General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
John Beerschoten
Middle East Eye
comments
Comments by "John Beerschoten" (@JohnBeerschoten) on "Man in Gaza holds outside world accountable as people found decomposing in their homes" video.
@delatorrecilla Israel has no right to exist on other people's land. This follows from the November 2nd 1917 Balfour Declartation. When you read the one page carefully. It states the conditions by the British Crown under which the refugee jews were allowed to live in Palestine. One of the conditions is “‘that nothing shall be done which may prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-jewish communities in Palestine”. Consistently violated.
48
@delatorrecilla I respect you.
10
@soggybadrongle Who are they and on what legal basis do you think they are?
5
@GingerIndiana You talk, talk, talk, but you don't even have the courage to identify yourself. Are you surprised by what happened in the 40's - 45's? I don't and it will happen again.
3
@GingerIndiana There is no good understanding of terrroristm. The definition is: “Terrorism (from the Latin word terror, panic) is the commission of serious violence, or serious threat thereof, WITHOUT LAWFUL GROUNDS, for a political or religious purpose. In most understandings of what terrorism is, it must involve illegal violence, usually linked to civilians and victims. This means that Hamas is not a terrorist organization but a resistance movement that even has the right to use violence. Israël, together with the US are the terrorists because the occupation is not a legal ground.
3
@GingerIndiana The International Community (UN) does not have the right to constitute a new state (Israel) on other peoples land (Palestine), without their consent. This follows from the one page November 2nd 1917 Balfour Declaration on behalf of the British Crown. The same thing happened at the Berlin Colonial Conference 1884-1885. Africa was divided among the European powers. Not a single African was present, so no consent. There is no legalization for that, it is unlawful, just like in the Palestine case.
3
@GingerIndiana The Berlin Conference took place from November 15, 1884 to February 26, 1885, in which Africa was divided among the European powers. Without one African present and without consuling the African people. Thus without their consent. This is called colonization. The same goes for other people to decide over the territory of Palestine without the consent of the people, as in 1917 by the British Crown, is called colonization. The International Community (UN) does not have the right to constitute a new state (Israel) on other peoples land (Palestine). This follows from the one page November 2nd 1917 Balfour Declaration on behalf of the British Crown.
2
@JayEdwards-oz7ss The questions like who owns the land and who was there first are no relevant legal questions. The term "Palestinian' refers to the people who live and lived there in that territory, Muslims, Jews, Christians, Atheists and Humanists. The term 'jews' refers to a religion. Palestinians are born there, immigrannts are not. Mind you that immigrants often have skin cancer. Read Jimmy Carter: Palestine, Peace not Apartheid; Shlomo Sand: The Invention of The jewish People and: How I Stopped Being a Jew; Rashid: The Hundred Year's War on Palestine; Ilan Pappe: The History of Modern Palestine.
2
@GingerIndiana Not the Israeli immigrants but the Palestinians are the descendants of the inhabitants of the area known as 'Historic Palestine'. The Palestinians have a fascinating Arab culture.
2
@GingerIndiana https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6LACse017-A&t=2s
2
@GingerIndiana Wrong. What is your source? Are you a zionist? Read Jimmy Carter: Palestine, Peace not Apartheid; Shlomo Sand: The Invention of The jewish People and: How I Stopped Being a Jew; Rashid: The Hundred Year's War on Palestine; Ilan Pappe: The History of Modern Palestine.
2
@GingerIndiana They cannot enter the mosque. And yet you notice that their religion is respected. You're confused. Is that respect for their religion? You really don't know anything because you are obsessed with your own religion.
2
@GingerIndiana Read Jimmy Carter: Palestine, Peace not Apartheid; Shlomo Sand: The Invention of The jewish People and: How I Stopped Being a Jew; Rashid: The Hundred Year's War on Palestine; Ilan Pappe: The History of Modern Palestine.
2
@GingerIndiana Israel has no right to exist on other people's land. This follows from the November 2nd 1917 Balfour Declartation. When you read it carefully. It states the conditions by the British Crown under which the refugee jews were allowed to live in Palestine. One of the conditions is “‘that nothing shall be done which may prejudice the civil and religeous rights of existing non-jewish communities in Palestine”. Continuous violation.
2
@GingerIndiana Not the Israeli immigrants but the Palestinians are the descendants of the inhabitants of the area known as 'Historic Palestine'. The Palestinians have a fascinating Arab culture.
2
To pray is not enough.
1
@GingerIndiana de wet nooit zullen volgen en gehoorzamen, ook niet na 75 jaar. Let's be enlightend. There are bad and good things written in the Bible yet, that does not make it the Word of God. These books, including the Torah, were written by and for the jews themselves. There is no Word of God other than our conscience, no Chosen People and no Holy Land. The land was and is Palestinian territory in the Arab Middle East. All the Israelites must be moved to the United States because the Israelites have abused, during 75 years, the unique and dubious opportunity for their own state. They will never follow and obey the law, not even after 75 years.
1
@GingerIndiana This jewish illusion is nothing more than a religious obsession, imagination and a fantasy. The entire Middle East is Arab territory, so what can the stupid jews expect?
1
@johnMcHale-j5s Not do you say there? It is not clear.
1
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/V8S6OMFKvKk Golda Meir, I'm a Palestinian.
1
@soggybadrongle What do you know about God? Let's be enlightend. There are bad and good things written in the Bible yet, that does not make it the Word of God. These books, including the Torah, were written by and for the jews themselves. There is no Word of God other than our conscience, no Chosen People and no Holy Land. The land was and is Palestinian territory in the Arab Middle East. All the Israelites must be moved to the United States because the Israelites have abused, during 75 years, the unique and dubious opportunity for their own state. They will never follow and obey the law, not even after 75 years.
1
@CalistoLP All the Middle East is Arab territory, not for white Western immigrants only based on religion. They get skin cancer there.
1
@truthseeker7612 You're more than welcome. I have to keep the messages short. So read Jimmy Carter: Palestine, Peace not Apartheid; Shlomo Sand: The Invention of The jewish People and: How I Stopped Being a Jew; Rashid: The Hundred Year's War on Palestine; Ilan Pappe: The History of Modern Palestine. And this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6LACse017-A&t=2s When people seem untruthful I ask them their source which they often don't have. Take care.
1
@gulgl3817 Being sorry is not enough, praying also is not enough.
1
@JeneNsns-m1u What is your source? You can say whatever you want, but you need to motivate. If it's not based solely on your imagination.
1
@JeneNsns-m1u Have you actually studied deeply in the Torah what God said to Abraham through the burning bush?
1
@JeneNsns-m1u And do you understand what it says in Luke 21 verse 24?
1
@JeneNsns-m1u Where did you get that from, do you have a source? Educate me, but don't wait too long because I'm not interested in slow people.
1
@adamcorbett5289 That's interesting. So what do you say to Golda Meir who said this: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/V8S6OMFKvKk She also said I'm a Palestinian. Like Ehud Olmert, Shimon Perez and many others. Who is confused here? Two questions for you.
1
Golda Meir said this: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/V8S6OMFKvKk
1
@GingerIndiana You had time now to read Jimmy Carter, Palestine, Peace not Apartheiod. You still believe the Arabs in Israel have the same rights as the Israli jews? If so you are confused by your own imaginary religion, like Karl Marx said, your religion is your opium.
1