Comments by "Connor" (@connor5669) on "Only A Man Can 'Identify' As A Trans Woman - Helen Joyce (4K) | heretics. 15" video.

  1. 24:08 Our brains are also part of our bodies. Helen thinks our body determines our gender but implies our own psychology has nothing to do with it. I think this is a contradiction
    4
  2. Hi Andrew! I commend your interview style and I appreciate that you try to raise what trans people might say I hope you see my comments and consider those perspectives when you talk about trans issues. I think it would add a lot of depth. thanks!
    2
  3. 57:47 Helen brings up safeguarding in schools but fails to mention that SA happens A LOT by school teachers. And yet teachers are still trusted with kids. A certain demographic of people is always going to include some bad people
    2
  4. Great content! I hope you see my comments respectfully disagreeing with her assessments
    2
  5. 51:50 What damage do you think this will do to the trans community to segregate based on hypothetical fear? TO BE CLEAR, there is ZERO evidence that trans inclusive spaces lead to SA or anything of the like. Helen MUST provide solid evidence that trans women are a legitimate safety threat in public women's spaces to argue that segregation is necessary. You don't have a right to comfort, trans people don't at least.
    1
  6. 13:34 What gender does Helen think an xy person is when their body naturally develops as female? She claims it's binary, but that's a perfect example of how complicated sex is. She has an investment in the idea that sex is binary and cannot change, but she references a perfect example of how sex is not binary
    1
  7.  @MiyangChoi  that doesn't answer the question. How do you determine what gender that person must be? It's literally ambiguous
    1
  8.  @MiyangChoi  So, sex is binary, but we need a doctor to determine what sex you are if it's ambiguous. That's a contradiction.
    1
  9.  @MiyangChoi  Wow. You're saying you would abort your fetus if it was intersex? Even though there's nothing unhealthy about the child? You're psycho
    1
  10. 10:04 sex is defined as an array of characteristics including hormonal sex, sexondary sexed traits, etc. Intersex people display a mixed set of these features. It's literally not possible to say they're "one sex or the other"
    1
  11. 14:03 If Helen were forced to dress as a man, she would still recognize herself as a woman in the mirror. The reason I know that I am a trans woman is because I recognize myself as a woman when I look in the mirror. Not a collection of stereotypes, just literally how my eyes understand the human I'm looking at. This is just psychology.
    1
  12. 10:57 she is literally standing against the medical guidelines of every major medical organization on the West. She is in the position of a flat earther (especially because she is not at all educated formally on medicine)
    1
  13. 8:15 Helen is herself a flat earther in the sense that she believes there's a massive scientific conspiracy to cover up the truth of gender affirming care. Have you considered that?
    1
  14. 42:35 Helen is incorrect about what trans people believe, which I find interesting considering the immense amount of time she has put in to this. I know many gender non conforming trans people. Their existence is proof that trans identity is NOT based on stereotypes of behavior, but rather an internal sense of self.
    1
  15. 54:00 people do not have the right to set a boundary about public space. It's PUBLIC
    1
  16. Magdalen said horrific, dehumanizing things about trans women. People like you have zero empathy for trans people.
    1
  17. Autogynephilia is not recognized by the psychological community for a good reason. Studies on cisgender women show that they demonstrate agp traits as well. It calls into question how the condition can be unique to trans women. Julia Serano wrote a great investigation into the condition. Contrapoints made an interesting video on the subject! Highly reccomend
    1