General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
Sandy Tatham
Middle East Eye
comments
Comments by "Sandy Tatham" (@sandytatham3592) on "Maxwell Frost: How a Florida progressive courted Palestinians, then abandoned them" video.
He seems to be a realist. Perpetuating the idea of a two-state solution, or one state of Palestine, is futile. The Arabs already have Jordan. Jordan was granted 77% of the British Mandate of Palestine after the Ottoman Caliphate was defeated in 1918.
2
SCBotanicals : I'm proud to be a Zionist who values the Holy Land, though I'm not a practising Christian. The Jews were promised their homeland in return for supporting the Allied Powers in WWI. The Ottoman Empire was defeated in 1918, and in 1948 and subsequent wars the Arab militaries who attacked Israel were also defeated. There are consequences for going to war against another country. You don't get to choose who gets what land. This is a good video which explains how Israel and the surrounding Arab countries came into fruition. They were all founded as a result of the defeat and dismembering of the Ottoman Caliphate..... https://youtu.be/wu1rkvwzshE Israel isn't going anywhere. The Jews have returned to their ancestral homeland. The Arabs have self-determination over 99% of the collapsed Ottoman Empire. If 'Palestinian' Arabs are hostile towards Israel they should apply to be resettled in another country. They are what anywhere else in the world we would call 'displaced' peoples.
1