General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
Cole Behnke
TIKhistory
comments
Comments by "Cole Behnke" (@colebehnke7767) on "“Hitler privatized the industries” is ridiculously misleading" video.
What’s Nazi apologist about it? Did you watch the video?
8
So they weren’t a totalitarian state?
7
@bananabourbonaenima when has socialism been about equality?
7
@bananabourbonaenima dam, that’s the goal of the Nazis, they just thought that you needed a permanent revolution, otherwise socialism would decay back to a previous state, and so a state was required for permanent enforcement of socialism.
6
Dam, it’s almost like that was addressed in the video…
6
How so?
5
@TlsMS93 get this georgism out of here.
5
@guerillagardener2237 so government officials bought the company, and that’s somehow privatization?
4
How is he wrong?
4
@guerillagardener2237 uh, so the Soviet Union was capitalist?
4
@guerillagardener2237 uh, you did watch the video, did you not? They didn’t privatize the companies, they sold some of the stocks the government had to Nazi party officials. So they sold the government owned businesses to the government.
4
@TylerLee-g7f dam, google is so trustworthy, it spews unsubstantiated claim like no other.
4
How so?
4
Yeah, e believed the communism was corrupted by the Jews and that he was recovering the true primitive communism.
3
Private property was suspended in 1933, years before war. And did the “owners” actually own the profits?
3
So you didn’t actually watch the video. Like socialists kill other socialists all the time.
3
How so?
3
Wow, it’s almost like Marxism and Nazism are different socialist ideologies. One based around class and another based around race.
3
Or is it the other way around?
3
Tell my you didn’t watch the video without telling me you didn’t watch the video…
3
@jb34ch1 we have, socialists don’t use those texts anymore because they have already tested them and they result in totalitarianism.
3
@KansasHempMan I care not for your racism, socialist.
3
@julymagnus493 just because his definitions flew over your head doesn’t mean he’s wrong. Was the Nazis party a public or private institution?
2
How so?
2
Did you watch the video?
2
@julymagnus493 what are you talking about?
2
@julymagnus493 I personally disagree with TIKs definitions, but even by any other definition the Nazis were socialists.
2
So how exactly is he wrong?
2
So you didn’t watch the video?
2
How so?
2
@LaborPrince yeah you should actually watch the video before making such claims. Unions with autonomy? In a socialist state? What are you taking about? Yeah if you didn’t pay attention to the video, Nazis weren’t Marxists, they were race based socialists. They abandoned the idea of class conflict and replaced it with race conflict. This is why they supported class collaboration while still be socialist. You have any evidence that they were pawns of big business? Any businessmen with substantial power that weren’t members of the party/state and thus public agents?
2
When self branded socialists enact socialist policies.
2