Comments by "" (@BharatThatIsIndia) on "Why are Indians indifferent to Palestinians’ plight? No, it isn’t about Jews vs Muslims" video.

Bcz it is not muslim suffering. It is about human suffering. We are a civilizational country. We cannot behave in only one way. Der should be nuances.
14
@vinushrenik Did you read history? It didn't start in 1948. What happened before 1948? Did Israel exist? A colonial power has created Israel in Palestine. They cannot say that our religious ancestors had left this land 2k years ago and it was our holy land and hence we can come back anytime. What about all Buddhists in the world who try to live in Gaya? Will India or local people allow that? Israel captured Palestinian land in 1900 with the help of Britain, a colonial power. Then in 1948 happened and they won the war with the help of the British. In 1967 UN created two state solutions and still Israel has captured lands. They have created colonies and treated Palestinian people like anything. HAMAS was encouraged by Israel and it is an open secret. Yes HAMAS killed innocent people. But what about Israel? Did you follow the news? They were killing people everyday in every captured land, outside Israel's main land. HAMAS is not in the West bank. What Israel is doing der? About Hizbullah. Which innocent Israeli citizen was killed by them? Hizbullah was bombing those parts which was captured by Israel in 2006 war with Lebanon and not Israeli main land. As you said, HAMAS is a terrorist organisation. Even Modi ji didn't recognise that. But let's agree on that. So a state will do the same or worse than what a terrorist is doing? They will kill everyone without considering they were terrorist or not? Israel said that Bcz People of GAZA elected HAMAS, they deserve this. So if HAMAS is using the same logic, that people of Israel elected Netanyahu and hence they deserve this? If they use the same logic that Bcz der was one Israeli Soilders or leader who has supported the killings of Palestinians, hence they killed 1200 people in Oct last year? Israel used the same logic to kill 400 people in the UN refugee camp. For me, HAMAS is a terrorist organisation and Israel is a terrorist state.
5
@vinushrenik And just for info. I assumed that Dharma is with Palestinian people,not with any specific organisation. And it is not with Israel and definitely not with Netanyahu. Israel is reality and so does Palestine. So der must be a two state solution which is UN and India's stand. Watch Netanyahu interview to at least understand that argument about the creation of Israel and logic behind it. Just keep aside your extra love(😉) for muslims and then think about those arguments.
4
Shekhar ji, so Krishana Supported Pandav bcz it was in Krishna national interest? Der is nothing called DHARMA(Not religion) and only Transactional behaviour? Are you talking about a country with great civilization or some of those countries which was drawn on paper by European or colonized by them to destroy them completely? So If it was 1940, you would have advocated to work with Hitler bcz ot was in our national interest?
2
@vinushrenik Do you know history or just pretend to do so? What happened before 1948? Did Israel exist? A colonial power has created Israel in Palestine. They cannot say that we left this land 2k years ago and it was our holy land. So all Jews has right to live der? What about all Buddhist try to live in Gaya? Will India allow that? Israel has captured Palestinian land in 1900 with the help of Britain, a colonial power. Then in 1948 happened and they won the war with the help of British. In 1967 UN has created two state solutions and still Israel has captured lands. They have created colonies and treating people like anything. HAMAS was encouraged by Israel and it is an open secret. Yes HAMAS killed innocent people. But what about Israel? Did you follow news? They were killing people everyday in every captured land, outside Israel main land. HAMAS is not in West bank. What Israel is doing der? About Hizbullah. Which innocent Israeli citizen was killed by them? Hizbullah were bombing those parts which was captured by Israel in 2006 war with Lebanon and not Israeli main land. As you said, HAMAS is a terrorist organisation. Even Modi ji didn't recognise that. But let's agree on that. So a state will do the same or worse than what a terrorist is doing? They will kill everyone without considering they were terrorist or not? Israel said that Bcz People of GAZA elected HAMAS, they deserve this. So if HAMAS is using the same logic, that people of Israel elected Netanyahu and hence they deserve this? If they use the same logic that Bcz der was one Israeli Soilders or leader who has supported the killings of Palestinians, hence they killed 1200 people in Oct last year? Israel used the smae logic to kill 400 people in UN refugee camp. For me, HAMAS is a terrorist organisation and Israel is a terrorist state.
1
@vinushrenik Do you know history or just pretend to do so? What happened before 1948? Did Israel exist? A colonial power has created Israel in Palestine. They cannot say that we left this land 2k years ago and it was our holy land and hence we can comeback and live der. What about all Buddhists in the world try to live in Gaya? Will India or local people allow that? Israel captured Palestinian land in 1900 with the help of Britain, a colonial power. Then in 1948 happened and they won the war with the help of the British. In 1967 UN created two state solutions and still Israel has captured lands. They have created colonies and treated people like anything. HAMAS was encouraged by Israel and it is an open secret. Yes HAMAS killed innocent people. But what about Israel? Did you follow the news? They were killing people everyday in every captured land, outside Israel's main land. HAMAS is not in the West bank. What Israel is doing der? About Hizbullah. Which innocent Israeli citizen was killed by them? Hizbullah were bombing those parts which was captured by Israel in 2006 war with Lebanon and not Israeli main land. As you said, HAMAS is a terrorist organisation. Even Modi ji didn't recognise that. But let's agree on that. So a state will do the same or worse than what a terrorist is doing? They will kill everyone without considering they were terrorist or not? Israel said that Bcz People of GAZA elected HAMAS, they deserve this. So if HAMAS is using the same logic, that people of Israel elected Netanyahu and hence they deserve this? If they use the same logic that Bcz der was one Israeli Soilders or leader who has supported the killings of Palestinians, hence they killed 1200 people in Oct last year? Israel used the same logic to kill 400 people in the UN refugee camp. For me, HAMAS is a terrorist organisation and Israel is a terrorist state.
1
@MrVish6666 😂😂😂 Version of history? It is the one version accepted by even Israel's. I quoted Netanyahu. I know whatsapp is important for you but it should not be that important for knowledge. Israel gave people a chance to flee 😂😂😂 They warned them and when they left at the designated place, Israel bombed that place too. They even bombed the UN shelter home. At least follow the news properly.
1
Shekhar ji, your whole argument is that even if a country is brutally and unnecessarily killing people, then also we should support that Bcz it is somehow in our national interest? So by this logic, we should have supported what Germany and Hitler were doing in 1936-1945? I am all for being our national interest taking the central stage and not some others countries views who have never supported us. But der should be some limit to this or not? We are civilizational country. We cannot behave only on the basis of profit margins. Yes this will be one of the biggest and most important criteria but not the only criteria.
1
@Namah18 I thought Modi ji can stop war..😂 Joke aside, India cannot stop the war alone but can put enough pressure along with others to stop it. India will suffer more and more of war continues. Oil prices will go up and it will create problems for us. Our growth will impact. So it is our national interest too which Shekhar ji completely missed. Der is humanity in war too. You don't bomb civilians indiscriminately. India and Pakistan have fought multiple wars. Der might be one or two instances of few civilians getting killed but not even Pakistan has bombed Indian civilian areas and killed indictmently. About donation - I don't donate as much as I should do Bcz I hv list faith in these organisations after I started in 2015. But still I didn't stop that which I started in 2015( according to my Limit of that time).
1
@prasvasu4217 yes, noone came for our help when we needed them. But who is saying to not think about our national interest! We have to think about it and we are thinking about it. We should keep our friendship with Israel but we cannot be bullied by them or cannot hostage our policies to Israel or any country. As a nation we should have something different than others? We are a civilizational country. We cannot behave like others in transactional manners. America criticizes India on many things and still we are friends. France has done this with Israel and still they are friends. Why can't we do that?
1
@mohanrao6 Is it happening in India? Am I Bangladeshi national? Do you think Modi government is so ignorant that I need to protest to force them raise concerns about Bnagldeshi Hindus? What about Hindus suffering in India just bcz of der caste? By the way, Theka liya hai kya Bharat ne duniya bhar ke Hindus ka? Wo unka desh hai, wo dekhe. Bharat sarkar help karegi agar jaroorat huyi to.
1