Comments by "John Beerschoten" (@JohnBeerschoten) on "New Film Examines American Jews’ Growing Rejection of Israel’s Occupation" video.

  1. Nancy, this is an interesting and important subject to talk about. My question would be to your dad: "what did made hin think he is/was a jew?" I remember what the zionists told me 50 years ago as it was yersterday. I have 69 now. My question is stil there.
    44
  2.  @yiannimil1  A religious argument has no value in court.
    36
  3.  @barmoleydd6300  I fully agree with your comment and i will not stay silent. As a Humanist and a scientist in this case I stand with the Arab people in the Arab territory of Palestine .
    27
  4. 100 % agree as a Humanist and a scientist and a lawyer. Almost everyting is documented, that will help.
    24
  5. I don't get it. Why are they calling themselves jews?
    14
  6. I don't get it. Why are they calling themselves jews?
    3
  7.  @gavrielmusheyev141  Gavriel, what makes you say I'm jewish and a zionist?
    3
  8.  @stephenjohnstone8812  How?
    2
  9. Nonsense
    2
  10.  @cinesonicvibes  Interesting. Can you name me your source. I will look t it. For you it might be interesting to read the one page Balfour Declaration November 2nd 1917. It is about the time when refugee jews went to Palestine and the conditions stated by the British Crown.
    2
  11.  @nancymathisen9707  Thank you Nancy, I appreciate your answer. Of course I read the 66 books in the Bible. The Thorah, the Old and New Testament. I recently read Jimmy Carter: Palestine, Peace not Apartheid; Shlomo Sand, The Invention of the Jewish People; Rashid: The Hundred Year's War on Palestine and Ilan Pappe, A history of modern Palestine. Very enlightening by these historians. I have friends who stopped being a jew. Isn't that funny? Take care.
    2
  12. Jennifer, what makes you say I'm a jew?
    2
  13. I do not believe in Israel.
    1
  14. I wonder what you understamd about "jewish peple".
    1
  15. All illusions. After all, the Arabs are also Semites. I respect the Arabs.
    1
  16. ​ @nuitsnight  What are you talking about? I don't see your logic. My question is what makes people say "for me as a Jew".? I never hear people say, "For me as a Buddhist, or Christian, or any religion." Read: Shlomo Sand, The Invention of the Jewish People. In my opinion we are talking about an obsession, a cult.
    1
  17.  @sun-9988  Youy mean the attack like on October 7? Is the ongoing illegal occupation not a terrorist attack?
    1
  18.  @annfrancis6287  The explanation can only be that the jews base their claim on religion and not on the law. Their religion says in the BIble that there is a promised land. There is no promised land because the Bible is written by the jews themselves, not by God. God does not write books.
    1
  19. The Arabs are Semites too. So what are these ignorant people talking about.
    1
  20.  @supertrucker99  Sorry , i do not know what you mean.
    1
  21. ​ @larinarozevich4869  Israelis have no right to security while occupying other people's land. Do I have to explain and motivate that? I will.
    1