Comments by "Scott Tovey" (@scotttovey) on "Krakatoa: The Volcanic Eruption That Changed The Course Of History | Catastrophe | Timeline" video.
-
@highstimulation2497
"it's just a theory. "
It's a theory based on more evidence, scientific research, and historical facts than the theory of evolution.
"many scientists dispute his claims."
In what way?
Do they just say it didn't happen that way and expect you to just take their statement as scientific fact without them having presented solid, logical counter arguments and evidence to dispute his claims?
If so, then take his claims as being a reasonable explanation until someone comes along with more evidence that contradicts this interpretation of the events.
The person with the best supporting evidence and reasonable argument wins the debate, not the person with the most education. His claims are a reasonable interpretation of the events in question therefore it is up to those that dispute his claims to present a more reasonable argument supported by evidence.
If someone should come along later with additional evidence that suggests his interpretation of the evidence is wrong; then you have a valid argument that disputes his claims. Without that additional evidence however, simply disputing the claims suggests that the individual disputing the claims is not a scientist, but a religious zealot.
Since 2020, we've seen plenty of evidence that the science community is filled and controlled by a lot of religious, power hungry, zealots; and not actual scientists. Like prostitutes, they sell themselves to the highest bidder.
1