Comments by "红火树 RedFireTree" (@firetree2007) on "Why India should be wary of SCO | The India Story" video.

  1. McMahon line was just a proposal by British Raj to China as a bargain for discussion in the conference of 1914, no Chinese government agreed to it. Even British Raj did not use McMahon line as border, that is why at the all time in British Raj , Tawang, which is on the side of British Raj on map was still controlled by Tibet local government, only after India got independent, in Feb, 1952, Indian government sent army to take Tawang, occupied it and forced Tibet local government official to leave, this is clearly recorded, and even celebrated by India, PLA on the other hand, only reach Lhasa on October of 1952, which is still 600 km away from Tawang without road.
    3
  2. it is not easy to change historical records, even from Indians, read Indian former diplomat, Avtar Singh Bhasin, book "Nehru, Tibet and China" to know the details, but Indians just chose not to recognize the truth, insist on holding what in history clearly show not India's, South Tibet, India does not understand, you are not British Raj, China is not Qing's China, not even Republic of China (in TW now), the PR China will never give up China's territory, the best way is for India to send it back peacefully, or just wait our hypersonic missiles arrival
    3
  3. the whole thing is based on India trying to inherit what British left illegal claims over China's territory, Nehru knew it, but he chose to fight China, and lost, today, Modi government is doing the same again, like Nehru, India will be defeated only 1000 times worse than 1962. read Indian former diplomat, Avtar Singh Bhasin, book "Nehru, Tibet and China" to know the details.
    3
  4. on the west sector of the border, Aksaic chin, it was always with China, Qin's map clearly showed it, so China never even bother, after founding of new China in 1949, China started build road 219 to connect Xingjiang with Tibet, then PM Zhou Enlai got report, saying Indian army was stationed inside Aksai Chin, (I think Zhou must have thought, what the fk??) Zhou asked Nehru to withdraw from there, sure proud and heroic Nehru would not listen to Zhou, only one day in 1962 reported to the India parliament that, "India army was defeated in both west and east sectors by the Chinese army" with tears in his eyes,
    3
  5. on the one hand, currently most Indians hate Nehru, for he lost war to China, on the other hand, Modi is much worse than Nehru, Nehru at least with blls, he dared to send Indian army into China's territory and ordered Indian army to just "kick the Chinese out", but for Modi, even lost 1000 sq km to China, he just told his people, the Chinese did not even take an inch from India, hah :)) such a coward
    1