General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About

A Vishnevsky
1420 by Daniil Orain
comments

Comments by "A Vishnevsky" (@avishnevsky7394) on "1420 by Daniil Orain" channel.

I think that it is modern version of Germany from 1940.
108
I am Ukrainian and my history teacher mentioned Kazakhstan and holodomor in it, but didn't go into details. It is shame. I think that people should push Kazakhstan government to get international recognition.
71
@maestro6458 russian propaganda claims that "Ukraine was invented by Lenin". Who invented Kazakhstan?😆😆😆
57
z-russians use old wars (Vietnam) to criticise USA and justify own aggressive war against Ukraine at the same time
49
In 2014, about 85% of russian citizens approved occupation of Crimea (according to russian independent sociology company Levada, you can read it on website of company in several languages). In fact, 85% of russians approved start of war with Ukraine in 2014 and did not notice it. Please stop wishful thinking, russians as citizens are responsible same way as russian government or russian army.
48
Absolutely true. There was no time in history before USSR when Ukraine had famine. According to my grand-grandmothers and grand-grandfathers, harvest in 1932 was quite good. Holodomor was created artificially, Red Army took all food from villages.
47
@pxelcss they really learn it, it is not a joke. Moreover, russians continue to study "alternative" history, created in soviet time by propaganda. In this "history", WW2 has nothing in common with soviet union and completely ignored till 1941.
43
@ivangohome it is her fault because she want to believe in obvious lie because truth is too horrible to accept. It is kind of sect thinking
41
@cbryce9243 it is false. In 2014 about 85% of russian citizens approved occupation of Crimea. In fact is was an approval of war with Ukraine. Consider is as modern version of Germany from 1940.
41
Because the main purpose of russian police and security services is to protect the regiment. Preventing crime is side job
38
Dude, you are not getting russian motivation! They do want to occupy every territory that was part of russian-soviet empire, it is a pure colonial point of view + years of propaganda. Just one fact. In 2014 about 85% of russian citizens approved occupation of Crimea, approved the start of war with Ukraine (according to independent russian sociology company Levada). This number remains on same level last 8 years.
35
It is totally wrong to use word "disaster" regarding artificially created mass starvation of two nations (Ukraine and Kazakhstan). It was genocide. Kazakhstan lost 20% of population, Ukraine - 12% (in absolute numbers number of died Ukrainians is bigger). By the way, you can easily see the results of this genocide on ethnicity maps of USSR before 1932 and 20-40 years after.
31
@IsomerSoma and it also explains how Germans that lived near death factories didn't notice anything. It is said that after WW2 many adult Germans denied nazi crimes and insisted that death factories were fake. By the way, same thing about soviet citizens and mass rapes (so called "night hunts") and looting committed by soviet army. Soviet WW2 didn't tell anything to anyone about the war, it was complete taboo. My grandma was "Gastarbeiter" and she didn't tell a word about it. Not sure that she told a lot to grandpa about it. She also keeped extra food supplies in her locker and didn't explain why. It was weird for me. Since spring 2022 i understand WHY she did it and now i am making food supplies too.
30
@Setinmywaysalways the thing is that video is not about USA, and we are not in 1960th. If you want to build a discussion about history, it is better to start from "Why russians are bragging about WW2 despite that fact that USSR was in alliance with Germany in 1939 - 1941 and actually started the WW2 by invading Poland together with Germany?"
29
@chemp1k you are manipulating. Does russian history book for school says "soviet union invaded Poland in 1939, according to Molotov-Ribbentrop pact, and after this both armies had a military parade in Brest" ? Does russian history book says clearly that soviet soldier and nazi soldier were allies in 1939? The whole idea behind Velikaya Otechestvennaya Voyna is to hide that one simple fact - soviet union and Germany are equally responsible for start of WW2, both countries are aggressors.
26
@wex6187 complete lie. Just compare results of censuses in USSR before and after. Ukrainians - minus 12% of population, Kazakhstan - minus 20% of population, Belarusians - gain of population, russians - gain of population. You should also take into account that Holodomor affected not only Ukraine, but also formally russian territories, populated by Ukrainians.
25
In 2014 about 85% of russian citizens approved occupation of Crimea, in fact they approved start of war with Ukraine and didn't notice it.
24
The thing is that Ukrainian oil and gas are depleted 50+ years ago, it was barbarically used by Moscow to create soviet heavy industry after WW2. One of the first gas pipelines in USSR was from Carpathian to Moscow (Dashava - Kyiv - Moscow). Although there are shelf oil and gas in Black sea and deposits of shale gas, but it is nothing comparing to russian deposits. This is pure colonial war, russian lowlifes want to prove themself as strong and modern country, that can split world in half with USA and rule on ex-soviet territory.
23
@genrikmuradyan9967 around 85% of russians approved Crimea occupation in 2014 (according to Levada surveys in 2014 - 2020). In fact they approved the start of war with Ukraine and didn't notice it, quite sure that majority of russians can't connect the dots even now.
22
Life in Moscow is good only because you take all resources from all regions, so life sucks there. Any village or small town is a shit hole, literally.
20
In 2014, about 85% of russians approved occupation of Crimea (according to independent russian sociology company Levada, they have English version of web site). In fact, they all approved start of war with Ukraine and didn't notice it. Quite sure that now at least 50% of russians will say no. They will say yes only to next questions: "Would you rather give Crimea back to Ukraine or send your son\father\husband\go yourself to fight in Ukraine on front line?"
18
@MrLebix but it is true, you need to be native russian speaker to understand. Colonialism is part of russian culture, empire is praised in school history. It hard for me to translate into English but there are two separate words to describe russian citizenship and russian as a nation. In general, russian citizens is a huge mix of nations (hundreds) with russians as dominant nation that erases languages and culture of other nations by teaching false history at school (example: Buryats "willingly asked" empire take them into! two wars are ignored) and teaching only russian language. Only few nations inside russain federation have enough schools with native language lessons. Nations in russia hate each other, national gangs or crimes of hate is common thing. By the way, russian occupants are trying to erase Ukrainian nation on occupied since 2022 territory by doing next thins: Step #1 is to crush resistance of locals (killing activists and public speakers, jails with torture chambers and russian TV broadcasting). Step #2 is raise next generations as russians (take control over school, forbid Ukrainian language, history and literature and start teaching children russian language, history and literature).
16
Non-educated people, that lives hand-to-mouth, do not care about moral aspect of war and are willing to to risk own life (propaganda says that risk is minimal) to earn 10 times bigger salary. Poverty is main factor here.
15
I saw quite funny interview with russian POW in Ukraine, he was in jail and was able to watch Ukrainian news program. This dude picked bits of information from news and created own alternative universe. Absolutely sick people.
14
@lesliefranklin1870 small addition to your words. In 2014 about 85% of russian citizens approved annexation of Crimea, in fact they approved start of war with Ukraine. The problem is not in russian leader itself, the problem is in russians who voted for president that want to conquer ex-soviet countries [former russian colonies]. This fear of russian aggression is reasonable, especially if you know russian and can understand what their officials are saying.
14
@81Heino currently you are repeating russian propaganda, mixing up things. There are facts and actions, what you are talking about is interpretation of events from goverment point of view. Very soviet and russian style.
12
@asynchronicity it never was an issue before 2014, the problem is that russians want to prove themself by capturing territories (in 2014 about 85% of russians approved occupation of Crimea, in fact they approved start of was with Ukraine).
12
Абсурд - это когда россияне (или русские) называют российский фашизм "абсурдом".
11
@the_Valinor_tourist а я подчеркиваю тот факт, что российская армия, состоящая на 99.9% из российских граждан, вторглась на территорию Украины и ведет агрессивную захватническую войну. Потому любые эвфемизмы о войне от россиян абсолютно неприемлемы, выглядят как издевательство или попытка сбросить с себя ответственность за происходящее. Что касается термина "российский фашизм" - это вполне официальный термин, который описывает устройство российского государства и взгляды его граждан (не всех, значительной части).
11
@wex6187 joke - it is alternative history, that russians are believing into. If we are talking about facts, look at ethnic map of early USSR, you will see regions with Ukrainians on modern russian territory. Kuban, for example, is historically Ukrainian territory. 100 years ago primary language on that territory was Ukrainian.
11
@wex6187 typical delusion of modern russians. For some reason existence of Ukraine and Ukrainian language was known in USSR, and there are official soviet ethnicity maps, that show Kuban in 1920-1930 as populated by Ukrainians. Lenin not just invented Ukraine, he also faked maps and forced people from Kuban to learn and sing Ukrainian songs! 😆😆😆
10
 @tatianarusmade336 yes, Lenin himself invented Ukraine😆😆😆 We already know about russian delusion and hate towards Ukraine, no need to repeated it.
10
@laza8675 you are totally wrong. First of all, Germany occupied all territory of modern Ukraine and Belarus, this two nation takes the biggest damage comparing to other soviet nations (by the way, it was the reason why Ukraine and Belarus were included into UN as separate countries despite being part of USSR). It is true about trauma due to WW2 in two generations of soviet citizens. For example, my 15 years old grandma was "gestarbater" in Germany for few years and didn't die just because she worked at farm; she was keeping hidden extra supplied of food for the whole life due to starvation during the war and after the war. But this WW2 trauma has nothing to do with modern citizens of ex-soviet countries! Generations that were born after 1960th don't have trauma!!! I personally didn't understand why my grandma is keeping food in hidden place, it was weird for me. Now I know WHY she keeped food and i will do same (russian aggression explained to me WHY extra food supplies is so important). How it is possible that modern russian citizens do have some "trauma"? The thing is that russian government intentionally use this "historical trauma" to generate hate inside russian citizens. It started in early 2000th. Now russian media can declare some country or nation as nazi and after few years of propaganda russian citizens will hate this nation and will agree to start a new war. One last thing. In 2014 about 85% of russian citizens approved occupation of Crimea, in fact it was an approval of war with Ukraine. Occupation increased popularity of russian president.
9
They do understand the language of force and will obey. The problem of modern world is that USA and Europe are not willing to use it.
9
@gergogaal568 that's typical excuse of aggression
9
Not all of them are open-minded. As usually, majority of russians prefer to say "i am a small person, i can't do anything". For example, 85% of russians approved occupation of Crimea in 2014 (according to independent russian sociology company Levada, it is available in English). In fact, they all approved start of war with Ukraine and didn't notice it.
9
@wilhelmu how about russian aggression against Georgia in 2008?
8
@TheJcrist your house is my historical territory, all your possessions belong to me.
8
@JNosewicz7569 why do you think that russian president is the only person to blame? How about russian army, that consists of russian citizens? How about russians that voted putin multiple times despite constant aggressive war?
7
It is not about oil or gas deposits or any other type of resources. They want to restore soviet union and want to occupy all former soviet countries. The plan was to capture the whole Ukraine by fast war, it failed and now russians are fighting only because russian government and military do not want to hold responsibility for failure and consequences of defeat.
7
@mcplutt in 2014 about 85% of russian citizens approved occupation of Crimea (according to russian independent sociology company Levada). People were very happy about this occupation and approval approval rate of russian president and government increased a lot. Sociologists call it "Crimea consensus" - approval and support of russian citizens of own government due to pride of government actions.
7
@arsonviburnums8453 yes, soviet occupation. USSR occupied a lot of countries. Do you know that USSR and Germany started WW2 by invading Poland as allies?
7
His son is around 20 years old and lives in EU or England.
7
@the_Valinor_tourist я где-то писал о том что все россияне являются фашистами? Нет. Это вы пытаетесь с помощью манипуляций продвигать идею "невинных жертв режима и пропаганды".
6
@emilydavison2053 in 2014 about 85% of russian citizens approved occupation of Crimea (according to independent russian sociology company Levada), in fact they approved start of war with Ukraine and didn't notice it!
6
@kostyaafanasyev8909 you also forget to mention about 146% and also mention that you, your family and all your friends are "out of politics" and never voted. This if very good theory but unfortunately russian soldiers prefer to obey and continue aggression in Ukraine. You are denying russian responsibility because being crazy and aggressive on nation level it is hard to accept.
6
@arsonviburnums8453 you are wrong. Holodomor forced villagers to join kolkhozes. Before 1932, kolkhozes were not popular among villagers. Only local drunkheads and needy people joined them (by joining kolkhoz - collective household - you will make all yours property to become shared property of the whole community, it is beneficial for people who owns nothing and very bad for people with own property). That's why villager with own property, tools and animals refused to join. As a result of Holodomor (after armed communist took all food, animals and property from every household), remaining people were forced to join kolkhozes as the only way to get some food and survive.
6
Adiagy small correction, USSR started WW2 with Germany in 1939 by invasion into Poland. In 1941 Germany invaded USSR, not in 1945. USSR is more than just russia.
5
@bobgnarley1 no, that's conspiracy theory. The real trigger is that Ukraine as country was drifting into EU, and events in 2004 showed it. Same about Georgia, russians were pissed that they are loosing influence in Georgia and decided to change government and occupy territory in 2008.
5
@sagisli that is insane conspiracy theory. If we are talking about gas and oil, the best target in the world is Venezuela. Not to mention that after Crimea russians are under sanctions and can't get modern technologies to mine oil and gas; there are way more bigger deposits inside russia; russians lost premium EU market for gas and oil, it takes no sense to fight for resources you can't sell or use. The reality is very primitive - russians invaded Ukraine due to aggressive ideology, in attempt to restore former "glory" of soviet union.
5
This video shows the level of degradation of russian society. My house was destroyed by russian shelling in March 2022, it was under russian fire in attempt to surround Kyiv. Small village north from Kyiv, right bank of Irpin river. This river played key role during battle for Kyiv, left bank was under russian occupation during one month. Bucha, Irpin (sity) and Hostomel are on the left bank of Irpin river. I left my house after 5-7 days of periodical shelling (mortars) during the shelling. Next day russian occupants killed family (4 persons) by shell. Occupants killed about 20-30 locals in my village and destroyed about 30% of houses. Information about victums is restricted during war, the community want to put memorial near church so we don't know exact number. By the way, church also was destroyed by shelling, completely. All information about the war is public and available, there are many russian speaking media that shows war as is. But russians prefer to believe russian state propaganda as is or assume that "both sides lies" (also inspired by russian state propaganda).
5
Consider it as Germany in 1942.
5
@wolfgangemmerich7552 no. Why do you think so? We had two disciplines - "History of Ukraine" and "World's history". Teacher mentioned Kazakhstan during lesson about Holodomor (as part of "History of Ukraine" lesson). "World's history" gives very brief information about important events in all countries, you can't put everything into it.
5
Translation of very accurate verse about russians: One russian man departed to kill, but was killed instead... His mother cries and whines: "What happens in the world? It is not clear why, what is the reason!" [of his death] Original: Ехал узкий убивать, а его убили... Плачет, ноет его мать: "Что ж творится в мире? Непонятно ей за что, по какой причине!"
5
There is special term for it - schizofascism, it is a mix of schizophrenia and fascism.
5
@PLTommia the "contracts" you are talking about is in reality are negotiations about shale gas, and the only reason why Ukraine started this activity is so called "gas war" - in 2005 russians were upset of first Maidan (2004) and EU-oriented government of Ukraine as a result and decided to change government in Ukraine by increasing gas price (using gas as a weapon, same way as they did in 2022 with Europe). Since 2004 russians tried to pressure Ukraine to remain in russian orbit, despite the fact that a lot of people in Ukraine (more than 50%, majority of young generation) at that time were willing to eventually join EU. Events: 1) 2004, pro-russian candidate in president of Ukraine lost due to mass protests after falsifications of elections (first Maidan). The result of this protests: re-elections, pro-russian candidate fails to win. 2) 2005, russians tries to change government in Ukraine by gas war and trading restrictions. The strategy is next: "vote for pro-russian forces and you will get a discount for gas and gasoline" 3) 2008, russian invasion into Georgia and occupation of it's territory. Motivation is the same - to replace democratic and EU-oriented government of Georgia with pro-russian marionettes (and it worked). At that time Ukraine helped Georgia with weapons for protection. 3) 2010, president election in Ukraine. Unfortunately, very corrupted pro-russian candidate becomes the president of Ukraine. 4) 2011, mass protests in russia after falsification of elections (similar to Maidan in 2004). Failed. 5) Autumn of 2013, mass protests in Ukraine agains pro-russian president Yanukovich solution not to sign required for integration with EU documents and siding with russians (second Maidan). 6) 2014, russians occupied Crimea and tried to occupy russian-speaking regions of Ukraine (east and south). Do you see anything related to "gas and oil deposits" in this chain of events? As i told you previously, it is all about russian political control over Ukraine (and other countries) in attempt of restore soviet union. In 2022, russians decided to do full-scale invasion in Ukraine after realisation in 2020 that Zelenskiy will not sign any deal with russians that harms Ukraine's national interests (and there is no chance that pro-russian politics will win during next elections). Same thing about russian aggression against Georgia in 2008.
4
@alwaysdisputin9930 you have zero understanding of situation, did you? In autumn 2022, russian army withstand Ukrainian counter-offence in Svatove direction only due to mobilization. So called "victims of russian dictatorship" prefer to fight in trenches than surrender since that time. Just a reminder, mobilized russian soldiers are so called "russian people" too. Just watch videos on this channel, russian people are explaining to you why your point of view is totally wrong. You just don't want to listen. The only category of russians who will agree with your point of view - it is so called "russian opposition", this group of people prefer to tell sweet lie in desperate attempt to participate in elections.
4
Rumours about russian ballet are exaggerated.
4
@georgine321 it is spring 2014, at that time there was zero consequences for expressing your thoughts on this topic. This fact is extremely unpleasant for russians, it proves that all russian citizens are responsible by giving positive feedback to russian government on international crime.
4
300 years is a bit of exaggeration. It is enough to say that in 1939 german army and soviet army invaded Poland, this two armies were allies and had a parade in Brest afterwards. Now russians are threating to do the same.
4
It is pure bravado, he is giving socially accepted and expected answer
3
it is kind of asking HAMAS to cooperate, the result will be the same
3
@arsonviburnums8453 Ukraine was part of USSR, it is obvious that every empire will fight with intruders to protect own colonies. After WW1, Ukrainians lost during Civil war to communists and failed to create own state. West part of Ukraine become part of Poland (till WW2, USSR and Germany started WW2 by invading Poland in 1939). During WW2, Ukraine was part of USSR and did not have own state or regular army, only rebels and partisans fight agains USSR at that time.
3
There is a russian joke about this: Morning, russian officer after heavy drinking last evening noticed that his adjutant is cleaning vomit from his uniform. Officer remembers that he vomited on himself, but don't want to look as drunkhead and says: - Damn corporal X, yesterday we had a drink and he vomit on my uniform! Adjutant smiles and answers: - Sir, he also s*it in your pants! Keep in mind that russians are always blame USA, EU, Britain or anyone else except themself.
3
@LLlAMnYP in 1917-1918 russian White movement lose to Red army due to russian imperial chauvinism. Ukraine in 1917 declared autonomy from the empire and were willing to fight against Red army but White generals rejected the idea of Ukraine as autonomous part of empire.
3
I'd like to remind you all here one interesting fact. In 2014 about 85% of russian citizens approved occupation of Crimea, approved the start of war with Ukraine (according to russian independent sociology company Levada)
3
@primrose8111 it is easy. "I am russian [as nation here, there are separate words for russians as nation and russian as citizenship]. Maksym perfectly summed up everything that is happening now. Thanks to the channel, at least i know what i am not single person who thinks that the fact of [having] war is complete absurd" I can't agree with this statement. Absurd - when russians are using word "absurd" to describe russian fascism.
2
Just one fact. In 2014 about 85% of russian citizens approved occupation of Crimea (according to russian independent sociology company Levada). It was an approval of the war with Ukraine as well.
2
@ekaterinapats5463 why do you shocked? Your aggressive country already did the same in multiple countries: Chechnya, Georgia, Syria. Killing civilians, mass rapes, tortures and executions are tradition for russian army.
2
Before the mass mobilisation the war for russian "patriots" was a nice picture in TV, a reason to be proud of mighty russia and it's army. Will see how the potential risk of being killed in Ukraine will change their point of view.
2
Old russian meme\joke: Obama personally pissed on every door in typical russian building.
2
@PLTommia nonsense. First of all, you are talking about shelf oil and gas in Black sea and deposits of shale gas. Do you know that russians do not have own technology to do that, and since 2014 sanctions forbid selling such technologies to them? Do you know that oil and gas deposits in Ukraine are nothing comparing to deposits of oil and gas on russians territory? This war is not about resources or money, the reason of this war is absolutely moronic - russians want to "restore" former glory and power of soviet union by occupying Ukraine and Belarus. And it is not a theory, russian politics and propagandists said it many times. You can find same information on this channel, old generation are re-telling official russian propaganda and very nostalgic about soviet union.
2
@macobuzi it is not true. First of all, you are talking about shelf deposits on Black see and shale gas. Since 2014 russians occupied deposits on Black see, Ukraine had no control over it. Second, almost all countries on Black see also have own deposits on the shelf. Shale gas is expensive, there are zero mines of this type in Ukraine. Not to mention that many countries in the world have shale gas deposits, including russia. Turkey, for instance, also a threat to russians business because it has oil and gas deposits in Black see and can transport it to EU. Do we expect that crazy russians will invade every country that has deposits and can sell gas and oil? Third, russians deposits are way more bigger comparing to Ukraine, including low-maintanance deposits.
2
@rolflin that's the whole point! Consider it as a primitive bully who is very dumb and cruel. The only way to deal with such type of person is to show him that he is weak and pathetic, make him to be scared instead of you.
2
@Danko003 looting is definitely a common crime in soviet army. Rapes is not described properly, it wrong to say that every soviet soldier raped someone. You comment about nations is wrong. First of all, word "russian" has two meaning in English - it is nation and citizenship. It is wrong to use word russian as nation here because during WW2 all nations of modern russia took part in war. It is also important to notice that during the war number of soldiers from east of USSR becomes bigger because of heavy losses of nations from west part of USSR. Rapes and mass executions of civilians is a way how occupants (usually primitive barbarians with low culture) show domination against enemy warriors. For example, Great Horde used this approach.
2
@yellowtunes2756 old russian proverb says "harsh rules compensated by optional obligation to follow them". Just read about "looting case" in USSR after WW2. It is said that soviet generals used separate wagons to transport loot. It is also mandatory to read memoirs of WW2 veteran Nikolaj Nikulin, he tells about rapes he personally witnessed.
2
That's wrong, there is no threat to them. It is common russian excuse. If you will push a bit majority of them they will say that they don't care about anything.
2
It is sanctions against russian aggression
2
@jopetti at least half or russians are not aware about it.
2
 @davidpaulford1980 Germany history tells us that majority of the people will not wake up even after defeat
1
It is not brainwashing, it is modern russian fascism.
1
Soviet and russian states use history to indoctrinate children with ideology.
1
No, it is not. Usually it is more about "I know that my government did something illegal or horrible and I don't care about it as long as it is beneficial for me or my country"
1
The thing is that russian top one international relations university indoctrinates russian imperialism, antisemitism and fascism.
1
There are. Very short and simplified list: 1) You should hate regular russian soldiers that are killing, robbing and reaping Ukrainians on Ukraine territory for money (loosing military mortgage is also financial motivation). 2) You should hate russian who support this war of did support Crimea occupation in 2014. 3) You should hate russian who voted for putin. 4) You should hate russian who just ignore all government level crimes of russia and says "i am not interested in politics". 5) You should hate russian who still deny existing of russian imperialism and it's crimes. Quite a list, don't you think so? How many items do you match? PS Thank you and all russians, you "liberated" me by burning my brand new house in Kyiv region this spring.
1
@whatever1661 For old women - yes, at least he tried to look so. You need to know few things: it was his strategy since 2000 (that funny photo on horse without t-shirt) + women 40plus is a huge group that constantly watch TV and vote + their husbands are often drunkheads, in jail or dead
1
@vaxrvaxr they admitting the fact of war, it is true. The main issue with russians is that they have zero accountability and blame single person - russian president - for the war.
1
Welcome to russian fascism with it's cult of leader.
1
@SuperEdge67 sorry, but you are spreading modern russian fakes about WW2 history. During WW2 ALL nations of USSR lost people during war. Ukrainians and Belarusians nations lost more people among rest of soviet nations (including russians). Since 2000th russian propaganda tries to re-write history and instead of word "soviet" uses word "russian".
1
@starbase218 there are many reports that conforms force deportation of Ukrainians into russia (putin is blamed in stealing children) and filtration camps.
1
@rorychivers8769 it is absolutely delusion to say "putin's mistake" instead of "russian aggression". This channel proves that russians support the war
1
Of course they will say "no". The idea of russian superiority is based on russian language, culture and history.
1
@kaoskronostyche9939 great example of russian war crimes and aggression justification. Adequate people in "free" countries change own government by voting, yet russians prefer not to vote at all (because "the result is known") or vote for same person all the time.
1
They will reject any information that debunks russian propaganda. The number one thing that russian media is telling to people is "never trust single source of information, everything is lie and propaganda".
1
@TheHesseJames this is not true. This myth was created by russian political immigrants, and it's goal is simple - "tell sweet lie to russians in attempt to gain support". For example, in 2014 about 85% of russian citizens approved russian occupation of Crimea (you can check this information yourself, independent russian sociology company Levada has website with English version). In fact, up to 85% of russians approved start of war with Ukraine in 2014 and did not notice it. Please note that at that time it was absolutely safe to criticise the occupation (another beloved by russians manipulation is to use repressive law from 2022 to explain events in 2014) and poll had neutral "I don't care\hard to tell" option. By the way, do you know that a lot of countries were part of russian empire and soviet union and also expirienced this "survive-in-a-dictatorship-module" thing? Every post-soviet country has history of repressions, including repressions of national elite for just being non-russians. Yet only russians is using it as excuse of russian aggression agains other countries.
1
@pedros1 it is not about resources, it is about restoring soviet union. Crazy russians want to prove themself that are mighty and powerful enough to oppose USA
1
@brucewillis2 i completely disagree about gas and oil. First of all, russians want to take the control over whole Ukraine, ultimate goal is to restore soviet union. Second, they want to keep already occupied regions, because loosing previously occupied territories is weakness and can end badly for russian government. Third, in 2014, after Crimea, russians tried to occupy regions that have a lot of russian-speaking people (east and south of Ukraine). The goals were to occupy as mach as possible, to reach Moldova (read about russian occupied territory of Moldova) and cut Ukraine off the Black sea. All this three things are directly expressed by many russian politics and propagandists. And final thing. How much oil and gas deposits russains captured in 2008 in Georgia? How many oil and gas deposits are under russian control in occupied part of Moldova? Zero?
1
@Carlito84Qc no, it is you have no idea about the topic and russians in general. Example. East of Ukraine is occupied by russians since 2014. This region has some coal deposits and operating coal mines. After occupation, russians didn't invest any money into mines and eventually closed 80% of them. Why? It is good resource, few years ago it was in hight demand in China. Could you please give me at least one example of effective maining of any resource in occupied by russians region of Ukraine, Moldova or Georgia?
1
@Carlito84Qc at least i a not wearing tin foil hat. Can't say same about people who believes in conspiracy theory about "russians started war to get shelf oil and shale gas deposits". By the way, this conspiracy theories was popular 20-30 years ago about USA. At that time is was less silly, at least is capable of mining resources.
1
It is not senseless. They want to restore former empire
1
True! There is an explanation for this - it is called "doublethink"
1
@lafej7439 it is a wishful thinking, spreader by anti-war russians. In reality, 85% of russians approved occupation of Crimea in 2014 (according to Levada, independent russians sociology company). Now, at least 25% of russians want war till victory and will be offended by ANY peace. At least half of russians do approve peace but agains leaving territory of Ukraine. There is a special term for it - schizofascism.
1
@birdick1307 how about red flags with star on military technique of russian army? Why russians are using soviet names of Ukrainian cities, despite official renaming to pre-soviet? If you are good as you think, you probably know that at some moment (after Stalin become in charge) soviet union begin to incorporate symbols and practices of former empire. For example, language politics switched from liberal (it was Lenin's attempt to repel national movements for independency) to forcing russian language (as it was in empire) and repressions agains national cultural elite. Majority of russians (old generation) dream about personal expirience in soviet times (when the grass was greener and trees taller), they don't care about empire.
1
It is not a joke, it is modern nazi state
1
Oh, so you are hostages now? Could you please explain to me why did russians elected putin FOUR times?
1
@mcplutt propaganda by itself will not work, especially now with unlimited access to alternative source of information. Propaganda is effective only if it matches your hidden desires, emotions or fears. This video explains that russian aggression is based on desire to restore empire, just to be part of something "great and big" because own life of many russian citizens is miserable existence in poverty. It is also reason of mass alcoholism.
1
In 2014 about 85% of russian citizens approved occupation of Crimea (according to independent russian sociology company Levada). In fact they approved start start of war with Ukraine and didn't notice it. Many russian citizens even now, after full scale war with Ukraine, don't understand why Ukrainian don't like russians. It is a true riddle for them! Stories about "regime" is just a way to blame one person instead of the whole nation that elected this one person as president FOUR TIMES. Despite constant aggressive wars and invasions.
1
@tymateysz russian opposition tries to convince EU citizens that it is "putin's war" and russian citizens are victims of propaganda. Unfortunately it is a lie and majority of russian citizens do want to conquer other countries (and don't understand why it is bad!); russian soldiers do want to fight and kill. And russian president and his vision of russian future represents majority of russian citizens and their vision of russian future.
1
Tolstoy is known fan of the empire, antisemite and pedo. 100% russian writer
1
The core thing of russian fascism is false superiority. Starting from school, russians are told that their language, culture and history are "the greatest in the world". All close neighbours, especially small countries, considered as 0. Every nation has offensive alias or "trait". Estonians, for instance, are "slow".
1
You are totally wrong. There is no disconnect between people and politics. This phrase about separation is a doublethink approach: it allows russians to hate USA ("government") and love USA ("people") at the same time. Do you know that in 2014 about 85% of russians approved occupation of Crimea? In fact they approved start of war with Ukraine and didn't notice it. It is according to Levada - russian independent sociology company. The main reason why this war is not popular is due to it price for russians (too high). In 2008, fast and successful russian aggression against Georgia was very popular.
1
@zollen123 it is typical russian double standard. They study fake soviet-russian history that praises russian empire, consider russian culture and literature as "great" and other cultures are minor. Do you know that in russian-soviet history WW2 has own name and start from 1941 instead of 1939 to avoid initial part when USSR and Germany where allies and invaded Poland? "Educated" russians will say that it was "protection" of Poland from Germany and will deny mass execution of polish POW in USSR during WW2.
1
Helen R you also forget to mention AIDS spreading (world leadership) due to poverty and forbidden sex education due to flock of religious fanatics. it is totally wrong to say that russian president is the only person to blame. In 2014 about 85% of russian citizens approved occupation of Crimea, in fact it was approval of war with Ukraine.
1
@horzagiar88 you are missing hypocrisy! Typical russian that were caught on bank robbery will say next: "it wasn't me! USA robbed many banks 100 years ago, it is disgusting! I am against bank robbery! How USA dare to criticise me?!"😆
1
@Katushkarrrr bullshit, majority of russians DO support the war now, DID support Crimea occupation in 2014 (prologue of a war in 2022) and assault on Georgia in 2014. You are miserable nation with imperial syndrome and desire to makes others people life as miserable and bad as yours. "We didn't live well, you shouldn't even start" - that's the motto of russia.
1
Not just government, all russian citizens are responsible
1
No, it is the way how russian state propaganda "explained' occupation of Crimea in 2014. They never say that Crimea was occupied or annexed, they say next: Crimea returned home, it was decision of local people and it is "returning" because 100 years ago Crimea was part of russian empire. This language is russian "newspeak", this phrase implied that Crimea belongs to russians and in 2014 russians returned Crimea back. Same way they describe the war in Ukraine: russian state propaganda always use word "liberation" instead of "occupation".
1
@Martin-bx1et in this case russians are using own "newspeak", it is definitely not about guilt. About "gifts" - it is total nonsense and pure russian propaganda. First of all, it was political decision, based on national (majority of locals in Crimea were Ukranians at that time) and economical (Crimea was tightly coupled to Ukraine's infrastructure). Look at national identity maps at the start of 20 century. North of Crimea was populated by Ukrainians. By they, Moscow took parts of soviet Ukraine few times and joined them to russian, but for some reason it is not considered as "gifts" by russians: 1) Voronez and Belgorod are native Ukrainian territories, russians took some part of from Ukraine during soviet times and made it part of russia. 2) Krasnodar is native Ukrainian territory, locals forger own true identity due to oppression of Ukrainian language and culture. 2) After WW2, russians took part of Ukraine to create Moldova in it's current borders.
1
You are making wrong conclusion. The correct conclusion is next: "i don't want to create fascism in my country and be afraid of jail; to ensure it, i will not ignore elections and will oppose any political leader who want to rule more that two periods of time"
1
@daiseraise1200 as usually, russians prefer to deny reality using absolutely moronic "it did not happen because i personally did not seen it". I am absolutely sure that at least half of your friend, colleagues and relatives supported occupation of Crimea in 2014.
1
Ехал узкий убивать, а его убили... Плачет, ноет его мать: Что ж творится в мире? Непонятно ей за что, по какой причине! Translation: One russian man departed to kill, but was killed instead... His mother cries and whines: What happens in the world? It is not clear why, what is the reason! [of his death]
1
Aggressive war against Ukraine was unbelievable in soviet times. The problem is not in nostalgic memories, the problem is that modern russians become fascists and want to occupy ex-soviet countries to restore former union by force, that's ideology of "russkiy mir" [russian world] in nutshell
1
@Setinmywaysalways how you want to prove your point by comparing USA 60 years ago with russians right now? I sense modern russian hypocrisy here.
1
@TheBlackComedian complete nonsense, Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact proves that USSR and Germany were allies, agreed to invade Poland and actually did it! Please stop spreading soviet propaganda! It stinks!
1
@MrSkhara educate yourself properly, you can discover a lot of interesting facts about soviet union in 1939-1941. Funny fact #1: russians are bragging about WW2 without knowing the history of WW2. Funny fact #2: russians are always change topic and prefer to discuss USA.
1
Too late to worry about, it is complete mess. Even russian political emigrants (anti-war opposition) live in alternative reality and insist that only one person - putin - is to blame. In alternative reality of anti-war russians, russian army consists of clones. Zero accountability.
1
It is not loyalty, it is unmotivated superiority and pride. Keep in mind that soldiers in this video (except the man at 5:45 with alcoholic voice) have problems with speech, they are uneducated and lives hand to mouth (problems with alcohol included). There is special term in russian language for it - "social bottom".
1
Please don't call it "putin's" war. Major part of russian society DO support the war. They don't want to die at war but they pleased to news about destroyed cities in Ukraine.
1
@shooster5884 Levada, independent russian sociology company. This company was included into list of "forehein influence agents" by russian government in 2018-2020 (don't remember exact year). So please stop spreading russian propaganda about "innocent russians - hostages of russian government". This particular poll about Crimea in 2014 is valid and adequate. As i already mentioned above, the fact of total approval of Crimea occupation by russians in 2014 is extremely unpleasant for russians since 2022.
1
@shooster5884 there are two types of russian propaganda: 1) to justify russian aggressive war, it sponsored by russian government and pro-war russians; 2) to promote idea "russians are hostages and only one person - russian president - is to blame for the war" This second type of russian propaganda is spreaded by russian public speakers who oppose current russian government and don't support war. The main goal of this type of propaganda - tell russians sweet lie (instead of bitter truth) to gain political support and to avoid accountabiliy.
1
@arathortizs28445 it is lie, spread by russian political immigrants. In reality, around 85% of russians approved occupation of Crimea in 2014, in fact they approved start of war with Ukraine and didn't notice it. Right now at least 25% or russians totally against any negotiations with Ukraine, and at least another 25% of russians do support negotiations, but totally against returning even a part of occupied territory back to Ukraine.
1
@31Blaize absolutely correct! The interesting thing about russians is total denial and zero accountability: pro-war russians blames Ukraine and NATO, anti-war russians blames one person - putin. But in fact at least a half of russians are modern fascists, and this fact is totally denied by both parties.
1
It is completely wrong to believe that russian president is the only person to blame. For example, in 2014 about 85% of russians approved occupation of Crimea, in fact they all approved start of war with Ukraine (according to russian independent sociology company Levada, you can check it yourself by looking for "Levada Crimea"). The main reason why russians did not withdrawn from Ukraine is draft in autumn 2022. Do you know that drafted russians fight on the front line and sometimes off themself instead of surrendering? Does it looks like "war of one person"? Do you know at least one fact of mass surrender of the 100+ russians because they don't want to fight?
1
Many delusional russians promote idea that "russians are victims of propaganda, they are peaceful and do not want to fight". It is lie.
1
4:33 - very noticeable. It is one of the ways how russian propaganda works. One of the tactics, an effective one, it to convince people that it is all about money. Just ignore the war, you are a small man, you can't change anything, it is all about money, people are making money on war etc.
1
The thing is next: a lot of russians died in attempt to occupy Ukraine, and the only way for putin to avoid this problem is victory (or never-ending war). Otherwise russians will start asking questions. By the way, years of state propaganda turned at least 25% of russians into real fascists, they want to occupy Ukraine completely and will be offended by any peace.
1
@cristinaguine5235 you can't transform the whole country into psycopaths or nascisists. It is ideology, you are witnessing russian fascism in it's prime.
1
@wirrwarr8834 this person is being paid for writing russian propaganda in comments, just ignore him. By the way, i hope that after the war Youtube will help Ukraine to find all russian paid commentators to put them into jail due to propaganda of aggressive war.
1
@@JurgenvanGestel-vz9ls the only country in the whole world that consider so called "referendum" legit is russia. Ukraine never approved it and will not approve.
1
It is not a joke, it is literally the state of mind of russians.
1
@tatianarusmade336 very typical russian chauvinism and hypocrisy. There are less developed and more developed nations, you can't be superior and deny existence of the whole nation just because yours ancestors occupied and colonised Kazakhstan.
1
@EUGEN093 Bohdan Khemlinckyi had "Ukrayneñ Dux" in his title. Google for "Willem Hondius portrait of Bohdan Khemlinckyi", you will be able to read the whole title of Bohdan Khemlinckyi yourself. Please note that during that time the name of your country was Moskoviya. Pyotr 1 changed name of your country from Moscovia to russia in next century, so technically Ukraine as country is older that russia😆😆😆
1
@GwynBleys the word Ukraine mentioned as self-proclsimed name of the country since 1600-1700. There is gravie of Bohdan Khmelnickyi, with his title on it. Part of his title is "Ukryenen Dux", we can translate it as "king of Ukraine". Word "Ukraine" initially was "homeland" (like state) and eventually it become the name of the country. It is also important to mention that history on Ukraine starts from Kyiv and tribes around it, that formed kingdom Rus (baptised in 988). The funny thing is that modern russians insist that they are the descendants of Rus, despite the facts and common sense.
1
@wolfgangemmerich7552 first of all, if some book says "Lend Lease to russia" instead of "to USSR", the book is very questionable :) Land Lease played essential role for soviet union during WW2. We also learned about Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact, soviet invasion into Poland in 1939. In fact, there was alliance between Germany and USSR in 1939 - 1941. Soviet aggression agains Finland ("Winter War") was in book, soviet occupation of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania was brifly mentioned. I think that history books in Ukraine are more or less fine, though it makes sense to spend more time on history of East Europe.
1
@GwynBleys just an observation: russians often start conversation with lie and almost always use disrespectful and belittling words. "Belonged" instead of "was part of" is just small example of it. Bohdan Khmelnytsky was orthodox christian, and only modern russian fascists consider him Pole. Moreover, USSR considered Bohdan Khmelnytsky as person, who "united" Ukraine and russia, and officially celebrated 300 anniversary.
1
@Boo0095 you can find this information yourself by comparing official soviet census before and after. Mix of false superiority and uneducation in russians are astonishing😲😲😲
1
In 2014 about 85% of russian approved occupation of Crimea, approved start of war with Ukraine. Current war with Ukraine is pure colonial war, the goal is to re-create russian empire (some sort of soviet union version 2). Due to colonial nature of russian aggression ordinal russian citizens don't want to fight in trenches themself but do want to occupy ex-soviet countries and see own intends in other countries actions.
1
There is very cool interview of Aleksandr Levinson, known russian sociologist. He said that he and his colleges noticed very alarming thing: educated russians that are progressive part of healthy society at some moment of time become very conservative and role of education plays no role. Same things happened in first half of 20th century in Germany and Italy.
1
Armed men who came to kill you are you enemies, it is absolutely foolish to think otherwise.
1
@Muf315 it is direct consequence of russian aggressive war against Ukraine. This attacks on russians will stop only after russians military leaving Ukraine.
1
They are not scared, many russians respects this piece of sh t
1
@englishmaninrussia stop the cap!😆😆😆😆 You have not been in russia if you did not visited public toilet - hole in the ground. 25% of russian houses do not have gas heating (use coal or wood instead). Majority villagers do not have sewage and using infamoust hole in the ground, even in winter. 😆😆😆😆 You probably never been in Moscow itself, not to mention villages or small towns.
1
3:28 - Nikita implies that Ukraine's government in wrong and want this war. Zero accountability.
1
They are not, but this propaganda will fall deep and become part of their identity. New russian generation will know all the reasons why they should hate EU, USA, Ukraine etc.
1
It is not. It is absolutely paranoidal and insane, not to mention that soviet union was an ally of Germany in 1939 - 1941 and responsible for WW2. Modern russians don't know about it and deny this simple fact.
1