Comments by "" (@BharatThatIsIndia) on "Caste census politics — what Bihar thinks today, Bihar used to think day before yesterday" video.

Shekhar ji, I understand that your argument is about development of Bihar and better alternate political idea than caste census to win the election. They obviously need something more. Caste census will be like Tadaka and not the entire daal. Overdose of Tadaka will kill the dish. All things said and done, why der was almost noone (except 1 oe 2 voices) raised der voice, written editorials and have panel discussion on that. The Print and The Indian Express has covered it but if you see how SC, Media, so called intellectuals, supporters of Talent, Online trolls etc have reacted to this EWS( Read Sawaran Reservation)? Our SC, which used to talk about 50% limit, Conducting surveys that any caste is backward or not. We have seen that in case of Jaat Reservation and Maratha reservation. However EWS is provided without any of this.
6
Shekhar ji, Bihar Politicians did not do better under any political ideology, neither under Brahmin CM nor under Yadav, Kurmi CM. They all failed Bihar. But what did any Central government has done in Bihar? What Modi ji has done In last 9+ years for Bihar? What BJP has done in 15 years of its rule?
4
And how many BJP voters are der? It is 15-20% ballpark. By the way, BJP was in Bihar for 15+ years and in union for 10 years now. What they have done for Bihar? Bihar has given BJP lots of support. How many roads were built by the Indian government, how many colleges, schools, hospitals were opened in Bihar?
4
@kvineet631 Lets agree to your points. They have thrown thos caste census and reservation idea for vote sake as they failed in delivery. Just one question. What do you think about Modi ji Throwing 10% reservation in 2019? Was not his failing to deliver? Did you check India growth rates under Modi that too before Covid? And please don't give that bullshit that EWS is for poor. It is also a caste based reservation and nothing more. Actually it is disproportionately allocated.
2
@ayushsinha3006 NAL se Jal in Bihar was Bihar government scheme. The central scheme started later. What is the Hindutva politics of BJP done for Bihar? They were in power for 15 years in Bihar. What have they done? What did the caste based Reservation of 2019 (which was not done since 1992) have done for India? Why has Modi brought out that again in politics? What benefit it has done for the country. Did it Increase the GDP?
2
@Myanmartiger921 Not only Nitish, BJP was in power in Bihar for 15 years with Nitish. What have they achieved? Before that Lalu was in power for 15 years. What did he achieve? For that matter, none of the state or central government has done anything for Bihar in the last 75 years. They have deliberately kept Bihar poor to keep it a cheap labour supplier state.
1
@ayushsinha3006 I have seen that and that 4 sectors are der for all over country. Indira Awas was already der and people were building home der too. As India grew, the scale of building homes grew too. So it is basic progression. Bank Account - Bank account may empower people, but that is half truth. If you don't have money then you will not be empowered even by 100 bank accounts. Jan Dhan did some impact but not much. Toilets - Obviously Swatch Bharat has its impact in the first Modi government. Toilets are built but the quality is very bad and people are not using most of them. But it was still a good scheme. Basis Asset - Are you serious? Having a cycle was a Modi government scheme? Nitish has distributed more cycles and hence people have it. Shekhar ji missed adding NAL se Jal, which Bihar is doing and is better than the national average. So at the end, BJP, MODI has done nothing for Bihar. Swatch Bharat and Jan Dhan have some impact but these were national schemes and were for every state.
1
@bhaskarpathak7924 Wow. That is not assistance but the actual distribution in all states based on predefined criteria. Modi government has not given any extra support to Bihar to enable it. He got votes and seats and promised also. But he backed away from his promises. By the way, Bihar is not creating wealth. We all know that. But it was made to be like that mainly by fool Bihari politicians and also by so-called national leaders of Both Congress and BJP. They wanted to keep it like that else who will go to Gujarat or Maharashtra or Tamilnadu to work for cheap? Where will cheap labour come from?
1
@bhaskarpathak7924 wow. Throwing money in well? Yes, Bihar is not able to create industry and it is problem of Bihar leaders. But throwing money in well? Wow.. So Bihar or Bihari are not doing anything all over the country? I can understand your level of thinking and understanding and feel sad for you.
1
@JanardhanPrasadDVS I don't the APMC has such an impact. Bihar didn't get any good leaders, government or party. Also none of the Central governments ever supported Bihar. They wanted to keep Bihar like this. And Finally, people of Bihar need to take responsibility and elect better people and should not depend on any party.
1