Comments by "Richard S" (@RichardEnglander) on "Youth Quake: Britain's Right Wing Youth Pressure Farage to Set Up Reform UK Youth Wing" video.
-
50
-
10
-
22:36 native English is a thing, we are an ethnicity.
### The Case for English People as Native First Nations Aboriginal People
*1. Historical and Cultural Roots:*
The English people, like other indigenous groups, have a profound connection to their land that spans thousands of years. This historical continuity and cultural heritage are integral to their identity.
*2. Arguments for English People as Native First Nations Aboriginal People:*
- *Historical Continuity:* The English have inhabited the British Isles since ancient times, with evidence of continuous settlement, cultural development, and societal structures dating back to the Neolithic era.
- *Cultural Heritage:* England's rich cultural heritage, including language, literature, folklore, and traditions, is deeply rooted in its unique historical experience. Landmarks like Stonehenge and historical documents like the Magna Carta symbolize this enduring legacy.
- *Ethnic Identity:* The concept of an indigenous people is often linked to ethnic identity and cultural practices. The English language, customs, and traditions form a distinct cultural identity that has evolved over millennia.
- *Land and Ancestry:* Indigenous status often includes a strong connection to ancestral lands. The English people’s ties to the landscape, historical sites, and regional identities (such as Cornish, Yorkshire, etc.) reflect this deep-rooted connection.
### The Challenge of Globalism
*1. Impact of Globalization:*
Globalization brings significant changes, including economic integration, cultural exchange, and demographic shifts. While it has benefits, such as increased diversity and economic opportunities, it also poses threats to local cultures and identities.
*2. Arguments Against Unchecked Globalism:*
- *Cultural Erosion:* The influx of diverse cultures and global media can dilute and overshadow traditional English customs, language, and values.
- *Economic Displacement:* Mass immigration, particularly of low-skilled workers, can lead to wage stagnation, unemployment for native workers, and increased strain on public services and housing.
- *Community Cohesion:* Rapid demographic changes can lead to social tension, reduce community cohesion, and challenge the integration of newcomers into the existing cultural framework.
- *Heritage and Identity:* The unique historical and cultural heritage of the English people may be at risk of being overshadowed or lost amidst a global culture.
### Strategies for Cultural Survival and Heritage Preservation
*1. Legal and Policy Measures:*
- *Cultural Preservation Laws:* Enact and enforce laws that protect historical sites, cultural practices, and traditional languages. Support cultural festivals and heritage education.
- *Immigration Policies:* Implement immigration policies that balance the need for economic growth with the preservation of cultural and social cohesion. Prioritize skilled immigration that aligns with national needs.
- *Support for Native Traditions:* Provide funding and institutional support for the preservation and promotion of traditional English arts, crafts, folklore, and local dialects.
*2. Community Initiatives:*
- *Education and Awareness:* Promote education about English history, culture, and values in schools and communities. Encourage local history projects and cultural exchanges.
- *Cultural Centers:* Establish cultural centers and museums that celebrate and preserve English heritage. Organize events that highlight traditional customs, cuisine, and arts.
- *Local Empowerment:* Strengthen local governance and community initiatives that empower residents to maintain their cultural identity and address the impacts of globalization.
*3. Economic Measures:*
- *Support Local Businesses:* Encourage policies that support local businesses and traditional industries. Promote local produce, crafts, and services.
- *Fair Trade Practices:* Implement fair trade practices that protect domestic industries and workers from unfair competition and exploitation.
*4. National Identity and Unity:*
- *Promote National Pride:* Foster a sense of national pride and identity through public campaigns, national holidays, and the celebration of historical milestones.
- *Inclusive National Narrative:* Develop an inclusive narrative that respects diversity while emphasizing common values and heritage that unite all citizens.
### Philosophical and Ethical Considerations
*1. Rights and Responsibilities:*
Balancing the rights of individuals to move and live freely with the rights of native populations to preserve their culture and identity is crucial. The concept of negative rights—freedom from interference—applies here, ensuring that cultural preservation efforts do not infringe on individual liberties.
*2. Ethical Frameworks:*
- *John Locke's Natural Rights:* Locke’s philosophy underscores the importance of property rights and the protection of individual freedoms. These principles support the idea that English people have a right to preserve their cultural heritage and land.
- *John Stuart Mill’s Utilitarianism:* Mill’s emphasis on the greatest good for the greatest number can justify policies that protect the cultural and social fabric of society, ensuring long-term stability and prosperity.
### Conclusion
The English people, with their deep historical roots and rich cultural heritage, can be seen as a native first nation within their ancestral land. The challenges posed by globalization require a balanced approach that respects individual rights while actively preserving and promoting cultural identity. Through legal, policy, and community initiatives, England can navigate the complexities of modernity, ensuring that its unique heritage and identity endure for future generations.
4
-
1