General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About

Jjk Jjk
VisualEconomik EN
comments

Comments by "Jjk Jjk" (@JjkJjk-or9kc) on "Why Are Muslim Countries Poorer? - VisualEconomik EN" video.

 @محمدالقحطاني-س1ق4ف it's right why else would they hire from the west then
6
 @HolyknightVader999 there can be arab names who aren't muslim you know
4
And the funny thing is those countries you mentioned are all richer
3
The golden age can't be replicated today, it wasn't able to bring industrialiation
2
 @ibnMuharis. all built on outdated models for the modern world
2
Plenty of Islamist laws check your legal system
2
 @silentbyte196 it does cause lower int"llig"nce
2
Socialism never works
2
 @GrigRP that blaphemy thing covers a majority of freedoms and you forgot political and cultural oppression not to mention various restrictions on not just speech but other things
1
Most islamic countries today are not secular at all ,compare an average non muslim secular country to a so called secular muslim country you will see the difference
1
They wouldn't be able to emulate it,that golden age wasn't able to bring in industrialiation and they are still more reactionary, conservative and religious than the rest of the world
1
Lol because it worked in the medieval ages won't work in the modern world
1
 @I_hu85ghjo but they progressed y'all didn't
1
 @norikofu509 even latin american ones are doing better
1
Egypt is poor Malaysia is ok due to the Chinese turkey is secular
1
You said Egypt is rich you can't be taken seriously
1
By what metric is it more pious
1
The reason for less secularism in that part of the world is due to low industrialisation
1
The leaders which enforce religion
1
 @adrianainespena5654 not really, mid level petrostate
1
Nope they aren't lol
1
The reason is more influence of religion and why is that the case? because of low industrialisation hence religion being more pervasive
1
 @scienceandartclub Malaysia is ok due to the Chinese
1
Lol all oil ones
1
Even the european and the Latin American countries are more developed
1
If Allah saved them why not afg
1
You do know that most of that is private debt right?and it cant be asked back because most of it is in dollars?and if it was the most poorest you wouldn't be using YouTube right
1
Malaysia is ok because of the Chinese
1
 @hubiraithegreat check out indonesia gdp per capita or hdi, it's not that much in the way of industrialisation as well, mostly relying on law value manufacturing and natural resources
1
Not really It's religion,these are all textbook economic issues
1
@silentbyte196 Liberal economics require open societies which islam is against
1
Nope medieval systems will not bring you prosperity there's a reason ottomans were called the sick man of Europe
1
 @silentbyte196 the islamic golden age had. Public atheists and rationalists
1
@فاطمةالزهراء-خ3ن lol all the oil ones
1
Lol correctly? it's still forced
1
 @silentbyte196 his priority of iskam against science was the downfall
1
@luke_ok_goot ok tell me the objections
1
@Brightlight-bd9jc but why are their countries richer
1
Those are all oil petrodollar ones
1
How is it more pious?turks are becoming less religious day by day due to erdogan
1
 @hubiraithegreat indonesia is poor
1
@ibnMuharis. well yes that's what I said ,those are unfit for the industrial revolution, weren't able to industrialise,the avg guy lived a peasant life,not anywhere comparable to today,if you apply the same model today you get Afghanistan or at the very best iran that's it
1
Only Malaysia indonesia and turkey are non oil countries and turkey is secular, indonesia is poor Malaysia is ok due to the Chinese
1
Nope look at china
1
 @faizan-gamerz-z4f they are oil petro states
1
Turkey is secular Malaysia is ok because of the Chinese
1
Doesn't make sense most of them have no sanctions
1
Gadaffi libya was a poor petrostate what did he do
1
Gadaffi was overthrown by his own citizens
1
Lol gadaffi had sanctions lifted in the 2000s
1
Lol those are all oil ones except Malaysia which is ok due to the Chinese
1
 @GrigRP you do realise it's preferable than isl"m"St Countries where due to Poverty women are victims of tr"fi"k"ng right?
1
@GrigRP nope isl"m"St countries have much more restrictions on irreligion and anyone acting out of religion,not to mention much less political and economic freedom due to being poor
1
Turkey is not becoming more pious
1
 @GrigRP vast majority of the world?china and russia don't enforce religion tf you talking about
1
@GrigRP it doesn't matter,why do you think people from the isl"m"at sh"th"les risk their lives on dangerous waters c"Ming to the west and why do m"st of th"m want to m"ve if given a change according to surveys, because ultimately it doesn't matter,bread and water issues are much more important and opportunities, that's why china and russia don't force religion too and have more open cultures
1
 @GrigRP nope but it's better than being INBr"d s"lf c"mbust"r pd" ,you don't see people r"sking their lives to m"ve to Egypt
1
 @grahamstrouse1165 you do realise it's preferable than isl"m"St Countries where due to Poverty women are victims of tr"fi"k"ng right?
1
@SY82010 very poor labour participation rate
1
Then why do abd""ls move to w"st
1
@ibnMuharis. no it didn't already in. 1700,prior to colonialism the middle east Only constituted 2 pct of the world gdp
1
 @gjjhgyhh6036 military tech doesn't relate to devlopment just look at the 2 countries you mentioned who got their tech from north korea btw
1
Oil ones or poor or not Islamist
1
@I_hu85ghjo no they aren't,name the democratic ones ,go ahead, democratic in name only with no democracy don't count just like north korea,most of them are ruled by theocrats,juntas , autocrats etc none of these systems support the pillars of democracy Researchers have already done research and the islamic world is less democratic than average,their research shows
1
@I_hu85ghjo democracy is not essential yet but accountability is and so is secularism Look at china they are not democratic but they are secular,ofc other factors along with these matter too
1
@I_hu85ghjo any proof of the first one? which ones of them support freedom of press , freedom of thought, freedom of religion, transparent elections,strong non political institutions, freedom of dissent etc?
1
@I_hu85ghjo if you don't like democracy why are you on YouTube expressing your political opinion lmao there's no benefit of living under a tyrant why else would you force your religion Tyrant etc on me
1
@I_hu85ghjo democracy has created the most prosperity in the world
1
@silentbyte196 economy?you mean social democracy because that's the closest economically and even they failed?and all those countries forced religion socially
1
@silentbyte196 majority of countries have had no major large scale war
1
@silentbyte196 Afghanistan suffers due to disincentive of education
1
@silentbyte196 gadaffi didn't change anything he was sucking up to the west, Libya wasn't even as rich as uae
1
You played yourself plenty of Latin American countries are richer and only the non Sharia parts of malaysia are ok
1
@user-op8fg3ny3j it's federal the sh"th"le parts have restrictions for m"sl"ms,the wealthy parts are ch"n"se d"min"ted ,the sh"th"le laws are only applied to m"sl"ms hence the ok areas tend to have less affected by them as those are ch"n"se d"m"nated
1
@user-op8fg3ny3j the sh"th"le law is not applicable to the n"ns , Sarawak, Penang and kl are the which are the only ok ones in the whole country these are all where hence the sh"th"le laws are only applied to m"sl"ms and thus affect low numbers
1
@user-op8fg3ny3j you don't know malaysia,look up keleantan and other related special legal areas ,all sh"th"les
1
@user-op8fg3ny3j cuz the nons c"ntr"l the economy despite having obstacles in the legal code
1
@silentbyte196 it's poor compared to the world standard and hasn't industrialised
1
 @RapMusic490 monarchy and fascism started those now look at the present world
1
 @محمدالقحطاني-س1ق4ف it does that's why they are not innovative
1
You can't compare the middle ages to today's world lmao today's development is required to be much more dynamic and fast growing because we live in an industrialised world The same model cant work in an industrialised world lmao
1
 @DaddyM7MD indonesia is poor,uae still runs on oil money I mean there's no significant private sector neither has rhe whole country diversified just dubai
1
Turkey is secular, Malaysia is ok because of the Chinese
1
No wonder they are the most industrialised in the region
1
Nope it's because religion is forced
1
 @silentbyte196 gdp doesn't matter in regards to it's dependence, it's a petrostate
1
By each metric
1
@I_hu85ghjo carried? plenty of third w"rld isl"m"St sh"th"les get heavy aid and money and are still poor including military one lmao
1
Also secularism , israel is not ruled by the ultra orthodox
1
@I_hu85ghjo they got rich due to having strong High tech sectors and industrialisation tell me which of yo cult c"ountries have that
1
No they don't example afg
1
 @silentbyte196 lol most of them force religion either culturally or legally but ok
1
@silentbyte196 iran has plenty of partners like china and Russia which are huge powers not to mention it's own economic policy is bad due to socialism and constraining people's Liberty that's why they can't develop a viable private sector,the sanctions have been applied since decades yet their economy peaked in the 2000s
1
Because turkey is secular
1
Why?that still leaves a vast m"j"rity which are sh"th"les
1
Because the religious laws don't apply to the Chinese lol
1
 @systemreactive4092 in the poor states that's the argument
1
@systemreactive4092 nope in those countries those laws apply to everyone
1
@systemreactive4092 so aren't plenty of m"sl"ms in non countries
1
@systemreactive4092 that's why Malaysia is ok because those laws don't apply to a major part of the country
1
@systemreactive4092 afg is a failed state where those laws apply to everyone
1
@AmirAhmed-l8t wrong it's still forced today
1
Nope even china and russia don't force religion
1
But you can Play western haram video games like fortnte which contains g"re and n$fw?
1
 @tasumartinz1837 nope it's not just look at Afghanistan complete cope
1
@gjjhgyhh6036 yes those are prerequisites to industrialisation so you agree with me
1
China is anti west so is Russia both are more prosperous even cuba lol
1