Comments by "" (@BharatThatIsIndia) on "Modi has exhumed Nehru’s Global South. Which fails the test of geography, geopolitics and economics" video.
-
Shekhar Ji, your National Interest always gives a new perspective in my thinking process, which I truly appreciate.
So thanks for that.
I was looking into all the news of Dalits or muslims getting beaten up, killing in train in Rajsthan, Children enacting the play to destroy Babari Mosque, cow vigilante, Love Jihad darama, hateful Hindu and Muslim leaders speeches,etc.
Obviously it is still within control and is managed by one political power or another.
However, this beating of a muslim boy by his classmates on the encouragement of der teacher is far more dangerous than any Gunda beating someone.
They are students of primary school and der teacher is like this.
It has reached our children and it is against our national interest.
I don't think China, Pakistan or any other country can damage this much.
Your National Interest has a huge impact. No CTC, No Editorial will have that much impact.
Could you please do a National Interest on this.
6
-
5
-
3
-
@ringbasu6700 So no actual data. No jobs data, not GDP growth data, no inflation data, no petrol prices, no food prices data. Ok.
It is long message. Try to open your eyes.
Make In India - where is it? Even Modi ji has changed it to Atmnirbhar Bhart. Check the export data before 2014 and compare that and see if der is any substantial difference in per year percentage growth.
Example - The India trade deficit with China even crossed 100 billion.
Digital India - So check the data of phone connection before 2000. Then check what Atal ji has done and what was the number in 2004. Then check what Manmohan Singh ji did. So 2g almost started during Atal ji era, price reduced dramatically and people started using phone. Then 3g came and people started using it. Then during the Modi era, 4g came and it had great speed. Internet price reduced and it became affordable and hence more and more people started using it. The same thing happened 2G 5-6 years ago. This is simple technology development.
Modi ji done Notebandi and it was a mega failure. Right now, we have double the amount of notes in circulation than what it was before Notebandi.
PayTm and other companies came not bcz of Modi ji.
It was like Flipkart coming during Manmohan Singh's tenure. He didn't bring that.
UPI development was done which was again a natural development. As it is free and people have mobiles we are using it.
India has a 17% population of the world. So numbers will always be high. It shows that Indians believe in technology that says Chinese.
And that 40% is the count of the transaction not the value of it.
Gas Connection - it was done in his first term. Actually in the first or 2nd year. So do you know how many of them are using those gas connections? After he increased the price of, LPG,those who were using gas started using cow dung and coal. Do you know that data? Check how many of them have taken the 2nd cylinder. It was successful for the first time and after that it was a big failure.
Electricity - Do you understand anything or just see the BJP advertisement and believe it?
Before 2024,how many villages didn't have electricity? Do you know that India has some 7 Lakh villages and all but some 25k didn't have electricity.
Again, if it is 29 hrs, how can it be uninterrupted? By the way, do you not think it is a natural progression?
Earlier governments were trying to give electricity to some 7lakhs villages and once it was completed, the hours will be increased.
In the next 5 years it can reach 24 hrs per day, whoever might be the PM. It doesn't matter.
Clean India - it was a very good initiative. I really supported this. But finally it became only "toilets banao mission". What about cleaning the Naali, what about giving equipment to those who are going inside those Naali to clean it, what about new technologies?
But still, it was 25% successful and in a country like ours, it is difficult to inform people about cleanliness. And even 25% is a great achievement.
Bank Accounts - Do you know Modi as a CM and BJP as opposition party have opposed DBT? UPA2 was trying to persuade states for that and they didn't allow that. To transfer money, you need an account and it would have been done earlier. However, the opening of the account was a good step but not something which is an achievement of some sorts. It was not like that banks were not opening accounts. People didn't have money so they didn't want to open an account.
And today also, people are not putting money in those accounts.
Ease of living - All banks, almost all government organisations had der online availability before 2014. Are you saying SBI started all these facilities after Modi came to power?
I applied for my passport and all government facilities online in 2009. So get over this. It is natural and it will increase as more and more people will become aware of it and as technology will become cheap.
GST - Really 😂 Do you want to put this as Modi's success? First of all, Check Modi speeches and statements against GST in 2012, 2013. It was again UPA2 idea.
Now check what government claims were when they implemented GST. They are not able to pay money to states on time. Even BJP states are not happy.
Der aim was 1 Lakh 10k GST from beginning which took 2 years to cross. It actually reduced the government tax collection, harmed small businesses and took more tax from common people.
Even Khakhara and Jalebi were put under GST which Arun Jaitley announced to remove just before the 2017 Gujrat election. This is one example and you can check how horribly it was implemented.
Income Tax - First of all der is no benefit to common people in Income tax. If you calculate Inflation from 2014 and compare the tax slab, you will understand. Please do it.
If you are talking about filing of Income tax, so der is no huge increase in that and also the online process was before 2014. I filed online in 2012.
Driving licence, caste certificates, etc are part of technological development.
Road - Yes, the Modi government has made more roads or advertised more than UPA. But it is more of an exaggeration. UPA didn't calculate lanes as KM. The Modi government does. So if 1 km 4 lanes is made, the Modi government will calculate it at 4km and UPA has calculated it 1 KM.
Border roads are an achievement of the Modi government.
One more achievement is no terrorist activities in India, except Kashmir. But if you see, it is reduced in the entire world. In the later part of UPA2, in 2013, 14 also there were very few terror activities. Der are many factors involved here but still it is Modi government success.
Foreign Policy - You guys are so much into visuals. USA has been a natural progression since Atal Ji. 2008 was a nuclear deal. Modi ji has taken it forward in the same manner Manmohan Singh ji has taken it forward from Atal ji. Next PM will take it more forward.
Nepal went to China lap. Only Hindu majority country went with China. This is a Successful foreign Policy?
Don't tell me G20 presidency is part of Foreign Policy success. It is given to all members alphabetically.
What about China? Any Foreign minister can speak against Europe or the USA. Those are liberal societies and didn't bother about these things. Jayasankar has given Gyaan to them.
Now you will tell me that India is buying Oil from Russia even after Western sanctions. So first of all der is no western sanctions on buying Russian oil. You just cannot buy using der currencies.
You know India was buying oil from Iran earlier, even when the USA put sanctions on Iran? Modi government came under Trump pressure and stop buying oil from them. No other earlier governments have done that. We always bought the oil from Iran.
Russian oil, any Indian government would have bought that. Even Pakistan is doing it now.
Startup Culture in youth - Flipkart, PayTm was established before Modi became PM. It was already der and it will increase over time.
100 smart cities, Sansad Adarsh Gram, aatmnirbhar bharat, startup, skill development, sgandup, etc all are failed Modi government plans.
1
-
@satyasatpathy4529 Actually you should take government of India data on all of these and compare it.
% GDP growth, %Income increase, % Unemployment, Nutrition data, family health survey of Gujarat by Indian government,etc.
I am not your secretary to check and give that to you. If you want to know the truth,you have to find it yourself.
I just wanted to inform you about these and if you don't have the time or wisdom or guts or thinking or hunger for truth then you are free to do your cacoon/Bhakti/Support/Chamchagirii/live in your own world/or anything else you find fit for yourself.
If you claim something, you should first verify it.
For example, do you know how many km of roads were built during the Atal ji era MMS ji era and the Modi era?
Have you seen those data before claiming that more roads were built during the Modi era?
If you have not seen it(and I know you have not seen that else you would have mentioned the KM) and you are claiming that then you are falling into the trap of advertisement.
Be aware as you have a tendency to fall for advertisement. It is your weakness and you can fall for some other products in your day to day life.
This is just free advice.
One more thing, vote for anybody you wish. It is your right. I am not saying don't vote for Modi ji. If you think he has done good work, it is fine to vote for him.
But all should be based on actual facts and not advertisements or prapoganda or some prime time media bullshit.
1
-
1
-
1
-
@akrishnan1382 No babu..
Modi is not like his predecessor, except Indira Gandhi. He can be compared only with her.
And both of them destroyed the Indian economy. Modi has broken her record of high unemployment.
Enjoy your far sighted(?) view, which is just about worshiping one leader.
And yes, India will be Great in 2047. Till then enjoy Inflation, unemployment, hatred, etc.
And just like 2022, (when everything was supposed to happen), in 2047, the deadline will be increased.
Provided, Indians remain bigoted till 2047.
1
-
@sankalp6872 People like you will always do this kind of thing. You are a bigot,nafrati, fool.
Did forensics report of the video said that it is fake? Police has booked case against the teacher and what is in the video is der for everyone to hear. Why school gave compensation to the parents? Why politicians and locals are forcing them to not file case?
Now, First of all, your whataboutery will never end.
You guys can't see people without seeing der religion.
I don't think you guys can see anything without using your bigot lens.
When did the 2nd video emerge? Any leader who asked the Kashmir child parents to do "Compromise" with the school teacher?
Also, you are so bigot that you can't see the difference. In Kashmir the teacher was bigoted and he beat the child. He should be in jail for that. But he was not making children to do it. So he was bigot like you and he must be punished.
In UP, parents of Hindu Children should raise the issue first. They should file the case against the teacher first. That teacher is making der children bigot, Nafrati, idiot. She was destroying the career of Hindu Children.
Do you put your brother, sister, son, daughter in that school?
Bcz those Hindus are poor and lower middle class hindu, they should be made Gunda/bigot and brainwashed?
Tum bahut beemaar ho. Ilaaj karao apana.
1
-
1