Comments by "" (@BharatThatIsIndia) on "Modi govt's U-turn on lateral entry in civil service: Why it failed u0026 a case for such reform" video.

Shekhar ji, Donot you think the Jinn of Reservation was bring back by Modi ji himself in 2019 by EWS reservation and then our great SC(!?) found out a technical way to allow 50+%, that too without any survey, any proper data which was sought in case of Jaat and Maratha reservation. What did everyone (OBC, SC/ST) think about this? What did Maratha,Jaat, etc think about this? Before that almost everyone has accepted 50% limit criteria and der was no sympathy for anyone who were raising reservation issues. If you remember, that private job reservation and reservation in promotion was made fun off. I was against OBC reservation and thaught after year 2005, atleast Yadav's don't belong to OBC. They are already empowered. I used to BJP voter and one of the main reason was that BJP and RSS will not support reservation and will work on growth, privatisation. But I was proven wrong by Modi ji in 2019. I saw my friends and media reporting of that time. Except very few, no-one has written anything against it. However, I was 100% sure that SC will reject this on basis of 50% limit added by them only. I was proven so wrong. Now, Rahul Gandhi (RJD-JDU first) supported the increase in reservation and I see media (who didn't speak against EWS reservation), now speaking about talent and meritocracy. My same friends are again against caste reservation. Now I just laugh at them. Note - I do walk the talk. So I have never taken reservation and yes I belong to OBC.
58
@rishirajsharma7207 Haan, SEBI wali bhi Lateral Entry se hi hai. Bade kaam to kar hi Rahi hai. Waise Mujhe lateral entry se problem nahi hai. Bas Imaandari se honi chahiye. Wo dikhati nahi hai. Koi hai jo last 10 saal me lateral entry se aakar koi mahaan kaam kar diya hai?
4
@shivmohan99681 Read SC judgements on all cases and also don't give one exception as an example which was already challenged at that time. Read numerous judgments of SC. And talking about favourable cases, I can see who is quoting one exception which was challenged too. And check the recent one rejected by Patna HC. What they have quoted, even after crossing 50%.
4
बिलकुल। ये कहने वाले स्वदेश में किस Caste से Belong करते थें? तो फिर ये कैसे जायेगी? ये तब जायेगी जब इसका सदियों से सबसे ज्यादा फायदा उठाने वाले इसको छोड़ेंगे। उसके बाद OBC वाले छोड़ेंगे और फिर SC/ST वाले छोड़ेंगे।
3
@rishirajsharma7207 Watch the movie again.
3
@rajx7120 RSS supported Mandal!!! Obviously, but in an alternate universe. Do you know the purpose of reservation? SC/ST Creamy layer is a problem? You have crossed all the imaginable universe and went to somewhere else. Yeah, Der is a lack of entrepreneurship among SC/ST and OBC(less than SC/ST). Obviously. Bcz when for 2000+ years, they were fighting for basic foods, life, home and respect, they forgot about entrepreneurship. By the way, if the so-called general class is so entrepreneurial,why did they need that 10% reservation? Why did they not use the Mudra loan and others to improve der situation? Read and then comment. Reservation is not Gareebi Hatao Yojana. By the way, your comments show, your thinking level.
3
@rishirajsharma7207 Again Read. Lack of knowledge is not an excuse for commenting like this. Just tell me, why does Maratha are agitating against it? Have u seen the cutoff of this? However, these are the results. Do you understand the point I am making here? At least read, understand and then comment.
2
@rishirajsharma7207 😂😂😂 so they are getting benifits in 10% reservation category and asking for reservation as part of OBC, where total reservation is 27%? Bcz obviously they will lose EWS after getting the OBC category. Yadav's are taking benifits of everything but those who has taken all the benifits for 2000 years and are still taking all the benefits, plus they are not getting 10% reservation, are not acquiring anything. Great. Alos, By ur analogy, you live on earth. So you know everything about it. You are so funny.😂
2
@rishirajsharma7207 I will now not respond to any of your comments until you provide info about any of my points being wrong in my original comments. Also, what was ur position on reservation before 2019 and after that. I know, people like you and you guys have opened my eyes. Otherwise I could not have got Gyaan. Actually I thank Modi ji for that EWS reservation. Otherwise How could I have known the true faces of so many people, institutions, media , SC and even many of my friends. Obviously strangers like you, I always knew what you are.
2
@sunny57jo If upper caste stop taking 10% reservation on basis that they are already privileged for 2k+ years,and give those jobs and educational institution seats to SC/ST, then It will benifits all SC/ST. Don't you think that? By the way, Did you see the Intelligence of so called upper caste people? What was der cutoff? It was just above SC/ST. So the nation is not getting reasonable intelligence as part of EWS. What is ur take on this?
2
@rishirajsharma7207 😂😂😂 Please give those historical facts. Please enlighten me.
2
@sunny57jo 77 years of preferential treatment - wow. You are living in cocoon. Get out of that. See the real world. See how the SC Are always living in South side of village and outside that. Why are they always poor? Are yaar, Dimag me kuchh buddhi laao. Kahin se bhi laao thoda. Hey bhagwan, kripa karo isapar.
2
@sunny57jo Who said reservation has not helped? Yes, it could have been better but it has helped immensely. How else do you think that any SC ST person would be in IAS? I will ask you to check what fairness is. It is not treating everyone with the same criteria. A village upper caste person should be treated differently than a metro upper caste person. So u will see that for higher education, der are many places like JNU, IIM where extra points are given to village people. It is called fairness. Your idea of giving jobs to people marrying in a different caste seems noble but I don't think it will work. People can do anything for government job in India. I have done intercaste marriage. But I don't think I should get any extra benifits Bcz of that. It should be social change. Otherwise it will not work. People will make fun of genuine person if this happens.
2
@rishirajsharma7207 U got Suhaldev now😂😂 So Bcz Mayawati became cm in 90's, so Dalits were very well during 90's in India? The same way, Ambedkar has studied and become the most educated person of his time, then Dalits were getting the chance to get education at that time? Wow. By the way, why are you saying away from Shastras? One here and der, It can always happen. What about general treatment? Why were SC eating a dead animal ( cow)? Why? Get out of ur cocoon.
2
@rishirajsharma7207 About Manmohan Singh - He was recruited as Advisor for minister. Modi can also recruit it. He was not made in some kind of IAS officer. Even APJ Abdul Kalam was an Advisor to the minister. He was government employee but not IAS. So he has domain knowledge and was added as an advisor. Again, we have many examples of getting people into the government or RBI or planning commission. They have done remarkable jobs. However, I am still to get anyone in last 10 years who has done anything significant? Anyone recruited by Modi ji? By the way, MMS was recruited when der was only SC/ST reservation and also not included in bulk. Just added to do a job. Then added to another and came to politics Finally. The same way, Nandan Nilkeni was added to do a particular job.
1
@rishirajsharma7207 Jaati wadiyon ko ye dikhane me samay nahi lagata hai ki wo kya hain. Bahut jaldi dikha diye. Yadav ladte the, isiliye to dar bhi tha unka na tumhe. Warana jaise to baaki SC ka kiye the, unka v wahi haal karte. To apana itihas padho. Aur nikalo yahan se.
1
@rajx7120 RSS supported Mandal!!! Obviously, but in an alternate universe. Do you even know the purpose of reservation? SC/ST Creamy layer is a problem? You have crossed all the imaginable universe and went to something else. Yeah, Der is a lack of entrepreneurship among SC/ST and OBC(less than SC/ST). Obviously. Bcz when for 2000+ years, you are fighting for basic foods and respect, you forgot about entrepreneurship. By the way, if the so called general class is so entrepreneurial,why did they need that 10% reservation? Why did they not used the Mudra loan and others to improve der situation? Read and then comment. Reservation is not Gareebi Hatao Yojana. By the way, You are a top class ignor@nt with no understanding and knowledge of anything. And it is obvious that you are a J@atiw@di.
1
@rajx7120 RSS supported Mandal!!! Obviously, but in an alternate universe. Do you even know the purpose of reservation? SC/ST Creamy layer is a problem? You have crossed all the imaginable universe and went to something else. Yeah, Der is a lack of entrepreneurship among SC/ST and OBC(less than SC/ST). Obviously. Bcz when for 2000+ years, you are fighting for basic foods, life and respect, you forgot about entrepreneurship. By the way, if the so-called general class is so entrepreneurial,why did they need that 10% reservation? Why did they not use the Mudra loan and others to improve der situation? Read and then comment. Reservation is not Gareebi Hatao Yojana. By the way, You are a top class ign_ora_nt with no understanding and knowledge of anything. And it is obvious that you are a Jaat_iwadi.
1
@rajx7120 RSS supported Mandal!!! Obviously, but in an alternate universe. Do you even know the purpose of reservation? SC/ST Creamy layer is a problem? You have crossed all the imaginable universe and went to something else. Yeah, Der is a lack of entrepreneurship among SC/ST and OBC(less than SC/ST). Obviously. Bcz when for 2000+ years, you are fighting for basic foods, life and respect, you forgot about entrepreneurship. By the way, if the so-called general class is so entrepreneurial,why did they need that 10% reservation? Why did they not use the Mudra loan and others to improve der situation? Read and then comment. Reservation is not Gareebi Hatao Yojana. By the way, You are a top class ignorant with no understanding and knowledge of anything. And it is obvious that you are a Jaat-iwadi.
1
@rajx7120 RSS supported Mandal!!! Obviously, but in an alternate universe. Do you know the purpose of reservation? SC/ST Creamy layer is a problem? You have crossed all the imaginable universe and went to somewhere else. Yeah, Der is a lack of entrepreneurship among SC/ST and OBC(less than SC/ST). Obviously. Bcz when for 2000+ years, they were fighting for basic foods, life, home and respect, they forgot about entrepreneurship. By the way, if the so-called general class is so entrepreneurial,why did they need that 10% reservation? Why did they not use the Mudra loan and others to improve der situation? Read and then comment. Reservation is not Gareebi Hatao Yojana. By the way, You are a top class ig-nor-ant with no understanding and knowledge of anything. And it is obvious that you are a cas-te-ist.
1
@rishirajsharma7207 Are, Last 10 saal me aaye kisi ka naam batao na? Aur rahi baat Manmohan Singh ki ya Nandan Nilkeni ki, to wo Planning Commission se aaye the. Wahan aaj v (Niti Aayog) me bahar se aate hain log. Jis tarah ki lateral entry ki baat ho rahi hai,wo UPSC ki jagah dusaro ko wo job Dene ki baat hai. Aur fir se, last 10 saal me jo lateral entry ke through aaye the (Modi ji ne pahale v kiya hai Lateral Entry), unak kya contribution raha hai aisa. Batao to sahi.. fir na tulana hogi..
1
@rishirajsharma7207 Fir se dekho ek baar Movie.
1
@sunny57jo 😂😂😂 Ram killed Shambhuk for doing Yagna. Read Manu Smriti. Read Mahabharat. Read history and see what was happening during the so-called golden era of Gupta period. Read how Dalits were treated during the Peshwa raj in medieval india. Read any book except Shiva Related and read especially the Vishnu related books. And Shantanu was tharki. Nothing more than that. And obviously, it doesn't matter if a girl belongs to a lower caste, if she is beautiful. This is an example of that. Actually der is exception for this. U know the b s of girls caste is that of his husband after marriage. Give an example where some upper caste girl was married to a lower caste man. By the way, About Valmiki. What is your source? What was the name of his father?
1
@rishirajsharma7207 Nope. Only upper castes were suppressed in India. All others were enjoying the benefits of the caste system. Read Shastras. I have not met anyone from OBC or SC St who denied atrocities. Only upper caste people denied it. Is der any suspense in it😂😂😂 It is the same as white supremacists deny about having any benefits and complaints about+ve action being done for Black and others. Just read ur Shastra. By the way, If I start giving examples of individual atrocities by upper caste in current India against SC ST, then pages will be filled. Just google it And about Yadav's - Read my main comment. I know, ignorance is bliss but don't be that ignorant. By the way, in today's time, Yadav's are new swarna. And yet, they are less privileged than those who are under EWS.
1
@pawankhurana1345 I got teacher's job in 2011 when I was in 4th year 8th semester, final month. I left that job and chose the private one. So don't say things which u don't know. Those who join IAS/IPS from IIA or IIT are not Bcz of easy chance. They have to work extra in that job. Everyone is not aspiring for clerk jobs in government where they are not responsible for anything and hence only indulge in corruption and laziness. Any IAS IPS( except 1-2% exception) are working more hours and doing extra work, even the corrupt ones
1
@gilgamesh-rc2pb Yes, he is doing the same. I think he is taking all these examples from Amish Tripathi interviews. If I talk about women he will give an example of Gargi. They take exception cases as general Bcz they know that the General case is horrible. My logic is, if anyone is defending, denying the horrible things done in the past, then that person is more dangerous than those who have actually done it.
1
@pawankhurana1345 Do u even understand the job of IAS? They will do that job only.
1
@gilgamesh-rc2pb justifying those acts are actually worse than committing those acts. The echo chamber is working like this. They take few exceptions of the past and make it a general case. They are trying to influence everyone, mainly the OBC and SC/ST by this. They are trying to whitewash der entire past and actually trying to claim the future too.
1
@gilgamesh-rc2pb These people talk about removing caste, not caring about it. But they are the flag bearers of it. If they want to destroy caste then they need to leave the caste first. They are the most beneficiary of the caste. Hence they should leave it first, Then OBC and finally SC/ST. And don't get me wrong. Der are many upper caste people who understand this and they are also against them. Hence they mark them as secular gangs. We should respect them. It can never become hatred for one caste or other. It should always be showing a mirror to these casteist people who are living in der past.
1