Comments by "bas kir" (@vinsin328) on "S Jaishankar's 6 phases of Indian foreign policy u0026 5 axes of Modi Govt’s vision | ep 317" video.

  1. Question is why India rejected the borders given by Britishers when they left. Why Nehru wanted to renegotiate border with China and Pakistan on J&K? Britishers left India with both Tibet and J&K. Nehru declared J&K as an international disputed territory and gifted Tibet in 1950 and signed agreement in 1954. Nehru even agreed to give Arunachal Pradesh to China.
    4
  2. It was always like that. All leftist party around the world has always been sympathetic to Muslims and their cause. They are funded by China. Muslims have always been used to partition country around thr world. It is a win-win situation left-Muslim unity.
    4
  3. India was bankrupts and western power forced India to open economy and stop celebrating poverty if they want money.
    2
  4.  @parthasarathyvenkatadri  India already gave her Veto to China. There is nothing called effective veto. Anyway you never answer any questions.
    2
  5. Nope, Pakistan and Indian Muslims want another partition. It was India/Nehru who claimed that Arunachal Pradesh is part of Tibet. Nehru wrote books and even signed Panchsheel agreement. So why India doesnt want to give that to China, that is the question? You have not done anything. You are refusing to implement agreements that you have signed.
    1
  6.  @iashoksingh  So border issue with Pakistan can never be settled. Only with China with give and take of Aksai Chin.
    1
  7. True, but India has supported China in her territorial ambition. It is India who created territorial dispute because of unclear mind in Indian PM.
    1
  8.  @732anoop  Indira Gandhi did that. It was against Indian constitution, illegal and as per law she is a traitor.
    1
  9. People objected to that even at that time. People in Indira Gandhi government begged not to sign such an agreement. But she did. So you are wrong that Indians were in tune with Simla agreement.
    1
  10. That is against democracy. Bureaucracy follow orders. Bureaucrats are not answerable to anyone in that case.
    1
  11. How?
    1
  12. how?
    1
  13. So you are ready to give Arunachal Pradesh to China.
    1
  14.  @rajsattamsahoo  Agree. Jaishankar clearly said we are timid people.
    1
  15.  @rajsattamsahoo  Why?
    1
  16. Agree.
    1
  17. True, some even wrote Is Nehru PM of India or China? But there is another angle to it. Indian Muslims in India opposing human rights and secular laws and do not want India to become a Veto Power country. For Nehru being PM was more important then India national interests.
    1
  18.  @savithakl7577  majority Muslims lived in cities. Muslims were always poorer. 25% of Muslims had 12% of economy in 1941. Lahore 80% Muslim had 20% economy stake. Karachi 49% Muslims had 20% economy.
    1
  19. 1) Converted LOC to International Border. 2) Punished Pakistani involved in genocide. 3) Return of Indian POWs 4) Cancellation of Liaquat Nehru Pact.
    1
  20. Fail in what? Which exam Modi's India writing? India is a nation as far I know. Modi also do not have any children. What other India beside from Modi's India exists? Are you Indian? If not then why are you worried?
    1
  21. China has veto power, what India has to offer?
    1
  22.  @monojdas-gupta5918  Agree but both the problem created by India.
    1
  23. It was India/Nehru who never put any case against Pakistan on aggression. Nehru went and called that as a disputed territory and wanted to make J&K as an Independent country. Nehru failed to give reasons why J&K should be an Independent country? It was Nehru who begged for plebiscite. What was their misrule?
    1
  24.  @physicsonline8853  So how was he later on? What evidence you want? Why dont read before you speak? It was Pakistan who opposed Independent J&K.
    1
  25. You are right. Soviets were pressuring Gandhi to make sure that they accept all the demand put by Pakistani and agreement reach and signed. USSR was not ready to support India on taking POK. But Gandhi had an option to convert LOC to International Border. Indian Muslim and Bhutto made sure that no agreement made in that case. Gandhi also did something illogical, she pardoned Pakistani personal involved in Genocide and released all pakistani POWs without asking for similar gesture from Pakistani side. Indian 1971 war POWs are still in Pakistan. Indira Gandhi also promosed Pakistan to help build their nation.
    1
  26. ok, how?
    1
  27. How? India rejection to become a Nuclear Power Nation and helping China to become one was the issue.
    1
  28. why do you want to do that?
    1
  29.  @parthasarathyvenkatadri  So British Raj was better than Independent India.
    1
  30.  @parthasarathyvenkatadri  How? How Indian interests impacted or become bad during British Raj? Indian had 3-4 times more resources under her influence during British Raj compared to now.
    1
  31.  @parthasarathyvenkatadri  You cannot change your geographical location.
    1
  32.  @parthasarathyvenkatadri  How they were not consider citizens of Empire? Cant they get education in UK? Were they not part of British Army? Were Britishers not spending money on education, development, industrialization etc? You didnt answer the questions - did you like the sphere of influence British Raj had o r not?
    1
  33.  @parthasarathyvenkatadri  And where India can increase her sphere of influence apart from Bangladesh and Bhutan?
    1
  34.  @parthasarathyvenkatadri  So Britishers had feudal mindset, How? What about Indian, how is/was their mindset? So you think that British Raj would have been better to check China?
    1
  35.  @parthasarathyvenkatadri  You dont have even veto power, you cannot compete.
    1
  36.  @parthasarathyvenkatadri  UN.
    1
  37.  @parthasarathyvenkatadri  So how come British Raj was more powerful then China?
    1
  38. It is territory belong to Nepal which India annexed for national security and security against China.
    1
  39. They are loosing Kashmir. Can USA, Britain, China, France and Russia claim part of J&K after article 370?
    1
  40. Anti - america without any logic still exists in major part of India.
    1
  41. India do not want to give Arunachal Pradesh to China as agreed in Panchsheel agreement of 1954. In case of Pakistan, India do not want to give J&K to Pakistan as Nehru/India supported by declaring that as a disputed territory. What India can give to China for Arunachal Pradesh? Pakistan and Indian Muslim want right for another partition if J&K not given to Pakistan.
    1
  42.  @ansumannanda8289  Why do you lie? China was not member of UNSC at that time, so they can make such offer. Why do you lie and spread BS? Why Indians do not know to be shut up when when they dont know the answer?
    1
  43.  @prasantkumar7254  Possible by 2/3rd majority vote.
    1
  44. He said after loosing to China, security was consider as important thing in India replacing morality.
    1
  45.  @trao355  Yes, Nehru never consider J&K as part of India. He never declared a war for J&K, he was reluctant to do so. 2-3 weeks of war he fought for 1 yr and then suddenly declare ceasefire.
    1
  46. Those are disputed territory not part of India. By your logic Arunachal Pradesh is part of China? Do you agree?
    1
  47.  @Raishubham_rnc  True, agree but Nehru/India declare that as an international disputed territory in UN and signed the same in Resolution.
    1
  48.  @Raishubham_rnc  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kashmir_conflict#UN_mediation
    1
  49. How that is impacting you and India?
    1
  50. That is not what Indian neighbours want.
    1
  51. India will get Arunachal Pradesh and China Aksai chin. India will also get rest of the border as wanted. Nehru rejected that offer.
    1
  52. True but there are reasons related to incomplete partition also. India got all the poor Muslims whereas all the rich and powerful left to Pakistan.
    1