Comments by "红火树 RedFireTree" (@firetree2007) on "Top Secret Advanced Medium Combat Aircraft (AMCA) Project Revealed By Dr Ashis Kumar Ghosh" video.

  1. do anyone hear any technical experts in the US talked about design of F22 before it was made??do anyone hear any technical experts in China talked about the design of J20 before it was made?? do Indians even understand what top secret means?? if you openly talk about it, is it still a top secret?? I simply put engine data here, you will see that this AMCA will not be very advanced based on the fact that India cannot make advanced jet engine: simple compare, no need to talk too much, data will show and prove, when India is criticizing China, look what they have??: let take the data from this video: WS-15 max thrust: 30,000lbs after burner : 40,000 lbs OK India's dream "indigenous make " Kaveri K-10 Maximum thrust: Military thrust (throttled): 52 kN (11,687 lbf) Full afterburner: 81 kN (18,210 lbf) (planned to be refined to >95 kN) see the difference? and it is not even working, India even cannot make this engine yet. what Tejas is using now is GE F404 Maximum thrust: 11,000 lbf (48.9 kN) military thrust 17,700 lbf (78.7 kN) with afterburner can you see the data?? OK, India will use GE f 414 for its Tejas MK2, suppose to start in 2022, Maximum thrust: 13,000 lbf (57.8 kN) military thrust 22,000 lbf (97.9 kN) with afterburner tell me , anyone of them even close to the performance of WS-15??? good for India to have a top secret project leader like him, everyone can take it easy and go to a long sleep, when wake up in 2060, he is died someone replaced him still talking.
    1
  2. Lakshman Gowda  you think?? who gives a fuck what do you think?? you think Americans like Indians just talk about anything they are going to do??
    1
  3. Ninad Bhave  you have a strange logic, here we discussing AMCA, not LCA, your plan is to use GF F414 for it, that is I mentioned WS-15, I know your LCA is using GE F404. Your AMCA is suppose to counter balance China's J20, not just for national pride, although almost nothing to be proud of as the reasons I have pointed out, always too late and not useful. as for your ISRO, the same, it only for yourself, compare to China, your space program is also far behind China's, your rocket capability: LEO 14 tons GTO 4 tons compare to China's LEO 25 tons GTO 14 tons India media reported in 2009, saying that India would send a man to space in 2015 and walk on the moon by 2020, what a joke.
    1