Comments by "Neil Forbes" (@neilforbes416) on "The CED: RCA's Very Late, Very Weird Video Gamble (Pt. 1)" video.

  1. 7
  2. 2
  3. 2
  4. 1
  5. 1
  6. 1
  7. In 1929 when RCA(still part of General Electric) bought the plant at Camden, New Jersey, and the Victor brand-name, that's ALL they should've been allowed to buy. The His Master's Voice brand was 100% owned by The Gramophone Company of England Pty Ltd., and The Gramophone Company should've IMMEDIATELY REVOKED The Victor Talking Machine Comany's licence to use the HMV trademark. Prior to World War One, The Gramophone Company of England held 50% of the HMV brand, the other 50% being held by what was, at that time, the British company's German parent, Deutsche Grammophon Gesellshaft mbH, under which, the trademark was known as "Die Stimme Seines Herrens". Emile Berliner, who had established the German and British companies, also set up the Victor Talking Machine Company in Camden, New Jersey, but only as an afterthought. Victor was an insignificant minor side-operation. It owned not even the smallest fraction of 1% interest in the HMV trademark and the patents on the trademark and the products made, disc-playing gramophones and the discs themselves were registered by DGG and The Gramophone Co. Victor played ZERO part in the development and/or improvement thereof, they just made and sold the product, nothing more. In 1918, after WW1, DGG lost the Gramophone Co and Victor Talking Machine Co. as "spoils of war". Indeed, DGG could now only use the HMV trademark in Germany itself and only under licence from its former division, now fully-fledged independent company, The Gramophone Co. DGG found itself in a similar situation to its insignificant American offshoot, Victor. The HMV trademark was now 100% British-owned and Victor was now paying licence fees to Britain for the privilege of using the trademark and building the HMV gramophone for the US/Canada market and putting its own name on what was basically a British product. So that brings us back to 1929 and two jokers come sniffing around the Victor plant at Camden, initially just wanting greater floor space to expand radio production, but seeing what was going on, deciding to get in on the act, and here is where The Gramophone Co. should've said "STOP! You can buy the plant and the Victor name but the rights to the HMV brand are NON-TRANSFERABLE! The Brand is EXCLUSIVELY the property of The Gramophone Co. of England and will remain so until WE deem otherwise!"
    1
  8. 1
  9. 1