Comments by "Der Stoff aus dem der Joghurt ist" (@derstoffausdemderjoghurtis4346) on "4a4b" channel.

  1. The German version of this song is called "Budjonny Reiterlied" - I never expected this song to exist in Thai!
    35
  2. Is has multiple ones. Check out "maple leaf rock", "forgeons notre parti" or "death to the traitors".
    17
  3. Google translate can't handle Denglisch^^
    13
  4. You might also know it from the song "Ami go home"
    9
  5. What a find! Translates surprisingly well into swedish. Thank you for uploading.
    7
  6. Epic flag, epic song
    7
  7. Lyrics corrcetions.. 3. Stanza, 2. Vers: "Deiner Befreiung gilt unser Leben" ("To your liberation our life is dedicated") and 4. Stanza, 2. Vers: "Von tapferen Kämpfern sind wir die Erben" ("Of brave combatants we are the heirs")
    7
  8. I'm very positively surprised to find them here and their music and message being appreciated internationally!
    7
  9. Thanks a lot for sharing!! And especially for providing all the context to the song.
    5
  10. Why did I never heard of this song before? Found you channel thanks to @skryl !
    4
  11.  @Minecraftzocker135  They also have Mao on the same banner which they were very critical of, especially later. They honoured Stalin, that is true but they were not shy in critiquing him, were they saw it justified. What they didn't like about the GDR was the SED and that they broke from marxism-leninism while claiming to adhere to it.
    4
  12. Do you have a Discord channel or some form of contacting you? Ig think I got some songs for recommendation, which are rather rare and hard to find on youtube
    3
  13. Das Lied ist eine Parodie auf das Horst-Wessel-Lied. Nicht nur Melodie sondern auch der Text sind daran angelehnt. Die Fahne hoch - der Metzger ruft Die Reihen fest geschlossen - die Augen fest geschlossen SA marschiert im ruhig festen tritt - das Kalb marschiert mit ruhig festen tritt Kameraden die Rotfront und Reaktion erschossen - die Kälber deren Blut im schlachthof schon geflossen ziehen im Geist in unseren Reihen mit - sie ziehen im Geist in seinen Reihen mit
    3
  14.  @AnthemsOfEurope  fitting username ;)
    3
  15.  @zacharyhughes2950  KPD/ML broke from Maoism once the three worlds theory came into play.
    3
  16. originally it's "Tramp! Tramp! Tramp!" ("The Prisoner’s Hope") by George F. Root. It's from the (US-)American Civil War
    2
  17. Is this the original version of the song, or is this the one by Corala Occitania Lodova with the tone pitched up for copyright reasons? If it's indeed the original, who is the interpret?
    2
  18. Prob because Hamas is controlled opposition.
    2
  19. That's what the song is about...
    2
  20.  @roedagardet  Yes of course.
    2
  21. It never did, but communism was quite popular in canada during the great depression in the 30' and during the II World War. The Communist Party of Canada (CPC) exists since 1921.
    2
  22. Die neue linke ist da leider nicht viel besser..
    2
  23. @ being authentic and truthfull about what you believe is more important than "taking over". If you compromise about that, you may take over but than it becomes something like the GDR.
    2
  24. as a German: you are correct
    2
  25. They were critical of the soviet unions imperialism, but they still honoured stalin for what they deemed honourable. That's something actually nice about them - they weren't black and white people.
    1
  26.  @roedagardet  thank you!!
    1
  27.  @christopherstein2024  Ich bin links und ich liebe mein Land. Ich mag auch die tri-colore, aber ich würde sie mir nicht aufhängen oder tragen, weil ich den Staat den sie nunmal auch repräsentiert nicht gutheiße. Aber es stimmt, dass viele, vorallem aus der "neuen Linken" mit Deutschland nichts am Hut haben wollen und das sagt eigentlich auch schon alles über diese Bewegung aus.
    1
  28.  @communistcommissar  Comrade/Kamerad is adequade. If you think german communists don't use it, than you haven't heard many german communist songs.
    1
  29. where do I know this melody from?
    1
  30. Es ist ursprünglich die Melodie von "Tramp! Tramp! Tramp!" ("The Prisoner’s Hope") von George F. Root. Ein Lied aus dem Sezessionskrieg/US-Amerikanischem Bürgerkrieg
    1
  31. As far as I know there is not. But there is a German version of this song called "Budjonny Reiterlied" it's oretty popular and easy to find under that name, but that one lacks the last stanza. But there is a more rare version which includes it and this is the link to it: https://youtu.be/_sNLRS5l0X0?si=xKcPX1jKrc6L8bSC
    1
  32. try having a state without an army and you'll be conquered try having a society without police and you'll get armed gangs nonetheless Man is an animal and therefore has innate violent qualities. Either you bundle and focus them on where they are useful for man or you let them run rampant and let man destroy himself. Ask a modern day leftist if they support civilian gunownership and they will tell you no, people shouldn't be allowed to on guns. Ask a modern day leftist if they support police and military and they will tell you no. The box of pandora is opened, firearms exist and won't disappear and even before they existed bladed weapons had their place. So what you get whwn following these values is essentially a society with an unarmed and vulnerable populous that stands with empty hands against both the criminals without uniform and the ones with uniform, which both will be armed, regardless of what utopian phantasy of gun "controll" the populous let the politicians sell them.
    1
  33. If you don't know it already you should give the "Al-Fatha-Lied" a listen. 4a4b uploaded it a year ago. It's sung by the choir of the KABD, a successor organisation KPD/ML.
    1
  34. originally it's "Tramp! Tramp! Tramp!" ("The Prisoner’s Hope") by George F. Root. It's from the (US-)American Civil War
    1
  35.  @olafur7892  it is definitly patriotic. But not nationalist, rather internationalist :D
    1