Comments by "The SMR" (@SergyMilitaryRankings) on "Historian GETS MAD at All Quiet on the Western Front (2022)" video.

You can tell this guys never been in combat to think the gore is cartoonish
4
@hrmpug1092 yes, I work with MSF or doctors without borders, I've treated civilians in Yemen whilst our camp was being shelled, I've worked in Syrian hospitals when the government was barraging the area with artillery and treated soldiers in south Sudan whilst our encampment was under fire from rebel groups, I myself have been injured by shrapnel in Syria, my face, I nearly lost my vision, it was very close to my eye. Wounds from bullets, shrapnel and blasts from explosives, absolutely wreck the body, a high calibre rifle wound like a 5.56 or .308 can literally rip the flesh of the bones, I've seen a what must have been a .50 cal wound that looked like the person had a swallowed a grenade. This film is incredibly accurate in its gore and how it shows the absolute fear and constant stress effects people, constantly thinking that at any point a shell or bullet can hit you destroys your mental well-being, I'm okay because I get to go back to my nice first world life, these people in war zones don't have that luxury.
3
@dendemano you sound like someone who's never seen real combat or thinks combat is gunning down farmers with AKs with air support, artillery and tanks, I've worked in hospitals that were under fire, people like you get to go back to a nice cushy barracks with air conditioning, game consoles, TVs, the works. But tbh you sound like the only combat you've ever seen is playing team Death match on call of duty, which is why you're trying to sound tough when literally nobody asked, people like you are laughed at, social media warrior.
1
@hrmpug1092 where did he say that ?
1
This movie is a great example, this guy is clueless and has never been in combat
1
This movie is the perfect example of what real combat is like, but I understand people who haven't been in combat wouldn't get that
1