Youtube hearted comments of Alex (@Alex-cw3rz).
-
978
-
971
-
700
-
325
-
318
-
294
-
223
-
208
-
198
-
178
-
168
-
120
-
101
-
I think a great example is HMS Shannon who actually had a 1v1 fight in 1812, her armament and the performance of her sister ship HMS Guerriere, would show she should lose to Chesapeake, but not just did she win, she won so decisively, you'd need 4 chessapeake's too have the same number of cannon balls hitting Shannon as hit Chessapeake. This doesn't even go into the tactics and the way the Shannon had a cannon at the bow specifically placed their to act like a giant sniper rifle taking out the cheesapeakes helmsmen and wheel, this wasn't a particularly normal tactic, but won them the battle.
Another example is HMS Speedy Vs El Gamo 14 guns vs 32 guns of bigger calibre, yet Speedy won.
The idea of doing a 1v1 based on specs does not show training or how ships are set up differently, the accuracy or preferred tactics, it doesn't examine the captains. Or as you said when, where and why they are fighting which create 100s of different results.
94
-
81
-
75
-
One thing that sort of proves your point is the opposite as well, the golden age of piracy has very little contemporary paintings on it and nothing to the scale were you can understand the actual lines of a ship as almost all are 2d things that the measurement are all wrong for, if they were correct Bartholomew Roberts ship Royal Fortune was bigger than a city, and the earth is concave. The time was one of great change in ship design, you can find many paintings of grand 1st rates which are so over the top I still can't wrap my head around that those transom existed, but frigates and smaller ships pirates would use, there are no detailed paintings of, so you have to do a bit of guess work, you don't know how orinate they would be, how squared the transom is etc. It's no wonder pirate movies and TV shows always get the ships wrong, as they are looking at ships 9x+ heavier.
62
-
53
-
53
-
50
-
46
-
45
-
42
-
42
-
40
-
39
-
37
-
31
-
27
-
26
-
25
-
25
-
24
-
23
-
22
-
18
-
13
-
13
-
10
-
5
-
2