Comments by "bas kir" (@vinsin328) on "Why did Guardian fire cartoonist? Tracking anti-semitism, via Shakespeare, Karl Marx, Krishna Menon" video.

  1. 98.5% of Indian Muslims opposed Gandhi and voted for Pakistan. So Gandhi's intolerance was only limited to Kafirs. Gandhi was not seen as a leader for Muslims. Religious intolerance is from Muslims and is still there.
    6
  2. Zakat is not a tax. Jizya is a protection or humiliation tax. Taxes are equal for all citizens, they don't defer based on religion. Jizya was used to force convert Kafirs to Muslims or as a pretext to spread slavery.
    4
  3.  @arjuniyer5047  They did face prosecution, humiliation, Jizya etc.
    2
  4. They created three countries. Syria and Jordan for Muslims and Israel for Jews as demanded by Muslims (not by Jews). 90% of the land and resources were given to Muslims. Read some history.
    2
  5. Jews never demanded or were given sanctuary in Gujarat.
    1
  6. It is not that simple.
    1
  7. True, but Daya for whom?
    1
  8. So why has not been done to Muslims of India yet? Jews never wanted to kill Nazis, that was not the case with Muslims of the subcontinent. Your comparison is wrong. It is the other way around. Just because Kafirs of India don't want another partition of India, doesn't make them anti-Jews.
    1
  9. Nehru supported those ideas himself in the name of the Muslim vote bank.
    1
  10. Religion is a product of Hate or the job of religion is hate. The majority of the people are religious. If someone tells you that you should allow him to be killed for his religion and you oppose being killed then you would be seen as opposing that person's faith. No one hates anyone in the name of ethnicity, origin and caste or even color.
    1
  11. He spoke against Jews also, called them polluted people (In a capitalist sense).
    1
  12. Nope, that is an incorrect statement. Religion means anti-empathy.
    1