinheiro Racism or Colourism is complicated, even in Japan too because it's not simply about shades of darkness. It's actually about everything. For instance, a Brazilian-national who has Italian/Russian/German ancestry may be treated differently or receive more privilege in Japan because they're more educated, wealthy, and well-mannered. But a Brazilian who is tattooed all over his body, no university education, and dresses like a thug could be stopped by Japanese police for Identification multiple times. They're not being treated differently because of their skin-tone but the skin-tone is often directly linked to socioeconomic class, education-level, mindset, behavior, and culture.
    2
  13.  @annunakian8054  You really need to travel more and experience the paperwork and bribes required.
    2
  14.  @sakurakou2009  R U sure with that definition. That would make many "African-Americans" not Black. And how are you supposed to categorize people in East Africa? Some of them look mixed with Arabs.
    2
  15. I didn't realize our relations were improving. We just ran a mock war game. We're all preparing for eventual war with China, and US is asking for Japanese cooperation to defend Taiwan. But Japan has no desire to be caught between Taiwan and China. Anyway, my best friend is half-Taiwanese and half-Japanese. He was born, raised, and educated in Japan. In school, nobody cared to be honest. Unless he mentions it specifically, nobody would notice either. It's not like we talk about family history. That said, I do remember that his mother's cooking was a little different. (It's hard to explain, but perhaps a little sweeter?)
    2
  16. He was a slave purchased from the Portuguese or Spanish, or a gift. He didn't have surname, which implies his social status. In terms of dark-skin people, we have records of Indian Buddhist monks who came during the Heian period, nearly a thousand years ago.
    1
  17.  @Rudysattva  No, not all Gaijin are treated the same way. If he is fluent in Japanese language, culture, and mannerism...he'll do fine. If he isn't, he'll be another extended tourist living in a expat bubble with limited contact with Japanese society. But I do think we differentiate and judge depending on ethnicity/nationality...based on collective experiences. Right now, we have a major problem with a ethnic Kurdish asylum-seekers. They're violent, dangerous, and frankly disgusting. Vietnamese and Chinese make up 60% of crimes committed by foreign nationals, so people have a poor view towards them. Others are usually Koreans, Brazilians, and Filipinos.
    1
  18.  @aimuaidehen1835  Angela didn't look like she was suffering from an identity crisis. She is culturally Japanese, which is why she will always be accepted in Japan. Her speech, mannerism, and mindset is no different from other Japanese. The first girl (Christy) is the one that appears struggling with her identity. The way she speaks, behaves, and dresses is exotic. It's not rare in the fashion, music, entertainment and nightlife business.
    1
  19. You're Canadian.
    1
  20. WTF?
    1
  21. From context he's saying "daitai...go-nen gurai wa" だいたい5年ぐらいは・・・
    1
  22. You're obviously not Japanese, nor have you ever received formal education in Japan. I've never met a Nihonjin who believes they descend from Amaterasu...because that's the same as saying they're offshoots of the Imperial Family. You're a typical Gaijin. FYI, Yayoi people started arriving in Japanese Isle and Korean peninsula around 3,500-3,000 years ago. Their unique rice-farming culture, pottery, architecture, tombs, mythology, clothing, and genetic traits indicate some similarities with rice-farming people in Southern China and Southeast Asia.
    1
  23.  @Sunshine-zi4nq  Thank you. I had no idea there is an Indian diaspora in Singapore too. I've met somebody from HK, though.
    1
  24. It goes both ways. Asians are discriminated in Europe, but they get physically attacked and robbed by Blacks in the US. When a White police officer shoots a Black guy in LA, the Blacks burn downed Korea town. Most of the attacks on Asians in the US after COVID were from Blacks. Half of the prison inmates in the US are either Black or Brown. That's just the reality.
    1
  25. It's exposure (or lack of). I was surprised too when I first met a Chinese-French person. Since I've never lived in France, I had no idea there was such a community. Everything about her was very French. How she walked, talked, behaved...
    1
  26. Actually majority are half-Japanese and half-Asian. The next group would be half-European/White. Half-black is extremely rare combination. We have a lot of famous half-Japanese celebrities and politicians. Current governor of Okinawa is half-American. Yokozuna Taiho was half-Ukranian born in Karafuto.
    1
  27. That's BS.
    1
  28. At least they don't get attacked by Blacks like the Asians in the US.
    1
  29. Your segment?
    1