Comments by "Matthew Tuckman" (@matthewtuckman4447) on "Whatifalthist" channel.

  1.  @tomasmarcataio2066  well Whatifaltist isnt very imaginitve or dosent think too much when debating alternate history say compared to Alternatehistoryhub, Musiuer Z and such but he is right about somethings that were real, hes more rational and realistic or hes trying to be but hes still pretty good
    16
  2.  @mattnaka6437  eccept 27,000,000 out of 180,000,000 Russians died 13% of the population but there was still 87% of them left over 153,000,000 still plenty of people to have kids they could easily recover from that had Stalin lived longer Russia would fully recover from ww2 and much emphasis on the civilian economy and infrastructure and Marshall plan Stalin plan to do rebuild eastern Europe and Russia repairing destroyed infrastructure so in the 1950s and 60s if Stalin lived longer Russia could have a massive population and economic boom like America their birthrate would be high combined with modern medicine Russias population would skyrocket by the 1990s Russias population could be around 300,000,000 more than twice the population and by the present day 360,000,000 more than Americas.
    8
  3.  @exaid0556  unless the Soviets invaded Germany then itd be different
    7
  4.  @Mattavilasa  he got hit by a wagon so his arm had issues for the rest of his life
    6
  5. Or if Yeltsin was assassinated in August 1991?
    5
  6.  @mattnaka6437  still there were other reasons such as too much military spending, being a developed country, the USSR collapsing due to Gorbachev allowing freedom of speech and gang of 8 or August coup causing chaos and confusion within the government leading to Kazakhstan, Ukraine, the Caucasus and its other territory now former Republics wich were allways part of Russia, Khrushchevs economic reforms and failed land projects, Yeltsins corruption ect
    5
  7. It wasn't really Communism itself that destroyed or retarded this promising Russia but poor decisions by the Soviet leaders
    4
  8.  @Volunteer-per-order_OSullivan  true but China could still conventionally help North Vietnam even if America nuked them or Russia could still take most of western europe even if America nuked them unless they nuke the capital and cut off the head of the government causing the regime to collapes maybe who knows
    3
  9.  @hadtrio6629  ok
    2
  10.  @allthenewsordeath5772  what if someone who is independent is not loyal to a country, flag or any ideology but to themselves, where you stand on that?
    2
  11.  @hadtrio6629  Morocco
    2
  12.  @ggkproductions1632  well in another video "what if Japan invaded Russia"
    2
  13.  @ggkproductions1632  even if eastern Europe did fall remember he said with the former Japanese Empire the US still has a massive global empire
    2
  14.  @richardcheek2432  robots and humans will work simultaneously
    2
  15. Russia possibly could won the race to the moon if that were and there would be a red hammer and sickle banner on the moon and not a stars and strips banner.
    2
  16. Actually if the Japenese invaded southeast Asia just being careful not to step on the toes of the Americans or Russians, the Japanese would most likely take most of east asia evan a war against the British or French without the Americans or Russians to reinforce them the Japanese would most likely win and Japan would have a massive global empire rivaling Britains and France's.
    2
  17.  @mansory7996  true but i gotta say as horrible Stalin was he was still competent
    2
  18.  @mansory7996  ?
    2
  19.  @mattnaka6437  yes very true it contributed a good deal but it wasn't the biggest reason had the USSR survived it couldve bounced back earlier than it did now its starting to bounce back to the 25 year cycle is now beginning to stop.
    2
  20.  @baelonthebrave5474  it couldve been different
    2
  21.  @justinarzola4584  Central Asia Kazakhs Uzbeks and such, North Asia Yakuts Chuchki and such,
    2
  22.  @sionantara370  Ottoman Empire, Republic of Turkey, Russian Empire, Soviet Union, Russian Federation, Qing Empire, Republic of China, Peoples Republic of China, Mesopotamia, Babylon, Roman Empire, Roman Republic, Roman Kingdom, other nation states, different times
    2
  23.  @amitassasson1893  ok
    1
  24.  @ArkadiBolschek  theyed reform
    1
  25.  @sam8742  true they can
    1
  26.  @sam8742  some might some might not
    1
  27.  @gavinwang7886  Ottoman Empire was Turkey at the time
    1
  28.  @popopop984  Russia is authoritarian
    1
  29.  @allthenewsordeath5772  who says that
    1
  30.  @allthenewsordeath5772  i see but id hate to say this but some people don't care
    1
  31.  @allthenewsordeath5772  why do we need to
    1
  32.  @allthenewsordeath5772  oh thats alright i thought the essay was interesting
    1
  33. Zrrnd Zan Thats Darth Vader
    1
  34.  @zarzarbinks1705  created another problem
    1
  35.  @MrHanderson91  ha ha ha that's funny
    1
  36. Aaro Halme im curious, are you saying its possible that the Japanese would be the largest majority in their Empire
    1
  37.  @aarohalme1020  oh ok, my apologies i misunderstood
    1
  38. @Brandon  the working population will shrink because most youth will be Stoners alot of people will have kids but not get together or even get married there will be a break for the Man Woman thing, people won't get together Bros before Hoes alot of young people say that the next generations will also say it more and more people will say it. Marriage will be less popular or common than it is right now.
    1
  39.  @zarzarbinks1705  big mistake just like the Mujahadeen
    1
  40. @Richard Cheek  there have been robots since the 1970s there have been humans then for maintenance and they're will be in the 2030s
    1
  41.  @mattnaka6437  the birthrate could recover from that
    1
  42.  @EvilParagon4  in my opinion not worth it i prefer a totalitarian dictatorship
    1
  43.  @antares2840  maybe
    1
  44.  @antares2840  guess there are too many factors that affect it, i accept the truth but i cant accept the world for what it is or my place in it
    1
  45.  @kimehrenschiold1693  they could've recovered from it had Stalin lived longer
    1
  46. Actually Yakutsk is an indigenous native Siberian people
    1
  47.  @mansory7996  exactly they focused on themselves and under Stalin, Russia went down a Nationalistic direction
    1
  48. They wouldn't even be in the war if the Japanese didn't attack them.
    1
  49.  @theArab__  you need the right individuals in charge its all about the decisions that the leaders make, so in this sense ideology is meaningless
    1
  50.  @gunter6377  yes exactly Russia could've had a high population today of 360,000,000 if Stalin lived longer
    1