Comments by "Neolithic Transit Revolution" (@neolithictransitrevolution427) on "Israel Has No Post-War Gaza Strategy." video.

  1. Well that simply is untrue.
    9
  2.  @muhammadadeel8639  wow. That's a new claim
    8
  3. We need a UN Mandate over both Palestinian regions, with a coalition council of Saudi, Egypt, and Jordan (and potentially UAE and Turkey) in charge, and a local Palestinian police force under their Command, and a small IDF rapid reaction force also acting as peace keepers under the councils command. We obviously can't have local rule, Hamas is an example of the danger, and the population is widely radicalized for understandable reason. We obviously can't allow Arab military control of the region, as Israel would never allow it. And we obviously can't have Israel in control. This allows accomodation of all. The mandate should last 20 years, with an off road map allowing local elections for a continuation of mandate, single Palestinian state, two seperate Palestinian states (and a second election for Gaza if it chose unification and West Bank chose to go alone, for example), an option for West Bank to join Jordan, and Gaza to join Egypt, or either to join Israel. That provides skin in the game for all members to aim for successful development. Syria, Iraq, Morocco, Lebanon, Kuwait, and Qatar should also be in an advisory role, with potential for the UN to swap them in if a state in the council sees a government direction not amenable. And Israel should be allowed certain veto rights that can be over ridden with UN general vote to address security concerns.
    8
  4. @lif6737 excellent reply.
    8
  5. I want to say the Irish set the precedent. Or maybe Serbia. Could have been Algeria though. Edit: wait was it the US?
    7
  6. Well, tbf, the current military government is in charge because they kicked out the Muslim brotherhood, and they won't let Gazans in because they are worried it will add to their ongoing insurgency by the Muslim brotherhood in Sinia.
    6
  7.  @dain6250  the irony with your statement (which is largely agreeable to me) is that the area actually under Israeli occupation (west bank) isn't the source of issue, and the area Israel exited to allow an attempt at Palestinian state hood and independence is where the attacks come from.
    5
  8.  @hmada1222000  you know Israeli jws come from middle easter countries, and the European ones are mainly in New York, right?
    5
  9.  @SpaceMarine500  both? Both.
    4
  10. Hey, that was the US' post war Afghanistan plan. Stop ripping off other peoples homework.
    4
  11.  @007kingifrit  times are very different. For one thing, several Arab states recognize Israel (as would any state in the governing council have to be required to). And unlike the 1940s, most of those Arab countries have seen their own Jewish populations leave to Israel, and I truely don't believe they want to take action that would lead to their return. Israel allowed these countries to deal with their own "Jew problems" without taking action. Also, unlike the previous UN mandate, this would be under an Arab controlled coalition.
    4
  12.  @amnont8724  it's not, because the countries you listed aren't actively fighting a war against Ukrainian minorities in their own countries.
    3
  13.  @kevChess  it's certainly more than "that difficult".
    2
  14.  @KathyXie  only the French in the north though. The French in the south were still just french collaborators /s
    1
  15.  @oakhauser  Noah was kinda like "what de fuk". He just got to live.
    1
  16.  @hmada1222000  you know most Jews in Israel originated in middle Eastern Arab countries, right? Most of the European Jews are in New York.
    1
  17.  @hmada1222000  you know most of the Jews in Israel originated in middle Eastern countries, right? Most of the European Jews are in New York.
    1
  18.  @nicholasjohnson778  well be fair, something like 60% of Gaza is under the age of 18. You find me a population of peaceful teenagers living in abject poverty with a finger to point blame at. Teenagers are angsty, angry, and suicidal at the best of times.
    1
  19.  @nicholasjohnson778  your stance just shifter from "show me the good Palestinians" to "all Palestinians are rapists and murders". You asked how people can support Hamas, I'm saying 60% of those people are at an age where they at the age American kids shoot up schools.
    1
  20.  @harlowida  kinda a moot point but I think the Navajo have a support group you could join.
    1