Comments by "BC-Guy" (@bc-guy852) on "Anders Puck Nielsen" channel.

  1. "Russia's economy is collapsing and is turning itself into a disposable camera'. Got it! Thanks Anders.
    288
  2. This is your best interview / podcast yet, in my opinion Anders. While not uplifting and positive your guest is imminently qualified and has some great insights. Thank you for putting this together. I would follow Maxime's English channel and look forward to the existing episodes with subtitles. A great guest.
    125
  3. Was that nine minutes? It seemed to fly by! A lot of good interpretation and analysis there Anders - it flows so easily because you present it so well - and it just makes sense. Thank you for the effort you take to put these together!
    76
  4. It's nice to hear somewhat-encouraging news; from a trusted source. Thanks Anders. The courage and determination of the Ukrainian people and forcesswhile fighting with only a portion of the protection they were promised (in multiple signed agreements) is absolutely incredible. Slava Ukraini.
    65
  5. So well said. I was stunned and felt humiliation for the people of the USA!
    61
  6. I'm subscribed with notifications on since the first episode I viewed Anders. Thanks for your unique insights and analysis. I hope your projects go well and you'll be able to continue here soon; otherwise too many of us will lose the value of your great experience and insights.
    59
  7. Great analysis Anders, thank you; I know these take a LOT of time to put together. I agree that this could be the start of a very significant phase. Today, Ukraine has changed its rhetoric and says that 'full withdrawal from Crimea must be achieved before any talks can begin'. A bold statement that I think they can pull together.
    57
  8. Excellent analysis - as usual. Thank you. I still think the elimination of the RAIL section of the Kerch Bridge is paramount. Stop putin from bringing in trainloads of tanks and supplies every day - but still allow them a route to retreat from the imminent Ukraine advance. Perhaps it would be too much to take out the entire bridge, (were that even possible) but the high accuracy of the HIMARS and ML270's will allow that sort of precision.
    51
  9. Thank you Anders! Always a logical, calm, rational explanation of the current madness. With trump acting out like a spoiled child, virtually every day, the world needs these interpretations and analysis, I know I do.
    33
  10. I'm always left more-reassured about all things pertaining to this war after Anders Puck Nielsen posts a new video. Anders, your fantastic presentation skills, even tone and logical explanation can make sense of the most obscure and confounding events being done or considered by this madman putin. Thank you for taking the time to prepare another episode. Don't go away so long, please!
    19
  11. I ALWAYS feel better, less stressed and more calm after each of your episodes. There is so much twisted information out there - and you are a trusted source. Thank you Anders, (I'm heading to the linked article now.)
    19
  12. Can you imagine how cool it would be to have Anders as your instructor at the Academy?? A gifted guy for sure!
    18
  13. This man is Gifted! An uncanny ability to explain complex concepts so the underlying principles are clearly understood by just about any viewer. Definitely more. Thank you Anders!
    18
  14. Fabulous episode Anders. The maps, but especially the annotations are great and appreciated. Your content and analytics are SO impressive, thank you. I'm really looking forward to your upcoming interview with Jake Broe; with the fabulous, new annotations added, you will have over 100K subscribers - within a week of the podcast!
    16
  15. We've missed your sage and sobering analysis Anders. Thank you for this. Congratulations on your book Sir! I expect it will soon be published in English!
    14
  16. Excellent analysis as always Anders. Thanks for the effort. Your lectures are always fact-based, succinct and you communicate so well. You should have (soon will have) a TON more subscribers. Great analysis Sir!
    14
  17. Another great analysis and perspective Anders, thanks. I would like to hear more about the whole aspect you referred to as 'an aside'; how to deal with the War Crimes?! Another comment about putin appearing drunk - or at least with a champagne glass in his right hand... Is this to justify his right hand trembling when not holding something and him a little unsteady? But - the War Crimes!! He Must Pay!
    11
  18. Always great to hear from you Anders! What effect does the massive inventory of so-called heavy equipment have on this analysis? I understand that a great deal of what russia needs to progress and arm themselves comes from abroad and that most of the iron in 'storage' is decades old and needs major refurbishment before use. What is the key? Is it stopping russia from bringing the iron to the front line (Kerch Bridge) or more about the new tech that they are having to source from behind the line of sanctions?
    11
  19. Another great analysis Anders, thank you. The quality of your analysis has been a big part of how you've achieved 100,000 subscribers so quickly. Congratulations on 100,000 subscribers Sir - well earned! Clearly your professional career gives you a different perspective that many others miss.
    10
  20. Thanks Anders. Your analysis is always informative and very welcome.
    10
  21. Your lessons / lectures are always so well laid out, organized and with such strong supporting evidence that when you're done I think - 'Well yeah, when you say it like that - it all makes sense.' Thank you for your time and effort. I guess putin has made many of us, who never would have considered these aspects of a war no one expected, to be studied and discussed by so many. Hopefully that will speed the resolution. Slava Ukraini.
    10
  22.  @bluelogimouse2123  But your comments look neither rational nor objective, based on facts. I'm done with your trolling. Bye.
    9
  23. Anders, you consistently produce high quality videos that are well-researched, professionally presented and extremely thorough. I think the analysis you provide are on-point and that you do an exceptional job overall. Each episode! In my opinion - you should have hundreds of thousands of subscribers and tons more views that what's shown now. Great Work Sir!
    7
  24. Well said! I totally agree. A TED Talk quality lecture, exactly on-point, succinct and perfectly delivered. Anders should have, (soon will have?) hundreds of thousands more subscribers!
    6
  25. 3. russia implodes under the weight of their catastrophic losses in naval vessels, irreplaceable aircraft (A50's) and crews and leaves Ukraine when the Kerch Bridge is dropped, (which happens soon). 4. russia is broken up into many smaller countries after the revolt of its awakening sheep.
    6
  26. Thank you Anders. Between you Jake, Perun, Denys and The Russian Dude I feel I am getting a well-rounded view of the war and the crimes committed by russia. Your analytical and calming style is reassuring as the emotions of more violence against civilians and civilian infrastructure before Winter take hold.
    6
  27. I find some of the most engaging comments on your videos. Thanks for making the time to prepare and create these presentations!
    6
  28. You sound great Anders - I hope you're feeling better soon! Such a great episode; it all makes so much sense when you explain it that way! Not sure if the specific date of 'two months' made an impact but for sure, having allthe key wagner 'executives' get on one plane (to make a presentation about Africa plans to putin??) was a stroke of brilliance. The world is better off without them.
    5
  29.  @gnothiseauthon6045  And such great hair!!!
    5
  30. It seems like a lot has changed in 13 months Anders. Do you think China is still on the same exponential ship construction path they were on before the implosion of their economy and the 'complications' of the zero-covid policy? And of course the whole world has changed since russia invaded Ukraine...
    5
  31. Your episodes are ALWAYS a spot-on analysis in my view. Your thorough and professional analysis is very much appreciated. A pleasure to watch.
    5
  32. Insightful, impactful and succinct. Just as we've come to expect from you Sir. Thank you Anders.
    4
  33. Another thorough and very concise analysis Anders; thank you. You provide the most interesting and introspective analysis available and you speak from a position of knowledge and experience. We're glad to have you as a valued resource! Can you discuss the logic behind 'refusing to unleash Ukraine?" WHY are they not allowed to strike back - the way russia is attacking Ukraine? WHY NOT allow them to eliminate the Kerch Bridge and strike Rostov On Don power and water infrastructure?
    4
  34. When I saw the heavy trucks blocking Moscow and St. Petersburg city cores to prevent the masses from gathering I knew that change had begun. I believe that you are correct in every aspect of your 'improvised studio' assessment. The momentum is palpable and change is imminent.
    4
  35. Pro Ukrainian comments - being auto-deleted. SHAME ON YOU YOUTUBE!
    4
  36. "The Nexus' are adjusting..." An accurate and interesting analysis in my view. Canada has both a Navy and a Coast Guard. I wish we were much more vocal about enforcing on encroachment of the Canadian Arctic, especially since we've seen invasions by russia in other regions. Combine russian aggression and warming waters with resources and there is attractant to the bear... I would support much more purpose-built equipment and some sort of responsibility sharing - Now!
    3
  37. The trump camp and the russians are already essentially alligned. I agree that this whole charade is to position the political stance. It's all propaganda and confuse-speak, intended to befuddle us all into not caring... FORTUNATELY - we have you Anders - who regularly takes the smoke out of the room and restores clarity. Thanks Anders!
    3
  38. I REALLY like your stuff Professor! (sic) please don't mind a few comments along the way as to style - all meant to help... - (shirt and tie in newer vids is nice - even just a shirt with a collar) - camera is too high in this one - you're almost cropping out of image (but good to keep PowerPoint overlays high for those who use subtitles) - can you crop the lower boundary of the video (to not show the hands moving so much) Some presenters do it so much it is distracting - like conducting an orchestra - distracts from the spoken word. Your motions are natural IMO but a tad much for me. (Just ONE opinion.) - first bit of background music on this one - too hot - boomy. But nicely done. (I use a THX rated system and I have never noticed any sibilance or plosives in your audio. Nice!) - date stamp is a nice touch!! - I play some of these in the background - and although I speak English - I do use subtitles instead of backing up; yours are already corrected. Again - nice! And I completely concur with your analysis with one caveat - - that is, that Putin - has not gone mad.
    3
  39. Your analysis and forecasts have been spot-on all along Anders; I think your predictions for future outcomes will very likely become reality. Thank you for the work you do, making this all make sense.
    3
  40. YES!
    3
  41. I think you're being a little harsh with this review Anders. While I agree that Ukraine has received a lot of support and equipment for 'maneuverable warfare' but I do NOT think they are underperforming or at risk or losing support from the west. russia lied about the invasion and have had over a year to prepare for this counteroffensive. This will take time and even more support. It will happen!
    3
  42. The red lines set down by putin are nothing more than 'brown lines'! russia is saying and doing everything they can (changing nuclear use doctrine and firing IRBM's) because the russian economy is on the brink of collapse. The ONLY thing that putin has - is the SMO - when the war is lost - he knows he is done. They will say anything to get the US to stop supporting Ukraine. SUPPORT UKRAINE MORE!
    3
  43. I enjoy these enough to watch them again, months later! (You're gonna' hit 100K subscribers before the end of the year!)
    3
  44. Just too funny ivan. Do you have ANY idea the qualifications and experiend 'this guy' has? I guarantee he is more qualified, more experienced and better educated than you are. So, I can understand why your only option is to 'lash out' - with multiple nonsensical comments. (russian trolls are comical.)
    3
  45. I completely concur Anders. I think that Ukraine was more-involved in the latest drone attack because they CHOSE: to not heavily arm the drones with warheads to kill civilians, to attack during the day - so the billionaires and senior government officials could see them all get through - and raise the real threat of war within that untouchable crowd. It's more 'Ukrainian genius'.
    2
  46.  @edwardblair4096  He's a very gifted lecturer. And, FYI, I think even now, you can press the three dots to the right - and either delete or edit any comment you post.
    2
  47. I hope you're wrong Anders!
    2
  48. Your coverage and analysis is again - superb. Thank you for taking the time to create these insightful and thorough examinations of what is happening. Great stuff! Thanks - from BC Canada
    2
  49. I'm always better informed about these things - after I watch one of your balanced presentations Anders. And I'm 'smarter about the Arctic' now!
    2
  50. While I agree that russia is weighing options: long war or short war, I think the ever-opportunistic Xi Jinping is just sitting back with a grin on his face, wringing his hands wondering just how much of russia he should plan on taking, not IF China invades russia - but WHEN! And I think putin has trusted him and russia WILL pay the price - in land and human losses. Long war, short war - no end-scenario where putin remains free and rich.
    2
  51. Thanks Anders. You consistently take what appears to be crazy circumstances or frontline situations that look like a madman's outbursts and make them make sense. It turns out it IS madman putin's impatience and lack of military knowledge (initially inspired by his greed) that has russia backed into this situation.
    2
  52. Make Russia Small Again - - I like it!! Heroyam Slava!
    2
  53. Always very insightful Anders, thank you. Personally, I think along with some form of ground attack, the UAF will find a way to disable or destroy the Kerch Bridge. And that one structure, is the key to russia's ability to resupply Crimea - which then will soon-afterward, find an honourable way to leave - retreat - and end this.
    2
  54. I agree with your observations Anders and you present a good argument. BUT, I think you have underestimated the cumulative effect of virtually the whole world siding with and supporting Ukraine. Russia had two treaties with Ukraine - and broke them both. The world - supports Ukraine and is not letting up - intensifying in fact. New munitions being sent (ATACMS - finally), F16's, more MBT's... putin can hope to remain in his bunker and hide but Russia is going to be broken up over this. It is no longer 'Stalin-days'... the russian sheep are waking up and they WILL support the overthrow of russia as we know it. You're right - but you're wrong. This time - there are too many cameras, too many people all over the globe who ARE standing up to this madman's GREED. Yes - putin has to be gone before any major talks can happen. But Ukraine must force putin to LEAVE the occupied lands and then if reparations are not willingly agreed to - - Ukraine can take back their costs - by taking over parts of russian assets. Russia was a paper tiger. Full of bluster and bravado - and TicTok warriors. Russia is done. Putin bluffed - - and is about to fold.
    2
  55. "let's just say that the russian plan... is not based... on impeccable logic." And this brilliant statement applies to this entire FUBAR invasion. The SMO that has morphed into a War, was impeccably ILLOGICAL - from the start. Thank you Anders.
    2
  56. Cannot handle logic and reason ivan? Perhaps - adjust your copium levels - - then you'll see reality - but it won't bother you in your hazed-out state.
    2
  57. I believe, (not certain) he is a senior advisor to the Danish Navy. I have seen him, in Uniform (on the national news, in Canada, 18 months ago!) speaking about an incident in Danish waters. Sit back and enjoy - Anders is one of my favourite speakers on geopolitics and I think you'll enjoy further content.
    2
  58.  @IainMcClatchie  Good points. I guess with all the promotion Putin put into the opening of the bridge (on occupied land) that it would just feel good to stop that rail line right there. But I don't disagree. Your knowledge of the local geography is much better than mine.
    2
  59. Prigozhin is going to have a flight - bu it's going to be out of a window...
    2
  60. We would not be here and we would not be looking at this scenario - - IFF the United States had honoured its commitment to the Budapest Memorandum back in 1994.
    2
  61.  @aaronbaker2186  Or until putin is overthrown (by all those grieving mothers!)
    2
  62. Pure Bull$hit. russians - trying to cope. Have you run out of copium ivan?
    1
  63. More Bull$hit!! Can you do anything besides spout russian propaganda ivan? How's the Black Sea Naval Fleet looking - oh, wait, EIGHT warships - including the mighty moskva - - are all on the bottom of the sea!!! Destroyed by - - wait for it - - A Country WITHOUT A NAVY!!! And - those irreplaceable A50's - The Most Importand aircraft in the russian air farce - - TWO blown out the sky - in 30 days! And the 'highly-trainded crews'. A THIRD (of only 8!!) was damaged in belarussia and components are not available to repair the damaged dome! (The important part). Sure ivan, whatever you say. LOL May I suggest you adjust your copium levels? Your current dose - ain't makin' it. SLAVA UKRAINI
    1
  64. Did he say "because the earth is round???" LOL Merry Christmas Anders. Thank you for brining your input and analysis to us. You have contributed MUCH to the coverage of this war and I appreciate it.
    1
  65. Heroyam Slava!
    1
  66. Nonsense - or Bull$hit - you pick. Russia has been fully mobilized - taking protesters off of the street and sending them to the zero line - as their way to shut up protesters - since the beginning of the war - oops SMO. Ukraine has been kicking russian ass - not only in terms of the russian air farce losses - - what about the (former) Black Sea Fleet??? EIGHT of them on the bottom of the sea - - compliments of a country that HAS NO NAVY! F16-s are on the way (and perhaps already in theatre) and are going to make russian pilots load their shorts. The cannot even fly their A50's - - 200 km's inside russia!!!
    1
  67. Thank you Anders. I ALWAYS feel better after viewing your excellent lectures. You're a great instructor making complex concepts easy to understand. Thank you. Mad Respect from BC, Canada.
    1
  68. Does anyone care?
    1
  69. Ukraine is creating dilemma for russia. More effective than creating just one problem. Smarter tacticians. And russian corruption has caught up to them; the dam collapse may result in the destruction of major heavy weapons manufacturing facilities - all due to graft, bribes and misdirected funds. REAL dams would have prevented this.They were BUILT IN 2010!
    1
  70. Wow - a troll who can quote some facts. Novel. Unfortunately, you are not an authority on the matter and you neglect to consider that russia is GETTING ITS ASS KICKED. How's the Black Sea fleet looking?? Oh yeah - - ON THE BOTTOM! How's the russian air farce doing lately?? Oh yeah - have lost 2, (perhaps 3) of The Most Important aircraft in their air farce in the past 30 days. russia is done.
    1
  71. Too funny. NOT true - but funny. And hey, ivan - did you just skip over the fact that NO russian troops have been rotated? They just push them to the zero line and force them to become cannon fodder - at the fear of being shot in the back. Now - wagner group is no more - and there are no more prisoner conscripts to sacrifice. russia - is done!
    1
  72. Agreed. Not too long at all. An EASY like and I subscribed before even viewing any of your other videos - and I will get to them all. Your presentation style, manner and great insights are incredible.
    1
  73. Thank you Anders. I was wondering why 'we' aren't doing anything about these incursions - - but after your explanation, I see 'we' are indeed.
    1
  74. Only until the FSB decides it's time he is 'served tea' or has an accident at a high window.
    1
  75.  @wanderinginrussia6813  How do we know this is the only reason?
    1
  76.  @wanderinginrussia6813  operative words... "right now". Things ARE going to change in russia and soon. Your leader has gone mad and is delusional. Unfortunately his ravings are causing untold suffering for many. He will be defeated /overthrown / tried for war crimes / executed. No escape to armoured superyacht or palaces for him.
    1
  77. I agree totaly with what you've presented Anders. putin is 'all-in' and he has doubled-down on this war of GREED. russian lives mean nothing to putin - putin believes all russians are 'disposable'; he has chosen to make munitiuons instead of rebuilding the demoloished infrastructure in MOSCOW. His war is more important than his people... So there will NOT be any warning; therefore we should all prepare.
    1
  78. You make a great point about how far back this was likely planned - and after resting and having had rested his troops for a month. It's all good for Ukraine. I doubt prigozhin will just disappear now and I don't think he will ever become czar. I think he too has a flight booked - - out of a window.
    1
  79. a) Given that we agree with you, we had better get Trump's Team to view and understand this video b) The world should be wiser now, since you've pointed this out and we should prepare! c) Thank you Anders. Please keep doing what you've been doing - you do it so well Sir!
    1
  80. Fabulous episode Anders, thank you for saying it like it is! You're right, you dignify twitter/x with your presence there, I'm glad you left on principal; I suspect many millions are /will soon enough. I suspect trump and his new bestie will find a way to make money by merging twitter to truth somehow?
    1
  81. You explained the differences in the development perfectly, thank you so much. I love the new graphics and annotations; makes it so easy to follow. Greetings from BC, Canada
    1
  82. I totally agree on each of your points Anders. I think putin orchestrated it; it serves many purposes. Those you have pointed out, plus the psychological warfare aspect that russia gets to hold over all of Europe and, it prevents any Coup attempt - that perhaps had ideas of 'turning the gas back on' once putin was gone. Now, there is less 'reward' to deposing putin - those who would do so can no longer 'turn the taps back on' - not for a long time if they're permanently damaged.
    1
  83. Informative indeed Anders. So again, it IS in the interests of ALL in the world to support Ukraine NOW - with anything they need - and to allow the use of 'Western' munitions inside russia to defeat them now. Many analysts make similar observations and recent declarations (ridiculousness notwithstanding) proove this is russia's intent - now stated on paper. The US Republicans are playing a dangerous game of chicken with global democracy, at risk,
    1
  84. Perhaps your are right - Anders has integrity and speaks the TRUTH. donald trump uses coercion, extortion and economic sanctions to TRY to get what he dreams... but when trump wakes up - he is STILL A CONVICTED FELON, sexual predator and delusional old man who lied and bought his way to his job. CLEARLY the WORST President the USA has ever had - but they did it again.
    1
  85. Thank you Anders.
    1
  86. Fabulous review Anders - thank you! (You're looking good with this background!) Is there a chance that Denmark will let YOU tell us when the first F-16's WERE shipped to Ukraine? We know that Ukrainian pilots are training on F-16's in Denmark for some time - but some of us think / hope that one or two are already in theatre - and doing GREAT things. Can you share now?
    1
  87.  @bluelogimouse2123  Really? ... instantly demonstrate? I suggest you check out a few of his other episodes and then kindly 'state your proof' in some context of actual events. A simple analysis of the numbers of ancient pieces of ill-maintained iron and ore or few, modern weaponry prototypes has not garnered the once mighty russia any significant victory - in almost seven months. They lied to the entire world and attacked thinking they would wrap things up in a week. Second most-powerful military in the world?? Perhaps if you go by the specs... Second most powerful military in UKRAINE - for sure. And about to be kicked out.
    1
  88. russia is DONE. Finished. Kaput. OVER. putin tried to expand what he thought of as his Empire - - only to engage in a STUPID "SMO" that instead of gaining him Ukraine's resources - - is going to lead (has already led) to the Demise of russia as a nation! Make russia small again!
    1
  89.  @Calvito-  Really. So are you posting the link to YOUR video for us to review???
    1
  90.  @antoinemozart243  I'm going to indulge you with one reply - then mute you - troll. NONE of that artillery works without ammo and it ALL needs fuel. Both of which are being disseminated by the well-informed, well-supplied Ukrainians. Wait for the Lend-lease gear to arrive. Goodbye!
    1
  91. Exactly. The trolls and propagandists and haters can vent and spout their lies all they like. They do not vote in the USA, in November. And even the few that might be real Americans - only get one vote - despite hundreds of posts. So, yeah - once trump is defeated at the only poll that matters - the November election - we can get back to the real fight.
    1
  92. Just too funny. Can you do anything besides spout russian propaganda ivan? How's the Black Sea Naval Fleet looking - oh, wait, EIGHT warships - including the mighty moskva - - are all on the bottom of the sea!!! Destroyed by - - wait for it - - A Country WITHOUT A NAVY!!! And - those irreplaceable A50's - The Most Importand aircraft in the russian air farce - - TWO blown out the sky - in 30 days! And the 'highly-trainded crews'. A THIRD (of only 8!!) was damaged in belarussia and components are not available to repair the damaged dome! (The important part). Sure ivan, whatever you say. LOL May I suggest you adjust your copium levels? Your current dose - ain't makin' it. SLAVA UKRAINI
    1
  93. Thanks for making the illogical-russian-actions make sense Anders. Your analysis not only clears this incident up and illustrates how plausible that it IS a russian false flag attack - it also shows the method of evaluating other events to follow. We know - russia will continue to do this and lie their way along...
    1
  94. Ignore the troll.
    1
  95. This is a dumb comment based on the video. Did you watch the video?? Are you even real?? Are you a bot - or a troll?
    1
  96. You didn't have any real comment - anything of subscance - so you post this trite and then upvoted your own comment - - didn't you? Too funny. MORE COPIUM ivan!
    1
  97. Carlson is a russian asset. Follow the money.
    1
  98. Thanks Anders. Your common sense analytical review summarizes this madness and makes it make (a bit more) sense.
    1
  99. I'm only part way through your video but want to suggest you clear a bit of space on your wall - that YouTube 100 K member plaque won't be long in arriving based on what I've seen in just two of your videos, so far! Exceptional analysis, presentation, annunciation, pace, lighting, background; even wearing a shirt with collar - and tie... You missed your calling as a University instructor perhaps Professor Nielsen?? I look forward to the rest of your catalogue.
    1
  100. True, but they have HUNDREDS, perhaps over one thousand, of these illegal, unflagged, uncertified vessels in many seas. It's another series of ecological disasters just waiting to go. And - they don't care...
    1
  101.  @kenlieberman4215  Well documented! Well said. I agree completely.
    1
  102.  @romanmoldavan521  Too funny troll! Terrorism is what putin did with his WAR and invasion on February 24th. Anything Ukraine does as a result of that - in the Donbass or on ruzzian soil - is fair retaliation. And by the way troll - have you not noticed that virtually the entire civilized world - is behind Ukraine? They ARE winning. Orcs WILL retreat - or become fertilizer.
    1
  103. "From a military perspective, this (russian tactics) is not a smart way to do it..." That about sums up not only the premise to lauch a full-scale war on your neighbour but the logic of the naive tactics since then! russia is doomed and will collapse despite putin's greed for power and empire. So nice to hear essentially that - from an analiyst as reknowned as Anders. Thank you Sir!
    1
  104.  @barryhamm3414  Good. Then they can surrender and get warm.
    1