General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
Todd Webb
Drachinifel
comments
Comments by "Todd Webb" (@toddwebb7521) on "Ship vs Ship - Who Would Win - Episode 001" video.
Pretty sure warspite would take that. If a 14" standard was going to take a queen Elizabeth I'd say a 12 gun class like PA, NM, or TN would be more likely than the 10 gun NV
1
So something similar to your Texas vs Iron Duke vs Bretagne three way Colorado vs Nelson vs Nagato
1
One mistake is the size of escort fleet on PQ 17. The reason Tirpitz didn't sail was the Lutzow and 3 destroyers ran around before meeting up with Tirpitz. Had Lutzow not ran around Lutzow and Admiral Scheer and thier destroyers where to meet up with Tirpitz, Admiral Hipper, and escorts. So on the PQ 17 scenarios the Germans would have had 3 heavy cruisers, 2 of which were Deutschland class with 11" guns.
1
Scharnhorst vs Arkansas
1
One thing you didn't mention in the Iron Duke vs Texas vs Bretagne is that the turret face and barbette armour on Iron Duke is thinner than it's main belt armor and in fact the barbette armour is as thin as Bretagne's main belt Texas' barbettes are as thick as it's main belt and it's turret faces thicker than it's main belt. So Texas can potentially take down Iron Duke's turrets at longer range than it can penetrate the main belt. Probably not enough to change that Iron Duke has the advantage but maybe changes the percentage
1
German and French arms race vs Deutschland vs Dunkurque Dunkurque vs Scharnhorst Scharnhorst vs Richelieu Richelieu vs Bismarck
1
How about if a Deutschland class replaced Prinz Eugen in the Bismarck vs Hood and Prince of Wales.
1
I see what you did there. For 1941 start of Pacific war Hood had already gotten Bismarcked
1