Hearted Youtube comments on Whatifalthist (@WhatifAltHist) channel.

  1. So what I get here is that world economic history should be added to the curriculum of universities that has courses dedicated to economics and finance.
    1
  2. post modernists think reality is subjective, but value is objective (Marx's surplus value), when the oposite is true. Reality is objective and value is subjective.
    1
  3. For the new Chine's prophet scenario that Rudyard propose's I think there are two posibilty's 1. The Old Man Wanderer/Laozi/Confucius/Classical scenario Theres start to be a legend in the war-torn country of a mysterious man. Of a man, who wonders in the country-side plaged by bandits and maruders. Giving advice, spreading wisdom, helping city refuge's, smooth-talking his way from being mugged, and appeasing War Lords to stop harrassing locals. Some say he's just a legend, a Guardian Angle for fallen nation, others as re-incarnation of wise man of old times. Whatever the case is, the movement of pepole, following his example can't be ingnored. Is hope returing in this broken land? 2.Hong Xiuqan scenario A worker drone, a average Chine's man. He was nothing special, just another cog in the machine. But after suffering a mentall breakdown, after just another bad day, he woke up. Becoming a "street prophet" his message resonted with broken and defeted sipirit of the pepole, he understanded ther pain and his fiery words rekindle the hope and give a promise, determination that "Yes you can and desreve more in this life!" Of course the Party didnt like that there is something different than there vision, so decided to "give him more in the other life". But it was to late. To the pepole he was the next day, a beautyfull sunshine, a new home. He give them taste of hope and it was to good to give up. His arrest was a spark, and desperation of followers his fule. It was a fire storm entire, country was thrown into chaos, strike's, riots, brutal pacyfication. But then it happend. A group of his undercover followers tried to free him. And in the mostly improvised escape he died. The rage was insane, a human tsunami of grief. He was the one who give them will to live, and they will show theses demons, whow much it hurts.
    1
  4. I like that people watch this channel for some sort of enlightenment or affirmation. However, I know that the Whatifalthist guy is a Philadelphian, and as a Philadelphian it is his conviction--no his creed--to inform strangers on the internet that their "lives suck" Go Birds
    1
  5. Not only did Jefferson and Adam's die on the same day, it was also July 4th!
    1
  6. VaCHYNA
    1
  7. Wow, just wow. What an insightful and informative video, as always! This is like your Magnun Opus of sorts, since it's very well crafted and treats the subject fairly and from many angles. My favourite parts are where you explain something that I have thought seems off (like Cancel Culture or Environmentalism being part of social justice) and things that I've thought about myself and you confirm (like the aftermath of Social Justice being worse than Social Justice itself). But overall a great video!
    1
  8. Between 1700 and 1900, groundbreaking scholarship overturned nearly every foundational idea in western civilization, and it continues to be shouted from the rooftops to this day. Since 1900 to the present, groundbreaking scholarship has shown that pretty much all scholarship between 1700 and 1900 was completely wrong, often entirely made up, and the pre-modern understanding was actually pretty solid. And what do we hear about this? Crickets.
    1
  9. How are you able to juggle the work of being historian, business man, geopolitics analyst, therapy consultant, and a YouTuber Dude either drank the grind style juice, or is a fucking work hog
    1
  10. What an amazing video from a 20 year old
    1
  11. hey dude when are you gonna make a full video about facisism
    1
  12. I like listening to whatifalthist at work because he always makes me forget that im actually just painting a wall because he challenges my world views and makes me think about things differently
    1
  13. I think the most poignant take is genz would rather fight the ruling class at home than Iran. And frankly they wouldn't be wrong. Everyday the ruling class is actively spending their money and ruining their future and this country's future. I think you'd see balkanization of red versus blue regions/states and at that point all the red factions would need to do is cut or hold power and road infrastructure and watch the cities tear themselves apart. In short I'll be laughing if they try the draft it will be the ruling classes suicide at that point.
    1
  14. ok so..... GIANTS? 🧐🧐
    1
  15. Great video. Dont stop going down this rabbit hole. Youll discover this is only the head. It extends to all sectors and industries from politics, health, education, law, tech, media, entertainment, surveillance etc..your 1984 reference is literal. Thanks smith mundt You should not blame trump for it all, look at whay laws were changed. the bias is what keeps us on this track that you clearly define. Blame him for inflation yet attribute all job growth to illegal immigrants under another administration feels biased. This is a team game against the populace. It gets dark. You made great points and i hope your generation will listen. Remember its not r vs d. Soon youll be a 'conspiracy theorist.' Cheers
    1
  16. mfw when my giant corporation that I worked 15 years to build up starts crumbling down because it isn't cool to get laid using my product anymore
    1
  17. The irony is some equate the leviathan as the embodiment of envy.
    1
  18. If they do reparations, I wonder if I can get 12% of a reparations check for being 12% black
    1
  19. Great analysis! I don't think revolution will happen in the US until 3 thing comes. 1. Working class is starving 2. Overqualified people and no job 3. Local Elites with no purpose in life rooting for the working class This is what happened in every revolution.
    1
  20. A philosophy professor & 11/12th grade high school Sunday school teacher at my church once broke down Nihlism as the dumbest belief system. It’s self defeating, if nothing exists, no belief system matters, then why does nihlism exist, why be a nihilist, how could you follow such foolishness as a system of belief?
    1
  21. One explanation for this rampaging out-of-control Leviathan (ie. the insane social justice Marxist leftist ideology rampant in society) is dysphoria and insanity from being in an evolutionary mismatch. Rudyard's "Modern Dating is Broken" video goes over how animals held captive in zoos exhibit similar behavior to modern humans living in industrialized societies (need to use drugs, masturbate excessively, depression, anxiety). Industrialized societies are a kind of captive zoo for humans, and this is causing us similar issues as these zoo animals. The "Modern Dating is Broken" video also goes over the Universe 25 experiment, where a bunch of rats were placed in a lab environment with unlimited food and water, no predatory animals, and no environmental hazards. The rats reproduced exponentially, and they started to go insane: -incel rats who can't find a mate would laze about and wallow in depression, while occasionally having violent fits of rage and attack other incel rats (similar to incel humans who do mass shootings) -Alpha male rats formed harems (similar to hookup culture) -Mother rats that don't have a male to help them raise their children, would either abandon their children or even outright murder them (thankfully doesn't seemed to have become widespread in humans) This Leviathan could be an extension of this dysphoria and insanity, partly stemming from living in the unnatural environment that is industrialized society. The Leviathan may be weak in efficacy (ie. it can't get shit done outside of Gossiping-Shaming-Rallying) but it's drive to attack and ruin certainly is not. A possible long-term solution (though probably impossible to actually implement) is to have designated family towns in rural areas. Rural areas more closely resemble humans' natural environment, and it'll better for children to grow up into adults there than in the human equivalent of a zoo or Universe 25. It could also lower the dysphoria experienced by the parents, which means they could be more likely to not get divorced and be better parents to their kids. These children who grow up in these rural towns will hopefully grow up to be well-adjusted adults who aren't as likely to become radicalized and unleash another Leviathan on society. Short-term: try to get a remote job, and move to a rural area for a time. It'll hopefully undo the Universe 25-zoo dysphoria. Basically, make yourself less crazy
    1
  22. The real mfs remember when it was 8 taboos
    1
  23.  @WhatifAltHist  FIGHTING is easy mode get them to duel with a mace and the loser gets beaten by kids at Chuck E Cheese on a sugar rush.
    1
  24. "The story of history is the story of those who choose to excel.' Incredible wisdom and advice. Yes, it's difficult to continue to choose what to teach children as the culture continues to grow and change. You are incredibly fortunate to have found your strengths and create a niche. Goodness, you have capitalism down without an econ degree. What an example you are setting for those who don't quash themselves in envy. 'It has to be competitive, energetic, rough, fact based, and driven off personal initiative.' I went to an actual one room country school for first through third grade before it closed. (1968 in South Dakota). To this day, I thought it was incredible. My class consisted of me and two girls. The female teacher was tough and used the ruler if necessary. Personal initiative is required for a contribution for success; that is extremely hard to teach. It has to be found within.
    1
  25. The problem with history is you remember stuff. Stuff others day didn't happen.
    1
  26. Hi, I am the average Bangladeshi
    1
  27. What a coincidence! I went to Malden High School at 53:08! Was it just a random picture or did you choose it for some reason?
    1
  28. BRING BACK THE SHIPPING YARD. ITS A FRIGGEN GRAVEYARD
    1
  29. My favourite days are the ones on which @Whatifalthist uploads😁😁
    1
  30. It takes more muscles to frown than it does to smile come on rudyard but that's coming from a guy who's about to check into a 6 to 8 week rehab facility in Western Virginia so if you make any videos of the next 2 months I'll catch them at the end of September
    1
  31. Well, it's really expensive to get stamps that are actually valuable, plus modern stamps are just boring barcodes so the price is only going up.
    1
  32. Intentional depopulation. Go back to your pod, eat your bugs. So happy🙃
    1
  33. For anyone out there trying to start a business Anthropology is a perfect Untapped Market to jump into. There is a giant thirst that needs to be quenched and anyone brave enough to tackle this head on will make millions while educating millions. Capitalism saves the day yet again.
    1
  34. Well uh being I live in China this is kinda scary. I hope I have time to get to the airport to get out when it happens.
    1
  35. Rudyard, I have a question - are you potentially able to sense ambient energy via your mind, like e.g. the kinetic energy of a flowing river?
    1
  36. Great video as usual. My one critique is that Rudyard seems to vacillate between viewing this as a young white male phenomenon and broad young male issue and is unsure how to resolve that tension. I think the synthesis here is that while our institutions are explicitly hostile to young white men (in rhetoric and official policy), it’s more broadly hostile to men of all ethnicities in less rhetorically explicit ways. A smart leader will recognize that young men of all ethnicities are getting f***ed over, and lead them in a united manner to take back this country.
    1
  37. Always release your episodes in the evening to piss off your assigned FBI agent who has to have a report to the boss the next day.
    1
  38. Modern day adult westerners are playing a game called science says, same rules as simon says
    1
  39. Jack Elam never won an Oscar, but he was a great character actor.
    1
  40. You should read the Malazan Book of the fallen. Just suggesting
    1
  41. I'm 19, orphaned, in debt, living at one of the most violent cities of SA. Idk what much to do but that's okay I think.
    1
  42. This video really hit with me. I see that my self assessment that "I was born in the wrong era" is more true than ever because my thought processes and beliefs fit in much more with premodern thought structures. I think that Honor, Freedom and Truth are definitely things I want to stand for. Lately, I've been trying to apply that CIA research into my life by using binaural meditation and prayer to expand my consciousness. If you had told 21 year old me that I would be practicing such things, I would have laughed and poured a beer on you. But I really feel now that as I watch society degenerate, my personal growth acts as an antithesis to that. I know there are thousands of other people who are also spurred onto to spiritual growth as a reaction to the horror of societal degeneracy and lies. I hope that this will create a counterrevolution of high consciousness and a dedication to Honor, Freedom and Truth. I'm hopeful that this will produce enough people to build something good if the Left (Hand Path) succeeds in destroying Western Civilization. And just maybe a counterrevolution will prevent the collapse and spawn a renaissance in Western Civilization with an emphasis on mutual respect and sovereignty. One can hope.
    1
  43. Do the mice wear sunglasses in the house and make the female mice do webcam?
    1
  44. I work for Boeing. In the Pacific Northwest. We don’t really build military aircraft here. I think you emphasize it too much. The only defense programs here are the Kc46 and the p8. But only half is done here and Boeing supply lines could be changed to build these in South Carolina, San Antonio, or St. Louis.
    1
  45. I have a theory that all these hippy dippy green party types with no rationality or taste for war are reincarnations of the children of adam and eve from before the fall from paradise but now that the christian church as the bride of christ has anointed large sections of the earth the people whose vibrations mirror the current level are incarnating in this new jerusalem made out of crystals to look like a dmt trip
    1
  46. It's not hard to figure out. If you remove God and religion the masses look to the state for answers. So the bureaucracy grows to replace God. It's not like it's in a Godless states interest to make the people not reliant on them.
    1
  47. Okay, but charging a machine gun is not as scary as saying to someone you like them.
    1
  48. Julius Evola once postulated 4 ages: the golden, the silver-priestly, the bronze-warrior, and the slave/kali yuga. I've theorized that they alternate between masculine and feminine, so as the masculine warrior age ends, the feminine slave age begins. I'd also add another age in between warrior and slave--the merchant. It's my idea that the anti-semism on the right is a reaction to the (now past) merchant age.
    1
  49. Whatifalthist is definitely an INTJ. Lots of SJWish behavior in this vid.
    1
  50. You people is what he means by the “right going crazy”
    1