General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About

Inoovator
VisualPolitik EN
comments

Comments by "Inoovator" (@inoovator3756) on "Why shouldn't ISRAEL EXPAND its TERRITORY? - VisualPolitik EN" video.

The international community promised to protect Israel from Lebanon and they did nothing when Hezbollah attacked
67
@DevSarman which is also collapsing as we speak
36
That's why it won't ever happen
17
They did
13
@Omer1996E.C the Arabs
7
@SpykerSpeed Mexicans don't get to vote in American elections, guess this means America is an evil country or some shit Palestinians have their own elections which Israelis can't vote in, why are you ok with this?
7
@muhammadyaseen13002 how do you occupy your own land?
5
Retro Ads Channel all Jews can stay in Israel that's the point
4
@G0TIMAN yes all the Ethiopian Jews have to go to Europe
4
@muhammadyaseen13002 because Jews are from Israel not Poland or Germany. Many Palestinians today live in Chile so does the same logic apply there?
4
@eternal2780 not really, it's just a response to rockets being fired from those areas
4
@freedomsong9747 the funny thing is that martin Luther king was a huge supporter of Israel unlike you yet you're quoting him
4
@Omer1996E.C Jews don't speak Arabic why would it be Arabic speaking
4
Agreed
3
@ranvorms2242 He sounds like a classic American liberal who has no idea how the world works outside of his bubble, and he projects his worldview onto situations where it doesn't apply
3
@DriftRacing77 what is Palestinian land exactly?,
3
@freedomsong9747 you cannot force Israelis and Palestinians into one state when they don't want that arrangement. That's like saying the solution between Armenia and Azerbaijan is one state for both. You are being delusional my friend. You are asking for Israel to willingly become a failed state which they will never accept
3
@SpykerSpeed So you admit that you hate Jewish people. At least you're honest
3
@wanistani like they did in Gaza? What did that achieve other than Hamas taking over?
3
He's not Israeli you said it yourself he's from NYC
3
@muhammadyaseen13002 why would they agree to that?
2
@freedomsong9747 Not at all, if you think south Africa is an example of different groups living peacefully side by side you know nothing about the country. The racial tensions in SA are very high and there are plenty of examples of racially motivated attacks all the time Not to mention that south Africa is a failed state through and through that probably will not survive a few more decades. Seeing what happened to south Africa is a great example of why your solution is an awful awful idea
2
@mallari1224 this is already the arrangement in the border between Israel and Lebanon and it is a complete failure
2
@freedomsong9747 ah so you admit south Africa failed at least we are getting somewhere. So since you know it failed why should Israel repeat the same thing and allow the country to fail?
2
@freedomsong9747 peace is good but doesn't mean you have to be dumb about it. Sometimes you have to accept that peace isn't possible and live with it
2
@freedomsong9747 I bet you have never been to Israel and have gotten all your news from Al Jazeera or something. I invite you to come and see for yourself that what you are saying is nonsense
2
@freedomsong9747 You make it sound so easy, yet you will never suffer the consequences of what you are advocating while Israelis and Palestinians will
2
@immortalwombat7095 there was no south Sudan 20 years ago. So what?
2
@kissimak8853 All Jews originate from Judea that's why they are called Jews
2
@chiron13 it's already proven that Ashkenazis have majority levantine DNA regardless
2
@chiron13 The majority of Israelis are mizrahi and have no connection to Europe whatsoever If you think all Arabs are Bedouins it's quite obvious you have no idea what's going on
2
@freedomsong9747 I don't understand why you keep bringing up south Africa. Israel is not south Africa and there is no connection whatsoever
2
@freedomsong9747 South Africa failed completely and the rest of the states you listed are culturally homogeneous where the people don't have a history of conflict with each other lasting decades
2
Why did it not happen yet?
2
@freedomsong9747 I'm sorry but a song is not going to solve one of the mot complicated conflicts
2
@freedomsong9747 Nelson Mandela and martin Luther king both supported Israels right to exist unlike you yet you quote them
2
@freedomsong9747 Israel is already a democracy so the solution is already in place
2
@Purple Hearth not really In international law, there is a principle in international law referred to as Uti Possidetus Juris, literally translating to “as you possess,” a Roman legal doctrine first cited in private municipal law. Uti Possidetus Juris maintains that when a new country is created where there was not a separate country previously, the borders of the new country are identical to the borders of the last top-level geopolitical entity in that territory. Professor Kontorovich illustrated this concept with the example of Crimea, which the international community regards as currently occupied by Russia but truly part of Ukraine. The reason for this international consensus is that Ukraine declared independence upon the dissolution of the USSR–the last top geopolitical entity in the territory–thus taking on boundaries that included within it the newly-constituted independent Ukraine. In May 1948, Israel declared its independence, meaning that by the accepted legal principle of Uti Possidetis Juris, the new state inherited the same borders as Mandatory Palestine, which came before it, specifically the land from the Jordan River to the Mediterranean Sea. It is important to note that Palestine did not declare statehood when Israel did. Instead, they willingly handed their fate to invading armies of a combined Arab force drawn from neighboring states. If the Palestinians had declared independence, then the two forces would have fought for the power to govern the new state with borders set by the mandate. However, that legal fight for governance never materialized. Therefore, when we apply the rule of international law that is used to determine the borders of all new countries, Israel must be recognized as the only successor entity to the mandate.
2
@angrybanana5476 they can't since the Muslims kicked them out lol that's why they're in Israel
2
@freedomsong9747 Israel never took over anyone's homeland so your hypothetical doesn't even apply How would you feel if a foreigner who has never been to your country demanded for your homeland to become a failed state? That's what you're doing right now
2
It's part of Israel
2
@freedomsong9747 Israel is already one man one vote, everyone in Israel can vote whether Jewish or Arab. The bantustans you are talking about is a separate country with UN representation hence it cannot be one by definition
2
@XtoCee They literally do have voting rights. There is a Palestinian party in the ruling Israeli coalition as we speak look up the United Arab list
2
@namarahasia3762 give me an example of something a Palestinian with Israeli citizenship cannot do that a Jew with Israeli citizenship can then
2
@freedomsong9747 you know the one state will work? What makes you so sure? The one state completely failed everywhere it has been tried
2
@freedomsong9747 I literally just showed you a source explaining how the Joshua story didn't actually happen
2
@muhammadyaseen13002 you're literally spouting conspiracy theories at this point Look I get it you're Arab so you were probably raised by your parents to hate Israel which is fine I can't undo the brainwashing but at least try to be objective here
2
@jamesbedukodjograham5508 it is indeed
2
@jamesbedukodjograham5508 in that case they would have accepted the multiple offers that Israel gave them instead of rejecting all of them and resorting to terrorism
2
@freedomsong9747 Have you ever been to Israel to see the situation for yourself? Yes or no?
2
@freedomsong9747 they pretty much were untill 1967, and they had no issue being under Egyptian or Jordanian rule
2
Completely agreed
2
@freedomsong9747 I don't understand you're question or what you are trying to prove by asking it
2
@freedomsong9747 are you not aware that before 1967 Gaza was part of Egypt and the west bank part of Jordan? This already happened before I'm saying the solution is to return to that arrangement. They wouldn't be stateless since they will become part of those states
2
@freedomsong9747 No, historians have proved that the Israelites evolved out of the Canaanites and are a Canaanite group. This is why Hebrew is a Canaanite language, the only one still spoken in the world
2
@freedomsong9747 Either Egypt annexes Gaza and the west bank is split between Israel and Jordan or the Mordecai Kadir Emirates system is implemented one or the other
2
@freedomsong9747 what you are doing is spreading blatant lies for no reason
2
@muhammadyaseen13002 No I'm just pointing out that you have an inherent bias. If Palestinians weren't Muslim you wouldn't give a shit about them
1
@Purple Hearth the wmd thing was not about the gulf war you're thinking about the Iraq war in 2003 At this point it shows you're historically clueless
1
@freedomsong9747 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israelites "Based on the archaeological evidence, according to the modern archaeological account, the Israelites and their culture did not overtake the region by force, but instead branched out of the indigenous Canaanite peoples that long inhabited the Southern Levant, Syria, ancient Israel, and the Transjordan region[10][11][12] through a gradual evolution of a distinct monolatristic—later cementing as monotheistic—religion centered on Yahweh. "
1
@muhammadyaseen13002 they already do, all Israelis are citizens of Israel
1
@freedomsong9747 Are you saying that the bible is a historical source that should be taken literally?
1
@freedomsong9747 Inequality persists everywhere on the planet. It's not something that can be fixed completely, blaming everything on inequality is not going to fix the issue But either way you tried to make it seem like south Africa is a racial utopia when it is everything but. So why would Israel allow itself to turn into another failed state with racial riots springing up every few months?
1
@freedomsong9747 most people who read the bible don't take it literally like you are trying to
1
The Mizrahis Jews who are the majority there belong to Europe?
1
How? No power cares enough about this to start a world war
1
@ChickenVeggi tbh it's already been solved. Most Israelis don't really care about it anymore it's something they see on the news and that's it
1
@freedomsong9747 The ADL has calculated that over 90 percent of Palestinians are anti semitic, cramming them into a state full of people that they hate will cause a civil war. Your idea is absurd hence no one takes it seriously
1
@underratedbollywoodactors6534 You haven't shown any proof of a genocide though, you're making a very big claim without any evidence to back it up
1
@underratedbollywoodactors6534 the British didn't commit genocide either, they subjugated you yes but genocide no
1
@namarahasia3762 vast majority of Jews in Israel were born there
1
@jamesbedukodjograham5508 agreed
1
@underratedbollywoodactors6534 how much has the population reduced as a result of this genocide?
1
@muhammadyaseen13002 Arab is not a nationality lmao there is no nation called arab
1
@muhammadyaseen13002 ur name is quite telling that you are an Arab lol. Like I don't get what's the point of lying about it
1
@MSNskills What do you mean Gaza? Israel doesn't send anyone into Gaza
1
@MSNskills Israel never wanted to invade south Lebanon, the war started after Lebanon kidnapped an Israeli soldier
1
All Israelis have equal rights lol
1
@chazm100 proof?
1
@yobabydaddyismine not what genetics show
1
@MSNskills So how did Lebanon win if they are currently a failed state? What did they win exactly?
1
@MSNskills how did they lose exactly? Lebanon can't even afford basic electricity lol
1
But all Israelis have equal rights
1
@madara8515 Not true at all, all citizens have equal rights by law. There's even a Palestinian party in the ruling coalition in the government
1
@madara8515 No they can't do that lol, I legit have no idea where you got this idea Property rights are protected in the country It doesn't even make sense that it's colonialism since Jews are indegenous to the land
1
@madara8515 the examples you gave were cases where Israelis really did own the property prior to it being confiscated in the 1948 war and they had the legal documents to prove it. But either way it was settled and no Palestinians lost their homes there No one ethnically cleansed anyone nor did they settle there since you can't settle somewhere that you are already indegenous to. It's a fact that Jews originate from Israel
1
@sruliperelmam9132 I agree with you it's a great country lol I'm on your side
1
@freedomsong9747 or the alternative is Egypt taking Gaza and Jordan the west bank and let the story end there
1
How would they do that exactly? Israel has nukes lol the world would literally end
1
@SpykerSpeed because crazy leftists have taken over those countries
1
@Purple Hearth why?
1
@Purple Hearth not if it's a legal expansion
1
@freedomsong9747 their native language Hebrew There is no such thing as an Arab Jew though
1
@TheMagnificentGman trust me I know
1
@Purple Hearth what country are they building in?
1
@Purple Hearth Crimea was an example of how Russia was wrong since Crimea belonged to Ukraine the same way all of the former mandate is legally part of Israel
1
@Purple Hearth Arabs lived there longer? Arabs only came after the 600s AD meanwhile Jews where there during Babylonian times
1
@Purple Hearth the gulf war was started by Israels ally the US lol
1
@Purple Hearth Who is going to invade Israel? Give me the name of a country?
1
@Purple Hearth no not really, Israel never invaded any country unlike what Iraq did
1
@Purple Hearth who will invade Israel in defense of Palestine? WHO IS GOING TO DO IT????? Give me the name of a single country who would be willing to do this
1
@Purple Hearth When did Israel invade Syria?
1
@Purple Hearth You can't even tell me who is going to do this You seem to be forgetting that the gulf war only started because the enemy of America Saddam invaded Kuwait whose oil was very vital to America's economy hence America retaliated to stop them. Meanwhile Palestine does not have any oil or natural resources that countries rely on not to mention that Israel is an American ally. Not only that but Israel is nuclear capable hence no country will ever invade since they know they would be destroyed. No one will invade Israel don't worry
1
@Purple Hearth That was after Syria declared war on Israel in both wars By your logic Poland invaded Germany in WW2 and stole German land
1
@Purple Hearth so you're saying that America, the greatest ally of Israel, will invade them? Is that actually what you believe will happen?
1
@Purple Hearth but sure we can bet on it if you actually believe this will happen
1
@Omer1996E.C Yes true Jews spoke Arabic because of colonialism but luckily Jews were able to go back to speaking their native language
1
@Purple Hearth Syria declared war before Israel ever took the Golan what are you talking about?
1
@Purple Hearth and you're still ignoring the fact that Israel most likely possesses nuclear armaments so no one will invade just because of that
1
@Purple Hearth what about the Democrats, I don't get what you're trying to say
1
@Purple Hearth falling for what? I'm just stating facts for you man
1
@kissimak8853 eh not really, for example a prominent Palestinian family are the Masris whose name literally means from Egypt, so they only migrated recently
1
@freedomsong9747 I'm not listening to your stupid song that's going to magically solve a conflict that lasts decades
1
@srelma No they definitely do not, you're just blatantly saying false things
1
@chiron13 they won't
1
@chiron13 eh, look up the six day war
1
@srelma they do control their borders I'm not sure what you're talking about. There is a hard border between Israel and Gaza for example
1
@srelma over 100 countries recognize it. They have a seat at the UN, why are you just making stuff up?
1
@srelma Palestine is an independent country, they have their own government and soveirgn territory
1
@chiron13 there's some mix yes but mostly levantine the same way many levantine Arabs have a mix with other Arab groups
1
@chiron13 they mixed with Arabs from the Arabian peninsula so by your logic they are also settlers
1
@MegaMURRAY123 by killing gay people?
1
@srelma that's like saying how would you describe a system where Canadians don't have equal rights to Americans. No shit Israelis live in Israel and Palestinans live in Palestine so they aren't Israeli citizens
1
@srelma there is no such system so Israelis don't care
1
@immortalwombat7095 are you seriously saying that the rockets that killed dozens of people are fireworks?
1
@immortalwombat7095 show me the source that white phosphorus killed hundreds White phosphorus is not illegal in war if it's used as a smoke cover which is what Israel did "The International Committee of the Red Cross urged Israel to exercise "extreme caution" in using the incendiary agent, which is used to illuminate targets at night or create a smoke screen for day attacks, said Peter Herby, the head of the organization's mines-arms unit. "In some of the strikes in Gaza it's pretty clear that phosphorus was used," Herby told The Associated Press. "But it's not very unusual to use phosphorus to create smoke or illuminate a target. We have no evidence to suggest it's being used in any other way." In response, the IDF said Tuesday that it "wishes to reiterate that it uses weapons in compliance with international law, while strictly observing that they be used in accordance with the type of combat and its characteristics." Herby said that using phosphorus to illuminate a target or create smoke is legitimate under international law, and that there was no evidence the Jewish state was intentionally using phosphorus in a questionable way, such as burning down buildings or knowingly putting civilians at risk. "
1
@immortalwombat7095 so you admit that you lied, at least we're getting somewhere
1
@immortalwombat7095 This is called moving the goalposts. You lied and I called you out on it and instead you're saying the lie doesn't matter because of some other random reason. Just admit you lied and move on
1
@SuperSupersoda Moving the goalposts is an informal fallacy in which evidence presented in response to a specific claim is dismissed and some other (often greater) evidence is demanded. That is, after an attempt has been made to score a goal, the goalposts are moved to exclude the attempt.[11] The problem with changing the rules of the game is that the meaning of the result is changed, too
1
@freedomsong9747 they never used to together in harmony I have no idea where you got that idea. Jews were always considered inferior to other Muslims and were legally second class citizens as well as regularly being massacred
1
@mallari1224 that's already a thing. For example https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Arab_List They're even in the government coalition Also this https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joint_List https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Arab_members_of_the_Knesset
1
@ammaryasser90 source?
1
@immortalwombat7095 they did play a role look up the alliance between hitler and Husseini
1
@kissimak8853 Yes, since America stole Mexican land in the Mexican American war
1
@freedomsong9747 there are people who identity as basque yet they live in Spain. same with the Kurds, it'll become the same situation
1
@muhammadyaseen13002 look it's right here https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israel
1