Comments by "Subramanian Viswanathan" (@maniaphobia4719) on "SC order, India’s medical education mess, NEET, SC/ST/OBC/EWS quotas" video.

In Tamil Nadu , Former Chief Minister Dr.MGR ( a Bharat Ratna Posthoumously awarded ) tried to bring reservation on the basis of economic backwardness ; He was stopped on the tracks in spite of his massive Celluloid Popularity ( An Unprecedented matinee idol in his time ) Reason : I do not know ; Usual suspect is political ;
2
You do not need to feel cheated ; Actually we need many Kaipu Nagi reddy''s who pass out of State Govt Schools and pose challenge to Students from elite schools ; Real life story is Dr.APJ Kalam who got educated from a public school and went on to become a Nuclear Scientist and President of India later ; Of course it was not easy for him ;
2
@newbegining7046 Will you ( not you as a person but as an Indian public ) agree on Economic backwardness as criteria for Reservation ; Why it is on caste based ; Who is sustaining the castes ; Weather 70 years of reservation achieved the targets ; Is there proper use (or) abuse ; A dalit doctor's son should get reservation ? 25 % of indian population lives in slums ? What is left out is all around problems with lot of money stashed in foreign banks on few individual accounts ? No offense please ; These are realities ;
2
@newbegining7046 My understanding is financial backwardness is the root cause of social evils and abuses ; Most of the upper castes are united and help themselves which is instinctive and quite normal ; Brahmins are political punch bags in the south and they do not care an iota for this ; They are not interested generally in the muddy political process though we have seen many chief ministers for multiple terms ; Regarding Dalits, they are not united ; why not all india level ; If they do , then there is vote bank and negotiating strength ; parties will come crawling ; Why not dalit CM and PM ; The reason may be lack of unity and proper political calculations and sincere commitments to uplift ; There are many great Dalit leaders who are clean in terms of public money and high characters ; ( led by examples ) Regarding religion , Religion is generally misunderstood and twisted for political gains ; Religion says anyone can be a brahmin not by birth but by character ; Religion does not need politics and is purely related to the individual for inner peace , happiness and love ; Politics needs religion and is indispensable from it for whipping up individual emotions ; SUMMARY : All social roads leads to political hell and its exploitation for votes ;
1
@newbegining7046 If some priests make a living and Politicians interfere for votes then it is a life (or) death problem for them ; If the social evils can be sorted out by that action, I agree for it with legal sanction ; But it will not solve the problem ; Why castes can not be eliminated , if it is so much resented ; Problem is successive parties sustain it and conveniently put the blame on religion ; Political parties social reforms will pale into oblivion if it is compared to Acharya Ramanuja 1000 years back ; Regarding Sankaracharya arrest , the Dalits have protested more at that time if I remember correct ; He was helping them to his best ; I think , Political hell is a hell and will continue by sustaining the Caste discrimination and only politicians can have all benefits while others suffer ; Thanks for your time ;
1
@newbegining7046 you are conveniently avoiding answers and ask me questions; Sorry i have limited time ; If possible we can discuss what has to be done than searching past data and paralyse ourselves; Questions and counter questions without any committments is left to politicians as they make large money at the end ; i do not find any answer as how caste differences can be mitigated or eliminated ; you win arguments ; 🙏
1