Hearted Youtube comments on Whatifalthist (@WhatifAltHist) channel.

  1. Sex and Cultute by JD Unwin explains the fall of civilizations as well
    1
  2. I was born ready, let's see who's remembered in our upcoming age of heros. An American age of heros!
    1
  3. May the lord have mercy on us all. The coming decades will show who is a soldier and who is a serf.
    1
  4. Visit any grave yard and you,ll hear not one complaint from the dead.
    1
  5. It will burn itself out once the Monster energy and ZYN run out😂
    1
  6. 🎯 Key Takeaways for quick navigation: 03:37 🏫 The video aims to explore why the American educational system is expensive, biased, ineffective, and disliked, focusing on primary and grade schools. 05:25 📚 The speaker argues that our society has become culturally illiterate, citing examples of historical knowledge and literacy levels in the past compared to the present. 06:06 🧠 The decline in the complexity of language in speeches, eye-twitching speed as a proxy for intelligence, and other factors suggest a potential decline in intelligence over time. 15:37 ⚖️ The video explores the societal shift towards valuing STEM education over the humanities, affecting the understanding of science, politics, and societal issues. 20:11 🔄 The push for equality in education is linked to industrialization's need for uniformity, affecting how people are educated and potentially contributing to a decline in overall intelligence. 24:09 🏫 The school system's focus on conformity, docility, and standardization is rooted in historical factors, including the managerial revolution and industrialization. 26:03 🌐 Modern America sees a unique phenomenon where even the elite class pretends to be rebels, leading to an absence of a true ruling class with a clear focus on leadership and decision-making. 29:15 🔄 The uniform structure of education in today's society contrasts with historical practices, where education varied based on factors like geography, social class, occupation, and gender. 32:40 🧠 The current educational model tends to suppress creativity and individuality, favoring standardized testing and bureaucratic processes, hindering the development of genuine passion for learning. 42:26 📚 The education system's shift towards left-wing ideologies, ideological indoctrination, and lack of oversight has led to a decline in educational standards and a betrayal of societal values by some teachers. 47:32 🏫 Teachers, often high in agreeability, may resort to manipulation due to an inability to assert themselves, contributing to societal issues. 48:12 🌐 Woke culture may have originated from teachers' attempts to manipulate through guilt, influencing societal beliefs. 50:23 🚸 School environments discourage authenticity, creating a fake and sterile atmosphere where students cannot express honest opinions. 51:18 ♀️ Modern education systems, favoring compliance and stillness, are designed for women, leading to the feminization of schools and weaker populations. 53:38 🔄 Education restructuring is proposed, advocating for shorter, more practical learning hours, trade schools, and personalized approaches for better results. Made with HARPA AI
    1
  7. Science admits it doesn't know why Big Bang while religion fools itself into thinking it does
    1
  8. Did you forget to add Jonathan Black's: Secret history of the world to your reading list (apropo you final comment!)
    1
  9. I believe moderns have emotions all right, in fact they display a serious lack of emotional control. However, they also display a serious lack of depth of character, many seem to have no character whatsoever. As such they are extremely emotional about things which either don’t matter, or have it completely ass-backwards. They don’t actually care about liberty, that requires a high degree of emotional control, self-restraint, real factual knowledge, and genuine empathy. Rather, moderns are obsessed with license and the APPEARANCE of virtue, and as such our civilization is a ticking time bomb, and we don’t have much longer before it explodes.
    1
  10. Am I being stupid and it's because there was no state formed there, only people
    1
  11. To be read in the format of the Drake meme: Science: yes Scientism: no Markets: yes Neoliberalism: no Genetics as history: yes Racism and social Darwinism: no Spirits existing: yes Woo woo new age crystal healing: no Politics: yes Boomer politics: no Humble, honorable uncertainty: yes Total visions of the world that are wrong: no Democracy: yes Democracy where most of the population is poor and illiterate: no Religion: yes Naive literal interpretations of ancient texts that have nothing to do with you: no Sounds pretty good!
    1
  12. I honestly think that the reason why God predestined Europe to be Christian is because of how stupid western philosophy is (among other things) just imagine how we would be if we never had Christianity. We would easily be the most evil civilization in the world by far without question. This is why God didn’t send the apostles to ancient kingdoms like India, China, or Persia. Christ came to save the lost not the righteous and this applies to peoples as well as to people.
    1
  13. You phone knows when you are sleeping, it knows when your awake, it knows when you've been bad or good... Sounds like my phone might be Santa Claus
    1
  14. I live in Montpellier. You can just imagine my surprise hearing the name of my hometown in an American video while I was ds doing the dishes 😂
    1
  15. One semester at the University of Alabama put me 15k in debt so I said nvm lol
    1
  16. Almost half a million Rudyard. I remember when you where at 10k! Congrats my man!
    1
  17. 36:42 You remembered my comment about Laredo 😂 Most people would have cited El Paso instead.
    1
  18. this is sooo true... you are my most favorite channel for over a year now. i go over to my best friends house and force them to watch your videos. you are the only creator whom i download all their videos and keep that download folder upto date. you are one of very very few people on youtube who can really teach me about humanity, consistently, on the macro scale, with every video.
    1
  19. Newsflash, Europe is/was a woman. Unfortunately for you she's into bestiality...
    1
  20. Okay Rudyard, but have you considered that number go up = good?
    1
  21. You were right im wright this week after watching and after gathering my thoughts on it and observing the daily life it hits like a train
    1
  22. A better way to understand parts of the mystic world is to listen to music from different cultures and different time periods. Music is a reflection people and the world the surrounds them, both spiritually and reality. I have a hypothesis that the ability to perceive music is actually a form of adaptive synesthesia. Synesthesia is a condition where someone can perceive a sense through another kind of otherwise unrelated sense. An example of synesthesia being how some people are able to perceive the color of other peoples voices. The idea goes that long ago, some proto-humans evolved with the ability to perceive emotions through patterns in sounds. This lead to the ability to communicate in a similar fashion to how some birds communicate. Humans later evolve a singing voice, leading to finer motor control of the mouth and vocal cords, and later setting the path of the invention of language. I don't have anything to prove this but to me it make more sense than other hypotheses out there. Also, to the modern line of thinking, music makes absolutely no sense yet it exist everywhere in spite of modern logic. Just something to think about.
    1
  23. funny how pretty much all the problems in modern society are caused by the state or high time preferences.
    1
  24. Lemme be clear fellas, I've been a militant marxist for a decade and I know the kinda people that populate those organisations. They dont really take us seriously. You can kill yourselves all you want, you can show signs of complete disengagement and disillusion and maldaptation to this world, you'll still carry within you the Original Sin of masculinity and all the innate "dangers" it comes with. As much as I didnt want to believe it, this sht cant be. A feminine ideology cannot carry society on its shoulders. It's not natural. The blood of young men is the driving force of the wheel of history. I'm worried this entire social landscape will lead to a dramatic shift towards extreme positions on the other end, but it's our job as men to grow to the level of masculinity and responsibility that (most) our fathers didnt raise us up to.
    1
  25. "Germans have had a tendency across their history to do what they want without consulting other countries" You mean like everybody else have treated the Germans though history when they were not united?
    1
  26. I think it’s important to remember the amount of distractions competing for our attention has exponentially grown over the last century. Boredom has become akin to some disease, and thus core intellectual skills aren’t properly cultivated, especially during the most critical times of youth. Perhaps this is only exacerbated by the cultural rat race we have established that almost pits parents against kids in an effort to keep up with the Jones’. Parents don’t have/take the time to sure up any lacking areas as they should.
    1
  27. So basically we will see the emrgence of more Chinese gigachads who will get wives through fighting.
    1
  28. youre an anti chinese capitalist hack
    1
  29. What is this? -99999999999999 social credit. You will be sent to a re-education camp shortly.
    1
  30. Honestly I'm just impressed with how the people in power are kicking the can so successfully. The Great Wave and the dollar endgame and the coming economic recession should have all hit a while ago. I guess liquidity and hand waving magic tricks on the house of cards goes a long way.
    1
  31. Rudyard, this 1774 journal entry by John Adams nicely sums up New England's traditional view of the Foundry, I think: “Philadelphia with all its trade and wealth and regularity, is not Boston. The morals of our people are much better; their manners are more polite and agreeable ... Our language is better, our taste is better, our persons are handsomer; our spirit is greater, our laws are wiser, our religion is better, our education is better. We exceed them in every thing, but in a market, and in charitable public foundations.”
    1
  32. This could be one of the most important videos ever created - fundamental piece of work congrats Rudyard. Anyone wondering what I’m on about, imagine replacing this with some of the dreck making it’s way through schools right now. - An antidote to identity politics
    1
  33. "Our media is not that intelligent..." Shows a picture of Brian Stelter. lol
    1
  34. @WhatIfAltHist ... Could you PLEASE make a video explaining Gnosticism and the under-the-surface influences it has had on our modern societies?! From Marxism, to Fascism, to Port Modernism, to New Age and even "Atheist" religions. People are so hell bent on believing that humans are in full control when they are free from religion that they fail to realize that they are practicing another religion. And there really aren't ANY good videos explaining Gnosticism beyond short exposes of the Cathars. The only one that delves into it in depth is James Lindsay but he's not the easiest to follow.
    1
  35. Joe Biden was born in 1942, Vladimir Putin was born in 1952, Xi Jinping was born in 1953. These are all old men, the first is demonstrably senile and the latter two are close to being de facto autocrats. A video analysing the coming deaths of Putin and Xi as potential catalysts of civil unrest and possible collapse as their underlings vie for power would be interesting.
    1
  36. How did my meme end up here 33:23 Absolutely based
    1
  37. Science must quite evidently be pursued WITHOUT ideological goggles (be it left OR right wing, take note) or, God forbid, financial pressure behind one's back. Otherwise it's trash, either deluded or repusively dishonest.
    1
  38. Give a man a fish and he will eat for a day. Give Whatifalthist a pen and he will draw a map in which all roads lead to the rust belt.
    1
  39. Israel is third world?!
    1
  40. Smug Redittor: Um, ackshully, if the spirt world did exist, we would've found it already and it would be in all the textbooks and peer-reviewed journals ever. The CIA: NO ONE CAN KNOW ABOUT OUR PSYCHIC SPY PROGRAM, LET ALONE ITS SPIRITUAL IMPLICATIONS
    1
  41. So basically. To sum it all up. Modernity and the modern world is a world made up of people who have a long history or high aptitude for explanation and critical thinking within a certain box. They reject or “deputize” (for a lack of better word) those that don’t think in their box. They either become dissidents who are thrust from society, or they are hailed as experts for proving their way of thinking with physical evidence. Those that simply think with no box at all are left for the crows. Because to them, if you don’t have a direction to point your thinking, then you’re insane.
    1
  42. 7:52 The arguments from Christianity are faith based, but not on blind faith like the post-modern people do. We have faith based on evidence, not in spite of it.
    1
  43. Can you do Secular World 🙂
    1
  44. Very simple to understand. 1) Money no longer align on gold. 2) Peoples are getting broke. 3) Print money like crazy. 4) Price go up. 5) Peoples are even more broke. SurprisePikachu.jpg
    1
  45. Whatifalthist vid: Homer Simpson reference- The loss of religion- Too many incels- The decline of the nuclear family- The end is nigh- Gotta love it!
    1
  46. These hoes wanna be for the streets; they ain’t never heard about the tragedy of the commons
    1
  47. 20 year old sigma male giving sage advice to ceo's and politicians i love it
    1
  48. The zombie mice that only come out at night? Literally me.
    1
  49. As a sociology degree holder, wholeheartedly agree. When they abandoned Structural Functionalism for the Marxist Conflict Theory, it became complete garbage.
    1
  50. When he says we grow closer to Providence...Rhode Island??
    1