Comments by "srini sbir" (@srinisbir8781) on "India has always been Hindu, but Hindu Rashtra doesn't figure in the ancient texts : Wendy Doniger" video.

@jomalhotra Jyothi mam. Please stay out of religion. Nothing good comes out of discussing religion and its origins, etc.. Religion is faith based. Humanity has grown with this unshaken faith over time. Some religions, such as Semitic ones, force their belief onto the others. Eastern religions keep it to themselves, as it should be. You cross-questioning eastern religions from a western, so-called expert is quite demeaning. But because that religion (Hinduism, sanatan dharm) is tolerant, you are only treated with browbeating in the comments section. Consider calling an expert and fiddle with the origins of Islam and let's see if you stay alive. Good luck to your journalistic career.
7
@MegaLeoben Nobody is representing anyone. People are just expressing opinions. Last I checked democracy should allow freedom of expression.
4
@MegaLeoben That Ram wasn't born in Ayodhya. Is she saying Valimiki is a liar?
3
@MegaLeoben Really. Tell me one other place than Ayodhya that he was born.
3
@MegaLeoben So why doesn't she question the existence of Prophet mohammed, Jesus Christ, to name a few? Let her play with Semitic fire once in her life. I would keenly listen to that.
2
@MegaLeoben agreed. But all those real authors explicitly claim their work to be fictional. I don't see Valmiki ever claiming his treatise on Lord Rama to be an art of fiction.
2
@MegaLeoben Exactly, I am only expressing disapproval to Wendy (randi whatever) assessment of the birth of Ram. It is clearly written in Valmiki's Ramayana that Lord Ram was born in Ayodhya, so what is her source of the complete opposite? Again, I am not like radical islamists who behead those that I am upset with. I just chide them. Did you get in your Megabrain?
1
@MegaLeoben What is your job sir? Are you paid by print to moderate the chatting room here?
1
@MegaLeoben If you don't know then shut your trap. Wendy as a Jew has ZERO right to fictionalize any other religion. My reference is Valmiki Ramayana, which was contemporary. Is Wendy denying the existence of treatise on Lord Rama by Valimiki Rishi? Really??
1
@MegaLeoben Did you care to find one more place other than Ayodhya where Lord Ram could be "purportedly" born? Also, why don't we question if Lord Ram existed in the first place.
1
@MegaLeoben You referred to Valmiki as Valimikini. Your disdain towards Hindu religion is so transparent. So, what neutrality do you bring in this argument anyways?
1
@MegaLeoben So you agree he wrote a book. Then in next sentence you say, there is 0 evidence he existed. So, who wrote the book? Are you telling Valmiki used a ghost writer?
1
@MegaLeoben yeah because people had a lot of time back in those days for reading fiction.
1
@Nocou islam = jihadism = pasmanda = discriminatiom
1
@Nocou haha islam was created to rule over the world. Leave no difference of opinion.
1
Why does she care about India saving millions of ruppees by building a channel through Ram Setu?
1
Where was Ram born by the way?
1