Comments by "Manish K S" (@Manish_Kumar_Singh) on "Punjab u0026 Bihar: tale of 2 states — one slowing, one rising — and case for farm reforms" video.

  1. I am from East UP, us and biharis are abused in entire india, i have always tried to hide my identity wherever It's possible.
    4
  2.  @mxxmauuhan3597  Sikhs outside punjab are prospering more than sikhs inside punjab.
    3
  3. so all the comparison UPA vs NDA is stupid ?
    2
  4. supply and demand cannot run on predetermined price. also 5rs biscuit can be sold for less and or more, it's just an indicative price and not a MSP from government Also the production of grains can be done for 800, so why should the GOI pay twice that? And that too to punjab only? when we have an over production and massive wastage of grains. Also i can say the same thing for punjabis moving abroad to capitalist countries in the NATO block
    2
  5.  @karanveer900  please visit Mumbai or kannada and see for yourself
    2
  6. punjab is nowhere 76 or 81, otherwise youth wouldn't be moving to kanada
    1
  7.  @anjankumarchowdhury7379  you are assuming wrong
    1
  8.  @anjankumarchowdhury7379  then why stop the reforms? bihar produces grains literally half the price of punjab with half the subsidies and if Ambani starts procuring from there and if FCI is privatized, no one will grow anything in punjab. and you would have your typical Bihari labourers either. And then the rest of Punjabi youth will either become biharis themselves or have to move to kanada. green revolution was one sided
    1
  9. 40 %, what? UP produces more than punjab and Harayana combined, and MP produces more than punjab alone
    1
  10.  @karanveer900  Yeah..... Punjabi dhosa on the menu
    1
  11. Amul guy is a Punjabi and they brought the dairy revolution in india by private sector so why now this?
    1
  12.  @amitkp6957  Why stop at wheat and rice? Why not milk or poultry or multitudes of different vegetables and fruits? This is pure paranoia and propoganda
    1
  13.  Akansha Yadav  everyone else thinks that every other Bihari is a Lalu.. Seriously
    1
  14.  Akansha Yadav  he would have either conquered indian or would have removed the East coast from India
    1
  15. yeah, they are just 6% of the farmers dictating laws for the rest of India. And they know they can't do it democratically so the blackmailing
    1
  16. they can still sell in Middle East, infact many south Indian states do. So there is no requirement for cpec, also since it only adds Pakistan in the mix (which is even worse)
    1
  17.  @simg8277  Lol another idiot. crop diversity was done by Kerela without GOI HELP , why not your state try that? Also GOI didn't force anyone to grow anything, it just gave out money in subsidy. Also how come Harayana has developed an industrial city and not punjab? It's your fault and the fault of your politicians, if india wanted to Suck Punjabi blood it would be this rich and Sikhs wouldn't be one of the richest communities in india. also the population of centeral Asia is lesser than delhi and Mumbai put together, it's not a huge market anyways. The fact that there are no industries in punjab is because all your youth has left for kanada and the ones remaining think about khalistan 24x7. Seriously, i study at top engineering colleges and we see more Muslims than Sikhs in our classes.
    1
  18.  @simg8277  NCR is a cash source for HR and and cities being power houses for economy is true everywhere in the world otherwise Canada wouldn't be importing punjabi youth. Its' a Economic zone, punjab could have also had asked for the same but your CM is busy giving free electricity . Also we paid money for the grains and did not eat it for free in the 60's , thats where your plane tickets to canada comes from. again, the grans surplus only destroy punjab ? why not tamil-nadu or kerela or harayana ? it's your state's fault for not being a forward thinker and depending on FCI for your income. also those who think punjab is occupied can go to canada and clean dishes there or whatever.
    1
  19.  @simg8277  so in short , Punjabi farmers will be safe according to you, right ? because Sikhs are rich and have large land ? so let the rest of India suffer , we dont need you to protest for us
    1