Comments by "Steve Valley" (@stevevalley7835) on "The Battle of Jutland - Clash of the Titans - Part 1 (Beatty vs Hipper)" video.

  1.  @TheLeper2001  In the 1960s, Avalon Hill produced a game based on the battle. The game was initially fought on maps, and, when British and German units were found to be at the same coordinates, then cardboard tiles for each capital ship and each CL and DD squadron were used to lay out and fight the battle, using speed and range measuring devices and hit probability tables. A battle in progress on my living room floor looked very much like what Drac showed in the video. In the version of the game I had, the ship tiles were flat cardboard with a drawing of the ship, and numbers denoting speed, gunnery and armor factors. I would not be surprised if a later version of the game had molded plastic ship tiles like Drac used in the video.
    3
  2.  @joshthomas-moore2656  my two cents worth: BCs cost as much to build as a BB. BCs cost as much to run as a BB. Due to their armament, they will, sooner or later, be stuck into a battle against BBs, where their glass jaw will become evident. iirc, one of the Kongos was sunk by cruisers in the Solomons. To my eye, BCs are poor value for money. BCs are at a disadvantage against BBs, yet they can be taken out by a group of 3-4 cruisers. One of my nightmare scenarios is the IJN realizing the Kongos aren't up to the job around 1938, and converting them all to carriers, so they will not be stuck into a surface engagement, which would give the IJN a massive superiority in air group strength early in the war.
    2
  3. In the presentation, Drac says that, as a result of British code breaking, the RN knew the Germans were coming out and planned to intercept them. When I read about Jutland in the 60s, the events were described as the RN being on a routine "sweep" of the North Sea, searching for any German ships that may be about, and, by luck, ran into the entire German fleet, with no mention of German codes being broken. Was the fact that the German codes were broken kept secret by the British government until sometime after the material I read was written in the 60s, with the entire action being declared a lucky coincidence?
    1